View Single Post
Old 18th June 2008, 09:05 PM   #18 (permalink)
Cam Banks
Rusty Sellsword
 
Cam Banks's Avatar
 
Join Date: Mar 2002
Location: SE Wisconsin, USA
Posts: 1,444
Cam Banks Goblin Sharpshooter (Lvl 2)
Send a message via AIM to Cam Banks Send a message via Yahoo to Cam Banks
Quote:
Originally Posted by HyrumOWC
IANAL, but that sounds like redefining them to me. You'd have to call them Silvanesti as the racial name, much like eladrin are eladrin and not high elves.
So then the question raised is, can you use aspects of those defined rules when designing new races? The Kagonesti are almost identical to the 4e Elf, for instance. Could I simply say "In the world of Krynn, the elven race described in the 4E Player's Handbook is known as the Kagonesti" and then carry on? Or is that redefining?

If I use some of the various eladrin traits for the Silvanesti and Qualinesti, do I have to refer back to the 4E Player's Handbook or can I reprint that information (the text under Trance, for instance)?

I see the intent behind all of this, but I am also seeing that in protecting that intent there's a confusing and nebulous area that remains unclear and counter-productive to what I believe the purpose of the SRD is (publish new campaign settings, adventures, and sourcebooks to support the core rulebooks.)

Cheers,
Cam
__________________
Designer | Managing Editor | Margaret Weis Productions
Burned-Out Mercenaries. Bad-Ass Gnomes. Haunted Swords. Ugly Heroines. Dragonlance: The Sellsword Now Available!
Cam Banks is offline   Reply With Quote