Forum

[Felon]

Originally Posted by resistor

My question is: do other non-4e-fans feel the same way? Would a D&D Saga Edition be a better 4e for you?

4e isn't awful or without redeeming qualities, but personally I think comparing SWSE to 4e is a pearls-to-swine comparison.

SWSE is an elegant refinement of 3.5e.

4e is a gross over-simplification of some 3.5e elements, trying to borrow as much from DDM design as possible.

SWSE is a rapier. 4e is a club.