Monster ENCyclopedia: Nightmare
  • Monster ENCyclopedia: Nightmare


    The nightmare is the steed of choice for all kinds of D&D villains. Black in colour with flaming hooves, it is a highly intelligent creature. As it progressed through editions it gained weight and became more flammable. But is there more to the nightmare than simply being a mount for bad guys? This instalment of the Monster ENCyclopedia takes a closer look at this evil equine to find out.

    Monster ENCyclopedia: Nightmare

    This is a series of posts about specific monsters from D&D's history. Each entry takes a look at the origin of one D&D creature, and tracks its appearances and evolution across different editions. We have now reached the second half of our alphabetical tour and the "N" creature is the nightmare.

    Origins and development

    The English word "nightmare" comes to us from the Old English "mare", which is the name of an incubus or demon, often with a goblin-like appearance. This creature was said to ride on the chests of sleeping people, bringing them bad dreams, or nightmares. Despite "mare" also meaning female horse, there doesn't appear to be much historical relationship between nightmares and horses. However, there is a 1781 oil painting by Fuseli, titled The Nightmare which shows a mare crouched on a sleeping woman. The pitch-black head of a horse with unnaturally white eyes watches over the scene from the background. Could this painting perhaps be the inspiration for the horse-like creature depicted in the Monster Manual, or did Gygax create the D&D nightmare from scratch, without considering the mythological version of the "mare"?

    Whatever the inspiration for the Dungeons & Dragons version of the nightmare, the Monster Manual describes it as a gaunt and skeletal hell horse with an oversized head, a jet black coat, and a wild and rugged mane. It has red eyes, and nostrils from which orange flames protrude. Its hooves burn like embers, and sharp fangs protrude from its mouth.


    Monster Manual (1977)

    Although it doesn't specify which plane they originate from, the Monster Manual notes that nightmares are lower planar creatures often used as mounts by other evil denizens. Unsurprisingly, this has given them the alternative names of "demon horses" and "hell horses". Part of the appeal of such a mount to its rider is likely the nightmare's ability to fly and travel into the ethereal and astral planes.

    Even without a rider, a nightmare is a dangerous foe. They are ill-disposed to most forms of life, and will attack without provocation. As well as a bite attack (2-8 damage), and burning hooves (two attacks, each doing 4-10 damage), the nightmare is also able to breathe out a cloud of hot smoke which causes a -2 penalty to attacks and damage if the saving throw is unsuccessful. It has an extremely good armor class (-4), high speed (15" or 36" in flight) and 6+6 hit dice.

    Dragon #50 notes that nightmares are carnivorous, and that they particularly enjoy the meat of some lesser demons and devils (particularly manes and lemures). Failing to feed a nightmare its preferred diet may make it hostile to its owner. According to the article Arrrgh!!! in Dragon #118, nightmares have a high pain threshold, being more resilient than griffons, hippogriffs and perytons and similar to wyverns. The 1st Edition Player's Handbook notes that nightmares are not susceptible to invisibility to animals because of their high intelligence.

    Nightmares have low-key appearances in a number of 1st Edition adventures, including the drow series (D1-D3). The device of the drow House of Noquar is a bronze nightmare's head and the drow of Erelhei-Cinlu, particularly nobles, keep nightmares as steeds. The affinity of drow for these exotic mounts extends right up to Lolth herself. The Stable of the Nightmare in level two of Q1: Queen of the Demonweb Pits houses Lolth's personal steed, cared for by two manes. Her nightmare is wearing horseshoes of a zephyr, which, given that these allow a steed to travel without touching the ground, seems a little redundant for a flying mount.

    Inside one of the burial mounds of Dolem Moor in C5: The Bane of Llywelyn is a lone nightmare, and similarly, the article Grave Encounters in Dragon #114 lists nightmares as potential encounters in evil-enchanted graveyards. In C6: The Official RPGA Tournament Handbook, the nightmare residing in Keep Anelle is an aggressive individual. It viciously attacks any intruders, except, apparently, the hellcat living nearby.

    A slightly more unusual nightmare can be found in Dragon #42. The characters in the adventure The Mansion of Mad Professor Ludlow are children on a camping trip. While exploring the mansion, they may come across a motionless nightmare which only reacts if mounted by a character carrying something magical. If that happens, the nightmare animates, and returns back to hell, taking its rider with it.

    AD&D had more than one evil version of the paladin, and the nightmare is an obvious choice of potential steed for such a class. The Anti-Paladin NPC in Dragon #39 suggests a 25% chance of an anti-paladin's special warhorse being a nightmare. The arrikan, a neutral-evil paladin variant detailed in A Plethora of Paladins in Dragon #57, also has a chance to call a nightmare as a steed, but this is only 5%, and only a single replacement steed can ever be called if the first one perishes.

    For those considering the potential of nightmares as transportation, the article The Ups and Downs of Riding High in Dragon #50 looks at the suitability of the flying creatures in the Monster Manual as steeds. Nightmares are deemed to be suitable primarily for undead riders. The section on a nightmare's carrying capacity is confusing. It declares that the "semi-material" nature of the nightmare means that it can carry only undead on its back, but if it has a rider and is travelling to the ethereal plane, it can carry "up to 6,000 gp of additional weight" for some reason.

    The planar nature of the nightmare is explored only peripherally in AD&D. In Deities & Demigods, the nightmare is included on the encounter tables for both the astral and ethereal planes. It is also noted that nightmares are commonly associated with the god Hades. In The Inner Planes in Dragon #42, the nightmare is a rare encounter in the elemental planes of Earth, Water and Fire, as well as being attracted by "warps" into the negative plane.

    The Monster Manual II lists the nightmare as a very rare encounter for a typical abyssal layer. It is also very rarely encountered on the 1st, 8th and 9th layers of Hell, but merely rare on layers 2-7. Finally, the Manual of the Planes clarifies that nightmares can be found on the planes of Tarterus, Hades, and Gehenna. The encounter tables in the Manual of the Planes again confirm that nightmares are visitors to the ethereal plane (alone or in pairs), as well as the astral (in groups of up to four).

    2nd Edition

    There were some notable omissions from the first few volumes of the 2nd Edition Monstrous Compendium. As an (over-)reaction to some of the negative publicity the game had received during the 1980s, TSR decided not to include demons and devils in 2nd Edition. Predictably, all this did was annoy D&D fans, so two years into the release cycle, the lower planar denizens were restored, albeit with the offensive names "demons" and "devils" filed off and replaced with "tanar'ri" and "baatezu". Several other creatures, including the nightmare, were incidental casualties of this policy, and also had to wait until MC8: Monstrous Compendium Outer Planes Appendix was released to see print.

    Technically, the nightmare did appear in one 2nd Edition adventure before then. In A Rose for Talakara in Dungeon #25, the villain keeps a nightmare named Blackspike. Despite being a 2nd Edition adventure, the reference given for the nightmare is the 1st Edition Monster Manual. Curiously, the XP value for the nightmare differs from the 1st Edition Dungeon Masters Guide but is consistent with what would eventually appear in the Monstrous Compendium. An entry for morale -- a stat new to 2nd Edition -- is also included, but it is listed as "special" instead of the "elite (13-14)" value which eventually appeared in the Monstrous Compendium entry.


    MC8: Monstrous Compendium Outer Planes Appendix (1991)

    Other than the new XP value and the addition of morale and diet (carnivore), the statistics for the nightmare in the Monstrous Compendium Outer Planes Appendix are unchanged from those in the Monster Manual. The description, however, is greatly expanded, with the nightmare getting a full page to itself.

    We get a little bit more about their combat abilities. Their burning hooves will set combustibles on fire, and their cloud of hot smoke has a range of 10 feet and requires a save vs. paralyzation to avoid the penalty. The fact that their flight is a magical ability is spelled out, and we learn that they can understand commands from "evil riders" (why only evil riders?) and that they use "empathy" to communicate with each other, which is regrettably vague.

    In 2nd Edition, nightmares have a bit more personality than they did previously. Although they willingly serve as a mount for any mission involving evil, they now have ambitions of their own. Nightmares are compared to magical weapons with large egos -- you can never be entirely sure that they are going to do what you want them to do.

    The Monstrous Compendium Outer Planes Appendix is the first time the Gloom Meet is mentioned. This is a gathering of lower planar denizens on the plane of Hades, and takes place one per decade. Nightmares play a key role in spreading the word that the time of Gloom Meet is approaching, and the likelihood of encountering one of the creatures is higher during this time. Once the Gloom Meet begins, the nightmares announce this with a terrifying charge through the planes.

    The Monstrous Compendium entry notes that nightmares are unrelated to horses, despite their resemblance. It also clarifies their "carnivore" diet. Although they are in the habit of eating the flesh of fallen opponents, they require neither food nor air to survive. It is suggested that they gain their strength solely through their service to evil.


    1992 Trading Cards Factory Set, card 610/750 (1992)

    The first colour picture of a nightmare -- or at least of a nightmare without a rider -- seems to be in the 1992 Trading Cards set, where it appeared on card #610. The 1993 set also included a nightmare, but we'll take a look at that in the Dragonlance section below.

    The nightmare was reprinted in the Monstrous Manual. Other than a new (colour) picture, the entry is the same as the one in in the Monstrous Compendium Outer Planes Appendix.


    Monstrous Manual (1993)

    The 2nd Edition emphasis on nightmares with more personality continued in the Deck of Encounters, Set Two. One of the encounters in the set is with a nightmare who was summoned by an ambitious wizard's apprentice to slay his master. This did not turn out well for the apprentice, as it rebelled against his control and killed him. In another encounter in the same set, a nightmare has no qualms about abandoning her rider if the battle goes against him.

    There isn't much additional lore on nightmares in other generic 2nd Edition products, although as we'll see below, they have a significant presence in some of the many campaign settings. We get a brief mention in the article The Demiplane of Shadow in Dragon #213, which includes nightmares on that plane's encounter list, and in the The Complete Book of Necromancers it is noted that a necromancer would need to be at least 18th-level to attract a nightmare as a familiar.

    Finally, during the 2nd Edition era, TSR produced the Spellfire collectable card game. The nightmare featured on card #76 of the Birthright expansion, but the card simply recycled the artwork from the Monstrous Manual.

    3rd Edition

    The most significant change to the nightmare in 3rd Edition is a visual one. Despite the written description making no mention of additional fire, the nightmare in the Monster Manual now has both a flaming mane and a flaming tail. It has also picked up weight, and is no longer skeletal in appearance. As we'll see, this depiction became the norm from this point forwards.


    Monster Manual (2000)

    In terms of its description and statistics, the nightmare remains remarkably similar to its earlier edition cousins. It has slightly more hit points and does a bit more damage (now split into physical and fire damage), but it has the same special abilities: flaming hooves, defensive smoke, and the ability to travel into the astral and ethereal planes. The smoke attack is now cone-shaped but extends slightly further, to 15 feet. It gives the nightmare a measure of concealment against opponent, without impeding its vision. The astral and ethereal travel abilities are specified as being the same as the equivalent spells cast by a 20th-level sorcerer.

    For the first time, there is a mention of nightmares "haunting the dreams" of those who have crossed them, but this appears to be poetic licence with the description, rather than a new ability. Although nightmare are still used as mounts by powerful evil creatures, they appear to be more reluctant to allow others to ride them than before. While mounted, they cannot fight independently unless their rider makes a successful ride check. Their carrying capacity is specified as being up to 900 pounds. The Arms and Equipment Guide lists them as "untrainable".

    The "advancement" entry indicates that some nightmares can be huge in size, with up to 18 hit dice. When the nightmare was updated for the Monster Manual v.3.5, a huge version was given its own stat block as a "cauchemar" (French for "nightmare"). The 3.5 nightmare also gained darkvision 60 ft., and its environment was amended from "any land and underground" to specify the Gray Wastes of Hades as their home.

    The line from the 2nd Edition monster statistics block indicating a creature's diet was not carried over to 3rd Edition, leading to some confusion over what nightmares eat. The vampire Lythia, in Dying of the Light in Dungeon #84 keeps two nightmares which she uses to draw her carriage. Under the seat, she keeps a leather sack filled with platinum filings which she uses to feed the pair.

    The 3rd Edition Manual of the Planes maintains nightmares as possibles encounters in the astral and ethereal planes, as well as the Tarterian Depths of Carceri, the Gray Waste of Hades, the Nine Hells of Baator and the Abyss. No specific mention is made of their presence in Gehenna, but the encounter tables imply that they can still be found throughout the lower planes.

    Just in case a player wants a nightmare PC, the article Monsters with Class in Dragon #293 suggests that the Effective Character Level (ECL) of such a character would be 10, meaning that it would be treated as ten levels higher than ordinary humanoid adventurers. This article was a preview of Savage Species but the nightmare didn't make it into that book, probably because it isn't a particularly playable race.


    Book of Challenges (2000)

    The Tome of Magic includes the fiendbinder class, which uses truenames to bind fiends and other creatures into service. The cauchemar nightmare is one of the creatures that can be bound by a fiendbinder of at least 5th level.

    In Expedition to the Demonweb Pits, the adventurers visit the planar city of Zelatar. While there, there is a possibility that they can persuade a group of cauchemar nightmares to help them navigate the city. So bored are the nightmares with acting as mounts for dignitaries and merchants, that they will co-operate with the party as long as their intention is to leave Zelatar, and provided the heroes are reasonably competent riders.

    4th Edition

    In the 4th Edition preview book Wizards Presents: Worlds and Monsters, we get both a first mention, and a first glimpse of the nightmare. There is a black and white illustration in the Shadowfell section, and it is noted that the shadar-kai capture nightmares to use as mounts, implying that the steeds have been displaced from the lower planes to inhabit a new home.


    Wizards Presents: Worlds and Monsters (2008)

    The depicted nightmare is both heavily armored and heavy. There is nothing remotely skeletal about this beast, and it has extensive ornate barding covering its legs, head and neck. This is likely magical barding because it appears to cling to the nightmare despite no visible straps or means of attachment.

    The nightmare which appeared in the Monster Manual a few months later is not armored, but retains the well-defined muscular appearance. It is also the most flame-engulfed version we've seen so far, with fire now leaping out from the nightmare's head and torso. In death, these flames go out, and its mane and tail turn to ash.

    Mechanically, this is a simpler beast. It can no longer shift between planes, but gets a short-range teleportation ability instead, although the text notes that some particularly powerful individuals are capable of travelling to the Shadowfell. The nightmare has lost its bite and smoke breathing capabilities, and is limited to attacking with hooves. The only special attack it has is to leave a trail of fire behind it when it charges. It is able to extend its own fire resistance to a rider of sufficient power (13th level).


    Monster Manual (2008)

    Although it is still described as intelligent, its intelligence score has dropped to sub-human levels and it is incapable of communicating in any language. The nightmare seems to be back to a carnivorous diet, which could explain the dramatic weight-gain. Nightmares have a taste for human flesh.

    In theory (although not always in practice) nightmares of earlier editions were solitary creatures. These Shadowfell-dwelling versions are very much herd animals, even attacking in wolf-like packs. They get their name from the terrifying dreams experienced by survivors of their attacks. Nightmares enjoy spreading fear and terror and are known to let their targets think they have escaped, before closing back in for a kill.

    Although they are still used as mounts by powerful evil creatures, such riders must now first defeat a nightmare in combat, and give the beast a choice of service or death in order to compel it to serve as a mount. Despite this rather onerous requirement, the Adventurer's Vault includes the nightmare on a list of potential mounts for adventurers. With a price tag of a mere 25,000 gp, the nightmare compares favourably with a wyvern (21,000 gp) or a manticore (45,000 gp), and has a faster flying speed than either of them.

    Open Grave offers a slightly more powerful nightmare, Maheghoda the Black Course, ridden by the death knight ruler of a city populated by undead. Although Maheghoda is a unique creature with improved hit points, AC and attacks, it does not have any new abilities.

    The article Codex of Betrayal: Alloces in Dragon #373 mentions that the devil known as the Butcher of Nessus claims to have created the first nightmares. Although the same article also states that his claim is unlikely to be true, it acknowledges that Alloces has bred new, more potent nightmares. Quite how this lore dovetails with the nightmare's new home in the Shadowfell is unclear here, but a later article offers an explanation, as we'll see below.

    The adventure E1: Death's Reach introduces creatures called shadowclaw nightmares, but contains frustratingly little in the way of description or explanation as to what these are. They can clearly be mounted, so could be horse-like in nature. They are also large shadow beasts, like the nightmare, but unlike the nightmare, they are undead and capable of reanimating once slain. Are they relatives of the nightmare? It is impossible to tell from Death's Reach.

    A boxed set released towards the end of 4th Edition, The Shadowfell: Gloomwrought and Beyond, provides a little more detail of the shadar-kai relationship with nightmares. We learn that some shadar-kai have mastered a tactical manoeuvre where they leap from the backs of their nightmare steeds directly into combat. Svyn, the religious leader of the network of mountain caves known as Thyrin Gol, roams the Shadowfell on the back of a nightmare steed named Sear, searching out the mysteries of the plane. There are also rumours that a jet-black unicorn has seized the leadership of the herd of nightmares living in the nearby Gol Mountains.

    According to Underdark, deep within the Shadowdark a pair of nightmares is chained to the body of a purple worm, which is used as a bridge over the River Lathan, also known as the River of Souls.

    Strangely, it is the nightmare's last 4th Edition appearance that provides the most detailed version of the creature. Following on from the Essentials reboot, a number of monster update articles appeared in the online magazines. The nightmare gets a two page write-up in Dungeon #198, authored by Logan Bonner.

    Some of the earlier characteristics of nightmares are restored here. They are again described (but not illustrated) as "gaunt", and there is a nod to their plane-shifting powers as a possible explanation of their ability to teleport short distances. Nightmares are again said to be predominantly solitary, except in the Shadowfell, where they hunt in packs. The predatory nature of the creatures is emphasized -- so grisly can the deaths of their victims be, that some of them remain behind as vengeful spirits.

    The seemingly throw-away comment from the 3rd Edition Monster Manual that nightmares can invade dreams is repeated here, it seems that they somehow haunt the dreams of survivors of their attacks, as well as appearing in dreams as a foreshadowing of encounters still to come.

    The damage inflicted by the nightmare's hooves has been boosted from 1d8+6 (plus 5 fire) damage, to 2d8+7 (plus 5 fire damage), and it is given a Shroud of Smoke defensive ability, which is another tip-of-the-hat to earlier editions. All nightmares can now travel to the Shadowfell, as well as take their rider with them when teleporting.

    The discrepancy between their "lower" planar and Shadowfell habitats is addressed. The article makes it clear that in addition to the Shadowfell, there are also populations of nightmares in the Nine Hells and the Abyss. These herds are even given leaders. A stallion named Sin's Reward leads the nightmares of the Nine Hells. He wears spiked iron barding and is constantly surrounded by a cloud of black smoke and embers. Thunder of Hooves is a mare who has grown to enormous size, and mutated to grow an extra pair of legs. She rules over the herds of the Abyss by brute force.

    Although these two rulers hate each other, they meet in the Shadowfell once each year to mate and produce three exceptional foals. One of these offspring remains on the Shadowfell, while the other two return to the home planes of each of their parents. The article suggests that these two rulers were originally servants of Vecna, but have been corrupted by their home planes, and that Vecna now plots their demise. The article finishes with a mention of the legendary Gloom Meet and the role that nightmare play in announcing this planar event. It is said that one way to find the location of the Gloom Meet is to follow the trail of scorched hoof prints.

    This update does a good job of blending in traditional elements of nightmare lore, and it is a pity that it was published so late in the 4th Edition life-cycle. The 4th Edition Monster Manual would have been greatly improved by entries of this quality.

    5th Edition

    The 4th Edition of D&D is sometime viewed as the red-headed step-child, and 5th Edition a welcome return to the more classic lore of earlier editions. While this is often true, the 5th Edition nightmare (found in the latest Monster Manual) has more in common with its most recent sibling than any of its earlier cousins.

    Now officially classified as a "fiend", a nightmare can attack only with its hooves. It lacks a bite attack and does not produce any form of smoke cloud. It has a fiery mane and tail, as well as the standard hooves wreathed in flames. It no longer creates a flaming path behind it, but it does burn brightly enough to illuminate the area around it.


    Monster Manual (2014)

    Looking at the illustration, you'd be unlikely to use the words "skeletal" or "gaunt" to describe this beast. Nightmares remain willing to serve as steeds for exceptionally evil riders, but they require a sacrifice before they exhibit any level of loyalty to the creatures they serve. A nightmare's red eyes glow with malevolence. It is completely immune to fire, and grants fire resistance to any rider.

    This nightmare cannot teleport like the 4th Edition version, but it has regained the ability to move to and from the Ethereal Plane, taking up to three willing creatures with it. It cannot travel into the Astral Plane. It is has recovered some intelligence, comparable to a typical human, and can understand three languages (Abyssal, Common and Infernal), but cannot speak.

    The most notable change to the 5th Edition nightmare is the introduction of a completely new origin story. Nightmares are now created by removing the wings of a pegasus and transforming the noble creature to evil using dark magic. This lore comes out of left-field, and seems a little impractical. Once created, can nightmares breed with each other? If not, then who has been going to all the trouble of capturing pegasi to turn into nightmares? And to what end?

    Ultimately, the 5th Edition nightmare is rather disappointing. It is mechanically rather boring, and what little lore is included in the Monster Manual is at odds with most of what we know about the creatures from previous editions.

    Nightmare variations and relatives

    It seems that there are creatures very similar to nightmares, but which are not evil. In Setting Saintly Standards in Dragon #79, St. Bane the Scourger (a good saint, not to be confused with other D&D Banes) rides a white beast sharing the characteristics of a nightmare, but which is neutral good in alignment.

    There is a similar white nightmare in The Dancing Hut of Baba Yaga, which glows "brilliant white like the sun". This is the steed of Light, one of the personifications of primal energy that Baba Yaga has captured as part of her plan to permanently evade death. When mounted by Light, the nightmare becomes insubstantial. Darkness (Light's counterpart) also has a nightmare which becomes insubstantial when ridden. This steed is the traditional inky black, but its coat is so dark that it seems to absorb all light. Both of these nightmares are neutral evil.

    In Countdown to the Forgotten Realms in Dragon #277, the new champion of Zhentil Keep, Scyllua Darkhope, also rides a white nightmare. The Forgotten Realms Campaign Setting reveals the nightmare's name to be Targaraene. Although this seems to be an otherwise ordinary evil nightmare, its coat is not the only strangely coloured part of it. Both its eyes and hooves are imbued with blue flames. Unfortunately, by the time Darkhope and Targaraene make their final stand in the adventure Shadowdale: The Scouring of the Land, this detail has been forgotten, and the illustration shows a white nightmare with yellow flames.


    Darkhope's Fall, Shadowdale: The Scouring of the Land (2007)

    The black unicorn (detailed in Unique Unicorns in Dragon #190) is also sometimes called a nightmare, but isn't a direct relative of the true nightmare. Similarly, the article Destriers of the Planes in Dragon #243 details nine magical steeds with planar origins, one associated with each alignment. Although none of them are noted as related to nightmares, the charnalbalk is an emaciated, coal-black equine with smouldering eyes, native to the Abyss, and some sort of common ancestry with the nightmare seems quite plausible.


    Lesser Nightmare, Planar Handbook (2004)

    The Planar Handbook details a lesser nightmare. This isn't the undead Mystaran creature we'll get to a little later, but simply a slightly less powerful version of a normal nightmare. The ability to travel the planes has been removed and replaced with the ability to always know where true north is. This has to rank near the top of a list of monster abilities least likely to ever to be relevant during a D&D game. The entry for the lesser nightmare includes a section on using it as a mount/servant for a blackguard. It's hard to view this uninspiring variation as anything other than an excuse to water down an ordinary nightmare to make it more balanced for use as player character's mount.

    The Plane Below: Secrets of the Elemental Chaos mentions flame steeds, which are nightmares originating in the elemental plane of fire instead of the Shadowfell. These steeds serve efreets and fire giants.

    Nightmares and gods

    Although nightmares do not have a deity of their own, they are associated with a number of gods. The original Deities & Demigods mentions their link to the god Hades, and Welcome to Hades in Dragon #113 notes that Hades' chariot is drawn by four nightmares, who are stabled on the roof of his palace.

    An article on creating a pantheon of elemental gods (in Dragon #77) suggests that nightmares would be an appropriate creature to associate with the Fire God. Hypnatia, the Mistress of Dream, from Dreamlands: Variant Planes of Dreams in Dragon #287, is said to have thousands of children who tame nightmares.

    Complete Divine lists cauchemar nightmares as allies of Nerull, and ordinary nightmares as allies of Vecna. The Master of the Hunt (a lesser god from Dragon #342) counts nightmares as his allies, and his herald, Herne the Hunter, also rides one.

    Nightmares and other monsters

    Right out of the gate, the Monster Manual emphasises the role of the nightmare as a steed for D&D's traditional bad guys. Demons, devils, night hags, spectres, vampires and liches are are all given as example of creatures who use nightmares as mounts.

    New Denizens of Devildom in Dragon #75 details a number of new arch-devils. Bathym (a Duke of Hell) rides a nightmare into battle, while Alocer (another Duke) considers his nightmare as suitable for travel about his estates, as well as when going to war. The arch-devil Mammon rides a nightmare of largest size. He is still riding it in 1999's Guide to Hell.


    Mammon on Nightmare, Guide to Hell (1999)

    When encountered in OP1: Tales of the Outer Planes, Asmodeus is riding a nightmare. Nine Hells Revisited in Dragon #91 notes that devils appoint intermediaries (dark nagas, hell cats, imps, and the like) to command nightmares on their behalf. The same article notes that nightmares (and other mounts), are difficult to transport on the River Styx. They must be blindfolded and made to lie down, and the charonadaemons will charge a triple fare for the required space.


    Manual of the Planes (2001)

    Narzugon devils are probably the fiends most associated with the nightmare. First introduced in the 3rd Edition Manual of the Planes, they are consistently depicted astride the evil equines. They have mastered the art of mounted combat, and tend to be protective of their steeds, withdrawing from combat if their nightmares becomes seriously injured.


    Fiendish Codex II: Tyrants of the Nine Hells (2006)

    In 4th Edition, narzugons are known as hell knights, and are servants of Asmodeus. The illustration in the Monster Manual 3 shows one riding a somewhat skeletal nightmare, a rarity for later edition artwork.


    Monster Manual 3 (2010)

    Other fiends have also been known to use nightmares as mounts, including mezzodaemons (Dragon #113) and succubi (Fiendish Codex I).

    Another creature with a strong link to nightmares is the hag. The annis hag Vyedma uses a nightmare as a steed in I8: Ravager of Time as does Nuala, the resurrected sorceress who is one of the main protagonists of the adventure. Nuala also has a Leomund's secret chest which is guarded by a nightmare. If the recalling chest is used to return the secret chest by anyone other than Nuala, the nightmare appears and attacks. It retreats to the ethereal plane once seriously wounded.

    The Monster Manual v.3.5 mentions that night hags ride nightmares, and they are depicted together in the The Ecology of Night Hags in Dragon #324.


    Night hags with nightmare, Dragon #324 (2004)

    One of the most powerful hags in D&D history was Malagarde, the Hag Countess, appointed by Asmodeus to rule over the hellish layer of Malbolge for a time. Fiendish Codex II notes that once Asmodeus's daughter Glasya took over control of Malbolge from the Hag Countess, she also tried to co-opt the hag's steed, a monstrous nightmare named Bloodcurdle. Although this steed initially pretended to accept its new mistress, it then threw Glasya into one of the Lakes of Bile. As a consequence, Bloodcurdle now faces a gruelling schedule of torments each day. He's still being tortured by Glasya in 4th Edition (Dungeon #197).

    Death knights are also closely associated with nightmares. According to the original Fiend Folio, they can summon replacements every ten years. Two of the most infamous death knights, Lord Soth and St. Kargoth, are covered under their respective settings -- Dragonlance and Greyhawk -- below.

    Perhaps because of their astral travelling ability, Githyanki have been linked to nightmares since 1st Edition. OP1: Tales of the Outer Planes includes an astral encounter with a group of githyanki knights riding huge nightmares. The description of the stables here includes piles of molten rocks and troughs of boiling lava, but it isn't clear if these are needed to care for the nightmares, or a byproduct of their residency. A Guide to the Astral Plane notes that githyanki knights tend to ride nightmares into battle only when their combat abilities are important, because the knights are faster when unmounted.


    Polyhedron #159 (2003)

    Polyhedron #159 includes a d20 mini-game which allows players to take on the role of githyanki invading a human world. One of the feats available to these characters allows them to replace their fiendish servant with a nightmare steed.

    In 4th Edition, even though nightmares can no longer travel to and from the Astral Plane, the connection to githyanki remains. They serve as steeds for high-level githyanki in several sources (Monster Manual, Dragon #377, The Plane Above: Secrets of the Astral Sea).

    Arch-fiends, hags, death knights and githyanki seem to make the most use of nightmares as mounts, but throughout D&D history, a wide variety of other creatures have ridden them. The Battlesystem Fantasy Combat Supplement mentions that drow elves may ride nightmares, and the Dungeoneer's Survival Guide expands this to races of the Underdark in general, many of which employ nightmare steeds.

    In the 3rd Edition Manual of the Planes, powerful members of the Unseelie Court ride nightmares during their Wild Hunts. Nightmares are also ridden by the banesworn, the servants of the Iron General of Chernoggar in The Plane Above: Secrets of the Astral Sea.

    Other nightmare riding creatures include shades (C6: The Official RPGA Tournament Handbook), tieflings (Dungeon #116), wights (4th Edition Monster Manual), medusas (DDEX2-04: Mayhem in the Earthspur Mines), mummy lords (DDEX3-16: Assault of Maerimydra) and in 4th Edition particularly, powerful shadar-kai (Monster Manual 2). Enemies and Allies has Strabo, a half-dragon cleric of Erythnul, riding a nightmare. Riders are not limited to medium-sized creatures. The adventure Demonblade in Dungeon #97 has a nightmare ridden by a nine-foot tall troll.

    Some creatures are fated to be mere caretakers of nightmares. The nightmares in Expedition to the Demonweb Pits are being looked after by babau demons, and appointing minor demons and devils to do this job isn't uncommon. In The Dancing Hut (Dragon #83), the three nightmares stabled in Baba Yaga's hut are watched over by four diakkas. More than 25 years later, in Dungeon #196, her nightmares are still being looked after by diakkas, although there are now only three of them.

    Slasraths, ray-like flying creatures of Gehenna (described in Planes of Conflict) seem to be about the only creatures that view nightmares as food, but then slasraths will eat almost anything. Planes of Conflict also mentions that the mighty baernaloths sometimes have nightmares as companions.

    The shadow unicorn, from Ravenloft Monstrous Compendium Appendix III: Creatures of Darkness is said to be able to speak the language of nightmares, even though nightmares are not know to speak a language of their own. Finally, the blood fiend (from City of the Spider Queen) has the ability to become a nightmare as an alternative form.

    Nightmares and magic

    Summoning nightmares

    Although it seems creatures of the lower planes can readily use nightmares as mounts, the Monstrous Compendium Outer Planes Appendix contains a rather convoluted process for Prime Material Plane residents to secure one as a mount. A wizard of at least 5th-level must start by casting a mount spell to attract the attention of the nightmare, followed by a monster summoning III spell, and then finally a wall of fog, after which a nightmare will come galloping out of the mists. Once this is done, anyone (not just the caster) can offer the nightmare oat-like flakes of platinum worth at least 200 gp in value to secure its services for 72 hours.

    Apparently, this isn't the only way to call a nightmare into the world. Labyrinth of Madness has a statue which uses a special version of monster summoning to summon various monsters, include a nightmare. In the article Pleasant Nightmares! in Dragon #186, a nightmare haunts a castle built on an ancient evil unholy spot. Its appearance can be stopped using an exorcism spell, but this only works half of the time.

    In 3rd Edition, The Book of Vile Darkness simplifies this process by having a call nightmare spell. It is a demonologist spell, but is also available to sorcerers and wizards. The summoned beast remains in service for a week, or until the caster moves more than 150 feet away from it. The catch? The material component for the spell is a soul! If a soul seems a high price to pay, the alternative summoning rules in The Summoner's Circle in Dragon #302 allow a spellcaster to expand the list of creatures summonable using summon monster V to include a nightmare with only a few days of research.

    Also worth a mention is the conjure nightmare spell from Dragon #221. This spell summons a nightmare which serves willingly as long as it is given only evil tasks to do. It will rebel if given tasks that do not have an obviously malicious purpose. The spell is quite expensive to cast, requiring 200 gp of platinum flakes. More importantly, the nightmare is not summoned from the lower planes, but from the Plane of Dreams, where it is plucked from a random sleeper's nightmares. This means that the nightmare only remains summoned until that sleeper awakens, which could prove rather inconvenient, since the caster has no control over which sleeper's dream the nightmare is plucked from.

    Nightmare parts as components

    In The Ecology of the Cockatrice in Dragon #95 mentions that the blood of a nightmare is one of several potential components required to make a liquid capable of magically preserving cockatrice tail feathers.

    The mystic rope spell (Wizard's Spell Compendium Volume III) requires a miniature rope of braided hairs from the mane of a nightmare as its material component. Accord to Ecology of the Scarecrow in Dungeon #183, hairs from a nightmare's mane are also woven into "nightmare thread" by hags. Laced with the filaments of dark dreams, this thread is used to stitch together a scarecrow and keep its spirit bound within the cloth and stuffing. If an adventurer somehow obtains some of this precious commodity, burning the thread turns him or her into a terrifying vision in the eyes of an enemy.

    In Dragon #147, hoof of a nightmare is listed as an alternate component for the illusionist's phantom steed spell. This improves the capabilities of the steed by one level. However, with a price tag of 5,000 gp per hoof, and low availability (an alchemist has only a 5% chance of having 1-4 hooves), this seems more like a business opportunity for a nightmare-hunting adventuring group than it does a viable boost for the group's illusionist. Especially since that's not the only use for the hooves. Dragon #317 expands on the optional rules for power components as a replacement for spell XP costs, mentioned in the Dungeon Master's Guide v.3.5. The hooves of a cauchemar nightmare (all four) can be used for a planar ally spell. In order for the hooves to remain useful, they must be stored in a jar filled with a special oil that allows the supernatural flames to continue burning.


    Nightmare's Hoof, Dragon #317 (2004)

    In Ringing in the Deep, a tournament adventure for GenCon 2010, the heart of a nightmare can be wielded against a cinderhoof trampler to give a number of special bonuses. The cinderhoof trampler is a minotaur variant (from the Monster Manual 3) who has eaten the heart of a nightmare in order to gain burning hooves. However, using a heart as a weapon against a minotaur seems to be something unique to this adventure.

    Nightmarish magic items

    Nightmares are the inspiration for several magic items, including some things typically found in stables. Bazaar of the Bizarre in Dragon #47 details the horseshoes of Hades. When all four are attached to the hooves of a normal horse, it is transformed into an uncooperative and likely hostile nightmare.

    The nightmare harness from Dragon #234 is a magic item made by a lich in order to summon a nightmare. It is studded with platinum and precious gems which glow with an inner fire. Once summoned, the nightmare will serve the lich indefinitely, but should the nightmare die while in service, the harness crumbles to dust.


    Nightmare Harness, Dragon #234 (1996)

    Also capable of summoning a nightmare is the darkest bridle from Dragon #244. Made of black leather studded with onyx, when cracked against the possessor's leg, the bridle summons a flying steed. The creature summoned is determined randomly, with a nightmare the least likely monster to appear. A saddle of the nightmare (detailed in Adventurer's Vault) allows the rider of a teleporting mount to travel with the steed, even if that would not normally be the case.

    There are at least two types of magical figurines which transform into nightmares. The most well-known of the two is one of the figurines of wondrous power first detailed in the 1st Edition Dungeon Masters Guide. There it is described as a "small, nearly shapeless lump of black stone" vaguely resembling a quadruped. The obsidian steed figurine becomes a nightmare upon the utterance of the command word. It will allow itself to be ridden, but should the rider be of good alignment, there is a 10% chance that he or she will be dropped off in Hades.

    Bizarrely, the description of the obsidian steed in the Dungeon Master's Guide v.3.5 makes no reference to nightmares. Instead, it says only that the steed transforms into a "fantastic mount" capable of travelling to the Astral and Ethereal Planes. The goat of travail figurine, however, becomes an enormous creature with the statistics of a nightmare. In the 5th Edition Dungeon Master's Guide the figurine is back to changing into a nightmare, but the workmanship has improved, since the illustration clearly resembles a horse.


    Obsidian Steed, Dungeon Master's Guide (2014)

    The second type of figurine is the equus, introduced in Dungeon #22. This is a magical piece of jewelry that polymorphs on command into a beast of burden. Although a nightmare is not one of the standard options for creatures into which the equus polymorphs, it is mentioned as a possibility for an evil version of the item.

    One of the four functions of a wand of darkness, first detailed in Dragon #102, is to summon a nightmare. This costs three charges. The nightmare is under the control of its summoner, and serves for 90 minutes. It can transport a rider to the Astral or Ethereal Planes. A staff of fiendish darkness (Magic of Faerūn) can be used to summon a nightmare at a cost of two charges. (This item was renamed to be a runestaff of fiendish darkness in the Magic Item Compendium.)

    The warrior Ardenor Crush, who has been reincarnated into the body of a hobgoblin, is detailed in FR15: Gold & Glory. He wears an amulet that allows him to summon a nightmare. In Marco Volo: Arrival, the malevolent artifact known as the Dragonking's Eye is in possession of transport gems that can be used to summon extra-planar allies, including a nightmare.

    Dragon #76 notes that although a potion of fire resistance is ineffective against the most powerful of devils, it does work against the magical fires produced by a nightmare. The article The Many Facets of Gems in Dragon #83 states that diamonds are supposed to provide protection from creatures like spirits, ghosts and nightmares.

    Finally, one of the many creatures into which a paddleboard of wondrous transformations can polymorph its target is a nightmare. This item is detailed in Dragon #134.

    Al-Qadim

    Nightmares are listed as appropriate monsters in the encounter tables in MC13: Monstrous Compendium Al-Qadim Appendix, and the entry for noble efreeti indicates that a typical household in the City of Brass includes 2-4 nightmares. Similarly, the article Campaign Journal: Scimitars Against the Dark in Dragon #198 lists nightmares as creatures suitable for an alternative "Dark Arabia" version of the setting.

    The ALQ4: Secrets of the Lamp boxed set provides more detail on nightmares in the City of Brass. The Sultan of the Efreet and the master of the City is Marrake al-Sidan al-Hariq ben Lazan. He is known to lavish his affections on two prized racing nightmares. He frequently bets large amounts on the two creatures, named Eversmoke and Black Onyx, and he is even rumoured to sleep in the stable with them before important races.


    ALQ4: Secrets of the Lamp (1993)

    Another efreeti noble, Miraz Amak, owns a prized racing nightmare named Steam. She is albino and thus a silvery white color. He has been hiding her from the Sultan, whom he knows would covet her. Many of the other efreet rulers in the city keep nightmares as steeds and to pull bronze chariots. Nightmares are also the chosen mounts for most of the archers in the efreet legions. Secrets of the Lamp includes a racing sequence involving this colourful cast characters, complete with rules for DMing the event. It is one of the more interesting uses of nightmares in a D&D adventure.

    Birthright

    The initial Birthright boxed set lists nightmares as creature found in Cerilia, but they don't appear in any of the published adventures or accessories for the setting. However, the Shadow World is a faerie realm that exists in parallel to Cerilia. This realm has horses made of shadowstuff which, much like nightmares, function as steeds for the denizens which dwell there. Although not explicitly related, if a shadow steed crosses from the Shadow World to Cerilia, it becomes a nightmare, at least according to Bloodspawn: Creatures of Light and Shadow.

    Dark Sun

    Although nightmares do not seem to occur naturally on the Dark Sun world of Athas, The Will and the Way indicates that they can be summoned from the lower planes using psychoportive psionic powers.

    Dragonlance

    Nightmares feature quite prominently in the Dragonlance setting by virtue of their association with Lord Soth. This is particularly true of artwork depicting the death knight, perhaps the most iconic of which is Lord Soth's Charge, painted by Larry Elmore for the 1987 Dragonlance Calendar.


    Lord Soth's Charge, 1987 Dragonlance Calendar (1987)

    Lord Soth must take quite good care of his mount, since he can only summon a new steed once per decade (DL15: Mists of Krynn). This is a restriction he appears to have inherited from the generic death knights in the Fiend Folio. By the time Dragonlance was updated to 2nd Edition with the Tales of the Lance boxed set, Soth was able to summon a new nightmare steed more frequently, every four years.

    According to DL16: World of Krynn, Soth's nightmare has the rather underwhelming name of "Moggi". Moggi and the thirteen nightmare steeds belonging to his death knight warriors are stabled near the top of the tower of Dargaard Keep, which makes sense for flying mounts. ("What is Lord Soth's nightmare's name?" would be an excellent D&D trivia question.)

    Nightmares seem to be only rarely encountered in the Dragonlance setting other than in the company of death knights. There is an encounter with a pack of ten in Book of Lairs but these are dreamwraith versions summoned into existence by a vampire.


    The Bestiary (1998)

    There was a brief period when Dragonlance used the SAGA Game Rules, instead of any edition of D&D. The monster book for this version of the setting was titled The Bestiary and contains the least fiery version of the nightmare ever published. The written description also plays down the visible flames, stating that an unobservant person might mistake it for a pure-bred horse.

    This version of the nightmare has a paralysing breath which builds up with the creature's bloodlust. The book is written largely from the perspective of Caramon Majere, so perhaps the details should be taken with a pinch of sulphur. The editor's notes for the nightmare (the editor being -- in character -- Bertrem the Aesthetic) mentions that great herds of nightmares have recently been reported in the plains of Nightlund, but since this isn't supported in any other Dragonlance sources, perhaps this is simply a case of ordinary horses being mistaken for nightmares.

    In 3rd Edition Dragonlance, nightmares are given a link to the evil god Chemosh, who occasionally rewards his servants with a nightmare steed (Bestiary of Krynn, Revised, Spectre of Sorrows). In Holy Orders of the Stars, the night hag druid herald of another evil god (Morgion) also rides a nightmare.


    1993 Trading Cards Factory Set, card 446/750 (1993)

    As noted above, the nightmare also featured as card #446 in the 1993 Collector Card set. The card carries the Dragonlance logo simply because the picture is cropped from the cover of a Dragonlance novel (The Cataclysm), published the previous year.

    Eberron

    In the Eberron setting, nightmares inhabit the Demon Wastes (Explorer's Handbook) and the valley of Ahdryatmin on the continent of Sarlona (Secrets of Sarlona). On the continent of Argonnessen, the great dragon Zenobaal keeps a herd of 101 cauchemar nightmares known as "sky-blazers" (Dragons of Eberron).

    Although Eberron has its own planar topology, distinct from the Great Wheel, nightmares remain planar inhabitants. They can be found on the plane of Lamannia, the Twilight Forest (Eberron Campaign Setting). In the adventure Whispers Behind the Door which was part of the Xen'Drik Expeditions campaign, a night hag dwelling in a pocket dimension/dreamscape rides a nightmare equipped with mithral barding.

    The adventure Greater the Fall (also part of Xen'Drik Expeditions) gives Eberron's nightmares a slightly different spin. It states that they are "drawn from the pits of Khyber itself", and if slain, they disappear into rancid mist.

    Forgotten Realms

    In Forgotten Realms lore, nightmares are usually associated with specific riders. However, they do occur in the wild in a few places, including the Daggerford area (N5: Under Illefarn), Undermountain and in the ruins of Myth Drannor (Undermountain: Stardock).

    A solitary nightmare appears on the encounter tables for Ashanath and the North County in Unapproachable East, and in Shining South, nightmares are listed on the encounter tables for Veldorn. The same source notes that the previous queen of Dambrath, Yenandra, was transformed by her daughter into a spectral guardian. She is now known as the Nightmare Queen and patrols the countryside atop her nightmare steed, which was transformed from a horse into a nightmare as part of the same ritual.

    The Zhentarim skymage prestige class from Lords of Darkness can call a flying monster, such as a nightmare, to serve as his or her personal mount. According to Power of Faerūn, nightmares are also found in the stables of the Flaming Tower, a Zhentilar military outpost on the southern edge of the Border Forest.

    One of the characters in City of the Spider Queen is a drow ghost champion of Kiaransalee by the name of Taharak. He rides a nightmare and leads a group of scouts who patrol the cavern of Maerimydra ethereally. Detailed in Serpent Kingdoms, Chassan is a death knight able to summon a nightmare as a mount. As the leader of the Ack'ta tribe of firenewts in the Peaks of Flame, he is a very unusual example of a death knight.


    Imbrar Heltharn, Champions of Ruins (2005)

    Prince-Consort Imbrar Heltharn, the fallen king of Impiltur is a powerful death knight who favours a nightmare steed. If his mount is lost, he is able to summon a replacement after a year and a day have passed. The same is true of Lord Vanrak Moonstar, another Faerūnian death knight, who resides in the level of Undermountain known as Vanrakdoom. These two are detailed in Champions of Ruin and Vanrakdoom, an adventure published online to support that book.

    In 3rd Edition, the Forgotten Realms experimented with a unique cosmology, rather than using the Great Wheel. One of the fiendish planes of this cosmology, Fury's Heart, includes nightmares among its residents. Deity Do's And Don'ts, the web enhancement for Faiths and Pantheons, associates nightmares with a number of Faerūnian deities: Cyric, Ilneval, Loviatar, and Set.

    Far to the west of Faerūn lies the continent of Returned Abeir (at least during the 4th Edition era). Dragon #376 notes that in the region referred to as the Windrise Ports there lies a volcanic mountain range known as Nightmare's Hoof, which probably indicates that nightmare are also found on this continent.

    Greyhawk

    In the Greyhawk setting, the god Incabulos has a strong association with nightmares. He often rides a huge nightmare, accompanied by six night hags who have similar mounts (World of Greyhawk).

    Dragon #88 provides some more detail of the gods of the Greyhawk setting. The goddess Syrul rides her personal nightmare Flamedevil when she travels to the Prime Material Plane. If he is slain, she can revive him after 13 days. Syrul is also sometimes accompanied by other nightmares.

    According to WGR5: Iuz the Evil, the estate of Zengrunddin in the Horned Lands is patrolled by cambion guards riding nightmares. In the Almorian Lands, Duze Szeffrin, once one of Ivid's best generals, now serves Pazrael. The demon prince has gifted him a nightmare steed capable of breathing a stinking cloud three times a day. Nightmares are also found in Lyzandred's demiplane in Crypt of Lyzandred the Mad.


    Dungeon #89 (2001)

    The adventure Headless in Dungeon #89 is set in the Crystalmist Mountains and features a powerful derro loremaster named Eldrua. Eldrua has created four simulacra of herself, each of which rides a nightmare summoned from Orcus's court in the abyss. These simulacra have been raiding the outlying regions of Sterich in order to hunt heads.

    St. Kargoth, the King of Death Knights, is first detailed in Setting Saintly Standards in Dragon #79. There he rides a glowing green chariot driven by six nightmares, each of maximum hit points. In Demogorgon's Champions in Dragon #291, St. Kargoth rides a single nightmare into battle, as does Lady Lorana Kath of Naelax, one of his offspring.

    In the Living Greyhawk adventure COR7-07: Storm Harvest, the heroes have to explore the ruined tower of a deceased evil wizard Targandor. He specialised in experimental crossbreeding of various creatures, and his notes mention that he was able to successfully crossbreed a bulette and a nightmare. The resulting monster had the abilities of a bulette, but the colour and fire of a nightmare. Indications are that the creature was sent elsewhere shortly after the conclusion of that experiment, so it is possible that it is still roaming Oerth.

    This isn't the only nightmare crossbreed appearing in the Greyhawk setting. GEO4-05: Vision of a Lighted Path features an advanced half-dragon nightmare, and VEL4-03: War of the Rings includes a half-fiend cauchemar.

    Historical settings

    HR4: A Mighty Fortress suggests that nightmares would be appropriate (but rare) creatures for an Elizabethan setting, while DMGR5: Creative Campaigning notes that they could form part of the Fomorian alliance in a campaign set in Celtic Ireland.

    The article Red Sails: Tempests on the Steppes in Dragon #290 gives advice on running a campaign set in Eastern Europe during the Dark Ages. One of the included adventure ideas includes a vampire cleric riding a nightmare.

    Kingdoms of Kalamar

    The Player's Guide to the Sovereign Lands for the Kingdoms of Kalamar setting include the restorer prestige class, which is able to select a nightmare as a monstrous steed at 5th level.

    Mystara

    The Mystaran version of the nightmare appears in AC9: Creature Catalogue and originates from that setting's Sphere of Death. The description is similar to the AD&D version, but the illustration give the nightmare a whole mouthful of fangs rather than the two oversized canines we saw in earlier artwork.


    AC9: Creature Catalogue (1986)

    These creatures have the standard fang and burning hoof attacks, as well as a smoking breath attack (here a cloud) which imposes penalties not just to attacks and damage but also to saves and armor class. Replacing the AD&D nightmare's ability to travel into the ethereal and astral planes, this version can turn invisible (including its rider) three times per day. The mere presence of a Mystaran nightmare is sufficient to instantly kill plants, insects, and small animals within thirty feet, as well as causing paralysis in creatures of 3 HD or less.

    In the early 1990s, TSR relaunched Basic D&D with the Challenger series of accessories and adventures. The adventure packaged with the DM's screen (Escape from Thunder Rift) includes the lesser nightmare as a new monster. As can be expected from the name, this is a wimpier version of the ordinary nightmare, with few hit dice, and weaker attacks. Bizarrely, the lesser nightmare is an undead creature summoned by a powerful cleric or wizard, so it takes half damage from edged weapons and can be turned.

    The planar version of the nightmare was reprinted in DMR2: Creature Catalog, but both the picture and text are recycled from the AC9: Creature Catalogue version.

    AC11: The Book of Wondrous Inventions mentions Ch'thon of the Black Arts, who rides through dimension on a nightmare named Whelm. The Savage Coast Monstrous Compendium Appendix details inheritor liches, one of whom also has a nightmare as a steed.


    In Search of the Dungeon Master (1983)

    Prior to being given D&D statistics in the Creature Catalogue, the nightmare (or rather a nightmare) gets a mention in AC1: The Shady Dragon Inn, as Warduke's steed. A strong case can be made that Warduke and company don't really fit into Mystara. They do first appear in the D&D adventure XL1: Quest for the Heartstone, but the accompanying line of toys carried "AD&D" branding, and Dungeon #105 later retroactively placed Warduke in the Greyhawk setting. Confusing things further, Warduke (and steed) appeared in an episode of the D&D cartoon series, which certainly isn't set in Mystara.

    This steed also got its own plastic figure (pictured below) as part of the LJN toy line. It is worth noting that the plastic toy seems to be the first time a nightmare was depicted with a fiery mane and tail. Perhaps the artist who painted the nightmare for the 3rd Edition Monster Manual drew inspiration from this toy?


    LJN Nightmare (1983), image from Alex Bickmore's Super Toy Archive

    While we are on the topic of the D&D Cartoon series, Venger, the main villain of the series, also rode a nightmare. It could be argued that this is pretty lazy, given that Venger has wings, but according to the Animated Series Handbook, Venger has a fly speed of a mere 30 ft., compared to the 90 ft. of his nightmare, so his choice of steed makes practical sense.


    Venger on Nightmare, image from D&D Cartoon Encyclopedia (1983)

    Planescape

    The Planescape setting narrows down the native plane of nightmares to Carceri (Planescape Campaign Setting), but they are still encountered on other planes, including Pandemonium (Planes of Chaos), the Gray Waste, and Gehenna (Planes of Conflict).

    The Planescape Monstrous Compendium Appendix reprints much of the Monstrous Compendium entry for the nightmare, along with a new, full-page colour picture. This illustration is noteworthy not only for the fairly limited amount of fire visible on the nightmare's body, but also because it shows the beast with a strangely serpentine tail.


    Planescape Monstrous Compendium Appendix (1994)

    The statistics and lore for the nightmare are unchanged from earlier 2nd Edition sources, but Planescape adds an intriguing story of what happens at the end of a nightmare's life. There is a Hill of Bone in the Gray Waste covered in the bones of generations of nightmares, and ancient individuals travel to this hill to die. Some lingering evil force remains behind in the skulls of the deceased beasts, so that the Hill continues to echo with neighs and snorts. It is said that nightmares will sometimes retrieve the bodies of their fallen kin from other planes, so that their bones can be laid to rest here.

    Planes of Conflict includes a more detailed description of the Hill of Bone. If seen from above, the entire hill resembles a horse-shaped skeleton, and a careful observer might notice that parts appear to move from time to time. Some believe that the Hill itself may one day come to life. Travellers visiting this place should be careful not to remove any of the bones. Doing so will invoke the wrath of the entire nightmare race, and the perpetrator will be hunted across the planes, until the bone is recovered.

    Given the risks of owning the remains of a nightmare, it is surprising that a nightmare skull can be purchased for a mere 100 gp, at least according to an advert for "Parts & Pieces" in Uncaged: Faces of Sigil.

    The Planescape-themed card game Blood Wars featured the nightmare in Escalation Pack 3: Powers and Proxies, but the card simply reuses the artwork from the Planescape Monstrous Compendium Appendix.

    Ravenloft

    There is a nightmare in the original I6: Ravenloft adventure, in the crypt in Strahd's castle marked "Beucephalus, The Wonder Horse. May the flowers grow ever greener where he trods (sic)". This nightmare is identified as Strahd's steed, but it isn't clear why he keeps it in a crypt. Curiously, the text in the TSR Silver Anniversary version of the adventure changes the gender of Beucephalus, but doesn't fix the incorrect verb form. It reads "...ever greener where she trods."

    In I10: Ravenloft II: The House on Gryphon Hill, Strahd again has a nightmare as a steed, and in his guise as the Creature, will ride it into battle. Nightmares are also potential random encounters on the Moors surrounding Mordentshire.

    The adventure RQ2: Thoughts of Darkness features the domain of Bluetspur. Early in the adventure, one of the protagonists, a malicious human thug going by the name of Bonespur, calls forth his pet nightmare to escape the PCs. He does this repeatedly during the course of the adventure, in a manner that seems contrived to keep him in play as a plot device.

    The domain of Nova Vaasa is known for its horses, and the best steeds in Ravenloft originate from the herds dwelling in its grassy plains. However, according to the Ravenloft Campaign Setting, some people believe that these beasts are replaced by herds of nightmares once the sun sets each day.

    During his stay in Ravenloft, Lord Soth inhabited the domain of Sithicus. He was joined there by his nightmare, who features in the adventure When Black Roses Bloom. The shadow elves of The Shadow Rift make use of nightmares for their elite troops.


    Toy Nightmares, Forged of Darkness (1996)

    Unique to Ravenloft are toy nightmares, hobby horses which transform into nightmares. These are cursed items, however, and although the summoned beast will serve for thirteen days and nights once summoned, thereafter it will turn on its master.

    The Gothic Earth Gazetteer notes that a nightmare would be an appropriate creature to use in Ravenloft's Masque of the Red Death alternative Earth campaign setting.


    Denizens of Darkness (2002)

    The 3rd Edition Ravenloft monster books Denizens of Darkness and Denizens of Dread treat the setting's nightmares as separate creatures ("dread" nightmares). Although they are slightly more powerful than other 3rd Edition nightmares, they are earthly bound, having lost the ability to fly.


    Denizens of Dread (2004)

    Finally, in Curse of Strahd, we return full circle to the nightmare steed of Strahd himself. In the latest incarnation of the classic Ravenloft adventure, Beucephalus is again male, but he is still living in the castle's crypts. At least his crypt now has an enlarged door, so that he can comfortably enter and exit his home.

    Miniatures

    There have been several nightmare miniatures produced for D&D. Ral Partha's 1987 boxed set Lord Soth's Charge has not just Lord Soth on his steed, but includes his entire entourage of twelve death knights, all similarly mounted. Curiously, the back of the box shows the flames of the nightmares painted an insipid white colour.


    Lord Soth's Charge, Ral Partha 10-566 (1987)

    Wizards of the Coast produced two nightmares as part of its pre-painted plastic minis series. The figure from the War of the Dragon Queen set was a blackguard riding a nightmare, while the following year's Desert of Desolation set included a nightmare by itself.


    Blackguard on Nightmare, D&D Miniatures: War of the Dragon Queen, #25/60, (2006)


    Nightmare, D&D Miniatures: Desert of Desolation #30 (2007)

    WizKids began producing a licensed line of pre-painted miniatures in 2014, and the Rage of Demons set included a nightmare.


    Nightmare, Icons of the Realms: Rage of Demons #31 (2015)

    Most recently, Gale Force Nine sculpted Strahd von Zarovich astride a nightmare as part of its Collector's Series of resin miniatures.


    Strahd von Zarovich on Nightmare, Gale Force Nine Collector's Series (2016)

    Computer games

    The Planescape: Torment game introduced a relative of the nightmare, a creature known as a sohmien. These are said to have been created when the last of the nightmare lords was attacked by fiends who no longer wanted to have to barter for permission to use nightmares as steeds. Where the lord's blood fell, sohmien sprang forth. They resemble misshapen horses with dead white eyes and six large spikes protruding from their necks.


    Sohmien, Dragon#262 (1999)

    In the Neverwinter MMORPG, it was possible to unlock a nightmare as a mount, both a "heavy inferno nightmare" and a "heavy mystic nightmare" version.


    Neverwinter, image from Arc Games (2013)

    Nightmare names

    Beucephalus, Black Onyx, Black Strider, Blackspike, Bloodcurdle, Bloodfire, Eversmoke, Faras, Flamedevil, Kabus, Kadis, Maheghoda, Manam, Moggi, Rusub, Sear, Sin's Reward, Steam, Targaraene, Thunder of Hooves, Yubusat, Whelm.

    Comparative statistics



    References

    Monster Manual, p74 (December 1977)
    Player's Handbook, p54-55 (June 1978)
    D1: Descent into the Depths of the Earth, p8 (September 1978)
    D2: Shrine of the Kuo-Toa, p13 (September 1978)
    D3: Vault of the Drow, p8, 17 (September 1978)
    Dungeon Masters Guide, p144, 208 (August 1979)
    Q1: Queen of the Demonweb Pits, p27 (June 1980)
    Dragon #39, "The Anti-Paladin NPC", p52, 54 (July 1980)
    Deities & Demigods, p117-118, 123 (August 1980)
    Dragon #42, "The Inner Planes", p25, 31 (October 1980)
    Dragon #42, "The Mansion of Mad Professor Ludlow", pA16 (October 1980)
    Dragon #47, "Bazaar of the Bizarre", p19 (March 1981)
    Dragon #50, "The Ups and Downs of Riding High", p49-51 (June 1981)
    Field Folio, p23 (July 1981)
    Dragon #75, "New Denizens of Devildom", p12, 24, 30 (July 1983)
    Dragon #76, "The Nine Hells: Part II", p42 (August 1983)
    Monster Manual II, p35, 95 (August 1983)
    Dragon #77, "Elemental Gods", p23 (September 1983)
    D&D Animated Series, "In Search of the Dungeon Master" (October 1983)
    I6: Ravenloft, p29-30 (October 1983)
    World of Greyhawk, A Guide to the World of Greyhawk, Volume III, p70 (October 1983)
    Dragon #79, "Setting Saintly Standards", p30 (November 1983)
    AC1: The Shady Dragon Inn, p28 (December 1983)
    Dragon #83, "The Dancing Hut", p44-45 (March 1984)
    Dragon #83, "The Many Facets of Gems
    , p13 (March 1984)
    Dragon #88, "Gods of the Suel Pantheon", p8 (August 1984)
    Dragon #91, "Nine Hells Revisited", p30, 34 (November 1984)
    C5: The Bane of Llywelyn, p6 (March 1985)
    Battlesystem Fantasy Combat Supplement, p19 (March 1985)
    Dragon #95, "The Ecology of the Cockatrice
    , p26 (March 1985)
    Dragon #102, "Nine Wands of Wonder", p32 (October 1985)
    Dragon #57, "A Plethora of Paladins", p55 (February 1986)
    I8: Ravager of Time, p19, 22-23 (April 1986)
    Dungeoneer's Survival Guide, p33 (June 1986)
    AC9: Creature Catalogue, p29-30 (September 1986)
    I10: Ravenloft II: The House on Gryphon Hill, p42 (September 1986)
    Dragon #113, "Welcome to Hades", p13-14 (September 1986)
    Dragon #114, "Grave Encounters", p23 (October 1986)
    Dragon #118, "Arrrgh!!!", p42 (February 1987)
    C6: The Official RPGA Tournament Handbook, p15, 18 (March 1987)
    1987 Dragonlance Calendar (June 1987)
    Manual of the Planes, p14, 66, 72, 104, 106, 108 (June 1987)
    N5: Under Illefarn, p22-23 (September 1987)
    AC11: The Book of Wondrous Inventions, p19, 80 (November 1987)
    Ral Partha 10-566: Lord Soth's Charge (1987)
    OP1: Tales of the Outer Planes, p42, 78 (March 1988)
    Dragon #134, "Bazaar of the Bizarre", p44 (June 1988)
    DL15: Mists of Krynn, p125 (June 1988)
    DL16: World of Krynn, p49, 55, 87 (November 1988)
    Dragon #147, "Variety, the Spice of Magic", p24-25 (July 1989)
    Dungeon #22, "Tomb it May Concern", p34 (March 1990)
    Dungeon #25, "A Rose for Talakara", p39, 58 (September 1990)
    MC8: Monstrous Compendium Outer Planes Appendix (January 1991)
    MC13: Monstrous Compendium Al-Qadim Appendix (May 1992)
    Tales of the Lance, World Book of Ansalon, p107 (June 1992)
    RQ2: Thoughts of Darkness, p12-13 (September 1992)
    1992 Trading Cards Factory Set, card 610/750 (September 1992)
    Dragon #186, "Pleasant Nightmares", p12 (October 1992)
    FR15: Gold & Glory, p19 (November 1992)
    HR4: A Mighty Fortress, p89 (November 1992)
    DMGR5: Creative Campaigning, p19 (January 1993)
    DMR1: Dungeon Master Screen, Escape from Thunder Rift, p31 (January 1993)
    Dragon #190, "Unique Unicorns", p91 (February 1993)
    DMR2: Creature Catalog, p79 (March 1993)
    WGR5: Iuz the Evil, p38 (March 1993)
    Monstrous Manual, p269 (June 1993)
    Dragon #198, "Campaign Journal: Scimitars Against the Dark", p70 (October 1993)
    ALQ4: Secrets of the Lamp, Genie Lore, p7, 22, 23, 25, and Adventure Book, p17, 20-21 (October 1993)
    Book of Lairs, p36, 94 (December 1993)
    Planescape Campaign Setting, A DM Guide to the Planes, p56 (March 1994)
    Ravenloft Campaign Setting, Domains and Denizens, p26 (May 1994)
    Deck of Encounters, Set Two (June 1994)
    Planescape Monstrous Compendium Appendix, p82-83 (June 1994)
    The Will and the Way, p48 (June 1994)
    Planes of Chaos, The Book of Chaos, p92 (July 1994)
    Ravenloft Monstrous Compendium Appendix III: Creatures of Darkness, p105 (October 1994)
    Marco Volo: Arrival, p26 (November 1994)
    Dragon #213, "The Demiplane of Shadow", p25 (January 1995)
    When Black Roses Bloom, p22 (February 1995)
    The Complete Book of Necromancers, p89 (March 1995)
    Ivid the Undying (March 1995)
    The Dancing Hut of Baba Yaga, p45 (March 1995)
    Birthright Campaign Setting, Rulebook, p89 (June 1995)
    Labyrinth of Madness, p20 (July 1995)
    Blood Wars Escalation Pack 3: Powers and Proxies, Nightmare card (August 1995)
    Dragon #221, "In Dreams", p13 (September 1995)
    The Gothic Earth Gazetteer (November 1995)
    Planes of Conflict, Liber Malevolentiae, p32, 64 (November 1995)
    Planes of Conflict, Monstrous Supplement, p25, 30 (November 1995)
    Planes of Conflict, A Player's Guide to Conflict, p30 (November 1995)
    Forged of Darkness, p42 (January 1996)
    Uncaged: Faces of Sigil, p95 (March 1996)
    Spellfire, Birthright expansion #76 (May 1996)
    Dragon #234, "Bazaar of the Bizarre", p81 (October 1996)
    A Guide to the Astral Plane, p49 (October 1996)
    Savage Coast Monstrous Compendium Appendix (1996)
    Undermountain: Stardock, p8 (January 1997)
    Dragon #243, "Destriers of the Planes", p26-34 (January 1998)
    Dragon #244, "Bazaar of the Bizarre", p78 (February 1998)
    Wizard's Spell Compendium Volume III, p608 (February 1998)
    The Shadow Rift, p98 (April 1998)
    The Bestiary, p139 (September 1998)
    Crypt of Lyzandred the Mad, p21 (October 1998)
    Dragon #262, "Creatures of Torment", p82 (August 1999)
    Ravenloft (Silver Anniversary Edition), p44 (August 1999)
    Guide to Hell, p41 (December 1999)
    Monster Manual, p140-141 (October 2000)
    Dragon #277, p38, "Countdown to the Forgotten Realms" (November 2000)
    Dungeon #84, "Dying of the Light" p84 (January 2001)
    Forgotten Realms Campaign Setting, p164 (June 2001)
    Magic of Faerūn, p150 (July 2001)
    Manual of the Planes, p53, 58, 104, 108, 115, 149, 151, 166, 167, 211 (August 2001)
    Dragon #287, "Dreamlands: Variant Planes of Dreams", p36 (September 2001)
    Enemies and Allies, p50 (October 2001)
    Lords of Darkness, p103 (October 2001)
    Dungeon #89, "Headless", p48 (November 2001)
    Dragon #290, "Red Sails: Tempests on the Steppes" p43 (December 2001)
    Bloodspawn: Creatures of Light and Shadow, p47-48, 82 (January 2002)
    Dragon #291, "Demogorgon's Champions", p90-91, 94 (January 2002)
    Dragon #293, "Monsters with Class", p55 (March 2002)
    Denizens of Darkness, p109-110 (April 2002)
    Deity Do's And Don'ts, p11-14 (May 2002)
    Book of Challenges, p93 (June 2002)
    City of the Spider Queen, p9, 67, 117 (September 2002)
    The Book of Vile Darkness, p87 (October 2002)
    Dragon #302, "The Summoner's Circle", p25-26 (November 2002)
    Arms and Equipment Guide, p86 (March 2003)
    Dungeon #97, "Demonblade", p96 (March 2003)
    Unapproachable East, p90 (May 2003)
    Dungeon #100/Polyhedron #159, "Knights of the Lich-Queen", p23, 32 (July 2003)
    Dungeon Master's Guide v.3.5, p256 (July 2003)
    Monster Manual v.3.5, p193-195 (July 2003)
    Dungeon #105, "Critical Threats: Warduke", p70 (December 2003)
    Denizens of Dread, p156 (January 2004)
    Dragon #317, "Using Power Components", p45 (March 2004)
    Bestiary of Krynn, Revised, p152 (April 2004)
    Complete Divine, p116, 118 (May 2004)
    Eberron Campaign Setting, p97 (June 2004)
    Planar Handbook, p127-128 (July 2004)
    Serpent Kingdoms, p48 (July 2004)
    Dragon #324, "The Ecology of Night Hags", p66 (October 2004)
    Shining South, p90, 105 (October 2004)
    Dungeon #116, "Asylum", p46 (November 2004)
    GEO4-05: Vision of a Lighted Path, p37 (2004)
    VEL4-03: War of the Rings, p18, 36 (2004)
    Player's Guide to Faerūn, p153 (March 2005)
    Champions of Ruin, p139-140 (May 2005)
    Spectre of Sorrows, p139, 162 (July 2005)
    Vanrakdoom, p25 (July 2005)
    Explorer's Handbook, p111 (August 2005)
    Holy Orders of the Stars, p102 (September 2005)
    Dungeon #128, "The Fireplace Level", p85 (November 2005)
    Power of Faerūn, p38 (March 2006)
    Tome of Magic, p223 (March 2006)
    Dragon #342, "Class Acts: The Wild Hunt", p91 (April 2006)
    Fiendish Codex I: Hordes of the Abyss, p144 (June 2006)
    D&D Miniatures: War of the Dragon Queen, #25/60, Blackguard on Nightmare (July 2006)
    Player's Guide to the Sovereign Lands, p91 (October 2006)
    Animated Series Handbook (December 2006)
    Fiendish Codex II: Tyrants of the Nine Hells, p64 (December 2006)
    BDK6-08: Of Ruin, Restitution, and Revival, p16 (2006)
    Secrets of Sarlona, p37 (February 2007)
    Magic Item Compendium, p179 (March 2007)
    Expedition to the Demonweb Pits, p97 (April 2007)
    Shadowdale: The Scouring of the Land, p123 (July 2007)
    Dragons of Eberron, p72 (October 2007)
    D&D Miniatures: Desert of Desolation, #30/60, Nightmare (November 2007)
    CSH-7: Whispers Behind the Door, p9 (2007)
    COR7-07: Storm Harvest, p60 (2007)
    Wizards Presents: Worlds and Monsters, p54 (January 2008)
    Monster Manual, p129, 196 (June 2008)
    Adventurer's Vault, p11, 124 (September 2008)
    Adventurer's Vault, p124 (September 2008)
    CVN-11: Greater the Fall, p12 (2008)
    Open Grave: Secrets of the Undead, p19 (January 2009)
    Dragon #373, "Codex of Betrayal: Alloces", p38, 40 (March 2009)
    E1: Death's Reach, "Adventure Book One", p8-9 (April 2009)
    Monster Manual 2, p181 (May 2009)
    Dragon #376, "Adventurers of the Realms: Tarmalune and the Windrise Ports", p48 (June 2009)
    Dragon #377, "Tu'narath, City of Death", p27 (July 2009)
    The Plane Below: Secrets of the Elemental Chaos, p69 (December 2009)
    Underdark, p130 (January 2010)
    The Plane Above: Secrets of the Astral Sea, p109, 135 (April 2010)
    Monster Manual 3, p57, 140-141 (June 2010)
    Ringing in the Deep, p13 (August 2010)
    Dungeon #183, "Ecology of the Scarecrow", p41-42 (October 2010)
    The Shadowfell: Gloomwrought and Beyond, Campaign Guide, p74; Encounter Book, p22 (May 2011)
    Dungeon #196 "Baba Yaga's Dancing Hut", p35 (November 2011)
    Dungeon #197, "Codex of Betrayal: Glasya, Princess of the Nine Hells", p8 (December 2011)
    Dungeon #198, "Monster Manual Update: Nightmare" (January 2012)
    Monster Manual, p235 (September 2014)
    Dungeon Master's Guide, p169-170 (December 2014)
    DDEX2-04: Mayhem in the Earthspur Mines, p14 (April 2015)
    Icons of the Realms: Rage of Demons, #31/55 (September 2015)
    DDEX3-16: Assault of Maerimydra, p21 (February 2016)
    Curse of Strahd, p93 (March 2016)
    Curse of Strahd: Strahd von Zarovich on Nightmare (April 2016)

    Other ENCyclopedia entries

    Visit the Monster ENCyclopedia index for links to other entries in this series.
    SaveSave
    Comments 19 Comments
    1. Lancelot's Avatar
      Lancelot -
      Terrific article as always. Quick correction: the picture for the Sohmien and the Neverwinter Nightmare near the end of the article are reversed.

      Also, one additional early appearance of the nightmare is in the Official Advanced Dungeons & Dragons Coloring Album (1979), written by Gary Gygax. For anyone unfamiliar with the book, it included a bit of additional lore written by Gary about various iconic AD&D monsters. The nightmare appeared under the entry for "Ride of the Night Hag", with the following description:

      "Cursing in fury, the lich summons his lover, the night hag, Strovolla, from the convoluted Planes of Hades. She, in turn, rides across the astral reaches to seek aid from devil or demon."

      "[Strovolla] rides a night mare, also called a demon horse or hell horse. This dreadful creature's dull black coat is adorned with mane and tail of silvery black. Eyes gleam red, and nostrils and hooves flash orange tongues of fire. Its hoovers glow like embers, and the night mare's fangs are pale yellow."

      "Formidable opponents separately, a night hag and night mare working together will cause all but the most powerful of evil creatures to shun them. The night mare is a fierce fighter with fang and hoof, snorting noxious clouds of hot vapors when in battle. [...] It is not surprising, then, that Strovolla rides unmolested to the lower planes."

      There is also a terrific picture of a night hag and night mare, of course. Google search for "nightmare dungeons coloring" should bring up some images from the original 1979 book.
    1. Hussar's Avatar
      Hussar -
      Fantastic stuff as always.
    1. Scrivener of Doom's Avatar
      Scrivener of Doom -
      Thank you again, Echohawk.

      This is simply the best series of articles on ENWorld - with daylight in second place. I hope we keep seeing more from you.
    1. Echohawk's Avatar
      Echohawk -
      Quote Originally Posted by Lancelot View Post
      Terrific article as always. Quick correction: the picture for the Sohmien and the Neverwinter Nightmare near the end of the article are reversed.
      Fixed, thanks.

      Also, one additional early appearance of the nightmare is in the Official Advanced Dungeons & Dragons Coloring Album (1979), written by Gary Gygax.
      Ooh, good catch. I think that's the second oldest nightmare illustration there is. Here's a scan directly from the book:
      Name: 1a. Nightmare (1979) - The Official AD&D Coloring Album.jpg ► Views: 2199 ► Size: 90.4 KB
    1. Desh-Rae-Halra's Avatar
      Desh-Rae-Halra -
      Good article. I was under the impression that the figure hunched over the woman in Fuseli's Nightmare was a Homunculus, with the Nightmare standing to the right. Last time I checked, we still have that piece in the Detroit Institute of the Arts.
    1. Echohawk's Avatar
      Echohawk -
      Quote Originally Posted by Desh-Rae-Halra View Post
      Good article. I was under the impression that the figure hunched over the woman in Fuseli's Nightmare was a Homunculus, with the Nightmare standing to the right.
      It could probably be described as an incubus, homunculus, goblinoid or a mare. I went with mare, because a "mare" in folklore is specifically something which rides on people's chests bringing bad dreams, and thus thematically connected to the nightmare.

      Last time I checked, we still have that piece in the Detroit Institute of the Arts.
      That's quite cool. Do you just have the original, or also some of his later versions?
    1. Ranes's Avatar
      Ranes -
      Superbly researched and structured. A splendid read, as always. Ta very much!
    1. Vienneau's Avatar
      Vienneau -
      I'm always amazed by the depth and breadth of your articles. Great stuff.
    1. Desh-Rae-Halra's Avatar
      Desh-Rae-Halra -
      Quote Originally Posted by Echohawk View Post
      It could probably be described as an incubus, homunculus, goblinoid or a mare. I went with mare, because a "mare" in folklore is specifically something which rides on people's chests bringing bad dreams, and thus thematically connected to the nightmare.


      That's quite cool. Do you just have the original, or also some of his later versions?
      We just have that one piece, but I believe it is the original. One of my absolute favorites there. I worried years ago when the city was trying to sell off the art to pay off debts/avoid bankruptcy that we would lose it, but enough art lovers stopped that. Last time I went down there, it was on loan.
    1. Richards's Avatar
      Richards -
      Another fantastic entry, Echohawk! Every day a new entry in this series in released is a good day.

      Johnathan
    1. TheSwartz's Avatar
      TheSwartz -
      You, sir, deserve an honorary PHd in D&D literature for these thesis quality works. Thanks.
    1. Polyhedral Columbia's Avatar
      Polyhedral Columbia -
      Wonderful! Thanks Ecohawk.

      Three things:
      1) Would you please add the Classic (BECMI) D&D stats to the final chart? You showed BECMI stats for other monsters.
      2) You say that Warduke's presence in Mystara is questionable because he was later (in the 3e era) affirmed to exist in Greyhawk. Well, this is one of many examples of persons or places which canonically exist in several D&D worlds at the same time. For example, the Isle of Dread officially exists in Mystara, Greyhawk, Nerath (in the Feywild), and in the Plane of Water (5e). And the Keep on the Borderland has official placements in Mystara, Greyhawk, and Nerath.

      In regard to Warduke and the other LJN Action Figures: A Mystara coin-op video game places Shady Dragon Inn in Darokin. And the action figure characters also appear in the country of Ierendi. The Kingdom of Ghyr, which is the main setting of the LJN figures is not officially placed anywhere, but it uses the BECMI ruleset, and D&D product manager Bruce Heard said that Ghyr is presumably located somewhere in Mystara.
      http://www.rpgnow.com/product/16969/...acturers_id=44

      So Warduke exists in three worlds at the same time: Mystara, Greyhawk, and The Realm of the D&D Cartoon Show.

      3) Since Hackmaster 4E was a WotC-licensed AD&D product, any chance that Hackmaster 4E / Garweeze Wurld references (or at least just the monsters which appear in the directly-licensed parody adventures) might be added to the monster encyclopedia?
    1. Echohawk's Avatar
      Echohawk -
      Quote Originally Posted by Polyhedral Columbia View Post
      1) Would you please add the Classic (BECMI) D&D stats to the final chart? You showed BECMI stats for other monsters.
      Done!

      2) Well, this is one of many examples of persons or places which canonically exist in several D&D worlds at the same time.
      I agree. Warduke is a definitely a multi-setting character now. I'm not sure he fits particularly well into any of the three settings he's appeared in, but I did think he was Mystaran enough to get included in that section of the article .

      3) Since Hackmaster 4E was a WotC-licensed AD&D product, any chance that Hackmaster 4E / Garweeze Wurld references (or at least just the monsters which appear in the directly-licensed parody adventures) might be added to the monster encyclopedia?
      I'm going to have to disappoint you here. I don't have any plans to include Hackmaster monster appearances in the Monster ENCyclopedia series, for the same reason that I'm not covering Pathfinder appearances. Neither Garweeze Wurld, nor Golarion has even been an official D&D setting, which is roughly where I've draw my line for the articles. I'm not going to rule out occasionally mentioning appearances outside of D&D canon, as I did for the flumph and regularly do for Dragonlance SAGA products, but those will be exceptions. Sorry!
    1. Polyhedral Columbia's Avatar
      Polyhedral Columbia -
      Thanks for the BECMI stats and for being understanding about Warduke.

      Quote Originally Posted by Echohawk View Post
      I'm going to have to disappoint you here. I don't have any plans to include Hackmaster monster appearances in the Monster ENCyclopedia series, for the same reason that I'm not covering Pathfinder appearances. Neither Garweeze Wurld, nor Golarion has even been an official D&D setting, which is roughly where I've draw my line for the articles. I'm not going to rule out occasionally mentioning appearances outside of D&D canon, as I did for the flumph and regularly do for Dragonlance SAGA products, but those will be exceptions. Sorry!
      I understand that you're not delving into Golarion and the vast ocean of OGL-licensed worlds. Yes, the ENCyclopedia is about the D&D-branded worlds. I agree that Garweeze Wurld is not a D&D-branded world. And though HackMaster 4E was a direct licensing agreement between WotC and Kenzer for a "parody" of the AD&D ruleset, it is still only an adaptation of the D&D rules, not the D&D brand, so I agree that Garweeze Wurld as a whole, is not fitting for the ENCyclopedia.

      However, I still wish that the few HackMaster modules which were officially licensed parodies of specific D&D adventures, would be included someday. I think those few adventure modules were produced under a separate licensing agreement, since they not only parody the AD&D ruleset (like the rest of HM4E), but also a parody of specific places and characters from the D&D worlds. They are basically a WotC-licensed parody of the D&D Multiverse:

      B1: Quest for the Unknown (2002)
      B2: Little Keep on the Borderlands (2002)
      Smackdown the Slavers (2002)
      G1-3: Annihilate the Giants (2002)
      Robinloft (December 2002)
      D1-2: Descent Into the Netherdeep (2003)
      S1: Tomb of Unspeakable Horrors (2003)
      White Doom Mountain (2003)
      T1-4: The Temple of Existential Evil (2003)
      C1: The Hidden Shrine (2003)
      C2: Demon Tower of Madness (2003)
      I2: Crypt of the Lizard King (2004)
      S4: Lost Caverns (2004)
      Robinloft 2: Tahd's Legacy (November 2004)

      Still, I understand that one must draw the line somewhere - especially if you don't own those books anyway!

      Do you, in principle, include these D&D-branded worlds?:

      1e & 2e Lankhmar
      1e Conan
      3e Kalamar
      3e Diablo
      3e Warcraft: The Roleplaying Game (not to be confused with the subsequent OGL World of Warcraft).

      Again, I understand if there's no intention to include them; since they though they use a D&D-branded ruleset, they aren't part of the D&D Multiverse.

      But there is one official D&D world which had its own product line and logo, but which almost everyone forgets -- and that is Blackmoor. The 3e-era Blackmoor books by Goodman and Zeitgeist Games were licensed by WotC, in a similar way that Margaret Weis Productions produced the licensed 3e Dragonlance line.

      Yes, there are at least four Blackmoors: 1) a few aspects of Blackmoor were incorporated into Greyhawk's Blackmoor, 2) Blackmoor existed as part of Mystara's ancient past, and 3) there is also a Blackmoor which was tied to the Judge's Guild "City State" setting, but 4) Blackmoor also existed as a distinct planet: Arneson intended to publish a distinct planetary map for Blackmoor, proving that it was considered to be a distinct world.

      If you want help with finding Blackmoor monster references, Havard at the Blackmoor Archive site might lend a hand.

      Anyway, I'm just being uber-completist - I love your work as-is.
    1. Echohawk's Avatar
      Echohawk -
      Quote Originally Posted by Polyhedral Columbia View Post
      Do you, in principle, include these D&D-branded worlds?:

      1e & 2e Lankhmar
      1e Conan
      3e Kalamar
      3e Diablo
      3e Warcraft: The Roleplaying Game (not to be confused with the subsequent OGL World of Warcraft).
      Yes. If it made sense (and I noticed), I’d include appearances from all of those settings. For example, the lamia entry includes a small section on the Hyborian Age and slightly larger section on the Kingdoms of Kalamar.

      But there is one official D&D world which had its own product line and logo, but which almost everyone forgets -- and that is Blackmoor. The 3e-era Blackmoor books by Goodman and Zeitgeist Games were licensed by WotC, in a similar way that Margaret Weis Productions produced the licensed 3e Dragonlance line.
      I have mentioned links to Blackmoor in a couple of previous entries (the hook horror and ixitxachitl), but I don’t have many of the licensed d20 Blackmoor setting products, so I doubt I’d catch monster mentions there. I’ll happily add them if anyone points out notable omissions.

      Anyway, I'm just being uber-completist - I love your work as-is.
      Thanks for the kind words, and thanks to everyone who takes the time to post messages of encouragement in these threads. It’s great to know there are folks out there who enjoy articles about D&D’s monstrous history .
    1. Cleon's Avatar
      Cleon -
      Oh great, another Monster ENCyclopedia entry!

      Hang about, Nightmare? The last entry I read was the Lamia. What happened to the "M".

      Blast it, I was too busy enjoying myself over Christmas I missed the Myconid thread.

      Oh double blast it, there are two monsters in your Myconid post that aren't on my "unconverted Creature Catalog monsters" list - the Undead Myconid and the Hanuk Arazuul. In my defence, those monsters aren't in the Echohawk Index either.


      Anyhow, wonderful work as always Echohawk.

      Did the Nightmare Lord(s) ever have any more details published beyond the backstory of the Sohmien in Dragon #262 and Planes of Torment?

      I vaguely recall seeing AD&D-style stats for a "Lord of Nightmares" somewhere, but I suspect it wasn't in an official product. Maybe one of those Mayfair Games Demons books?
    1. Echohawk's Avatar
      Echohawk -
      Quote Originally Posted by Cleon View Post
      Did the Nightmare Lord(s) ever have any more details published beyond the backstory of the Sohmien in Dragon #262 and Planes of Torment?
      Not that I've noticed. A quick search didn't turn up any other mentions of either Nightmare Lords or a Lord of Nightmares. I'm also not too familiar with Torment so I don't know if that's perhaps part of the sohmien's backstory in the game.
    1. Cleon's Avatar
      Cleon -
      Quote Originally Posted by Echohawk View Post
      Not that I've noticed. A quick search didn't turn up any other mentions of either Nightmare Lords or a Lord of Nightmares. I'm also not too familiar with Torment so I don't know if that's perhaps part of the sohmien's backstory in the game.
      Oh well, I didn't have any luck at my end either - I flicked through my Mayfair Denizens and didn't see any demon ruler for Nightmares and some internet searches weren't any more successful. There were hits for demons with power or dominion over nightmare dreams and Ravenloft's Nightmare Lands setting, but no lords for the fiendish-horsie variety.

      Oh, and this very thread is the top Google result for "D&D "lord of nightmares" horse Hades" - you're famous!

      At least that means there isn't another high-CR monster to convert for the Creature Catalog.
    1. Jhaelen -
      Great article, as usual!

      I hadn't been aware that the Nightmare is basically a Gygaxian invention. It's so ubiquitous in all kinds of fantasy settings, I'd have thought it was based in real mythology.
      I also have to dig out the 4e article on Nightmares, sounds really interesting.
    Comments Leave Comment