Pure Evil/Chaotic/Good/Lawful weapon property from D&D Online

[Shin Okada]

There are Pure *Alignment* magic weapon properties in D&D Online.

Those are +1 equivalent properties which can be only usable by a character of corresponding alignment, and inflicts +1d6 damage against creatures who does not have that alignment.

For example, "Pure Good" weapon can be only usable by CG, NG or LG characters. And it inflicts +1d6 damages against anyone who is not good.

Maybe "not usable" factor can be interpreted as 1 negative level in pen and paper game.

Do yo think this property is well-balanced? Or is it rather too strong to be brought into usual 3.5e games?

I prefer those properties over usual Anarchic/Axiomatic/Holy/Unholy properties, because it will truly benefit someone with non-neutral alignment (something rare in 3.5e).

[freyar]

Well, if +2d6 vs a more restrictive alignment group (like the usual ones) is a +2 bonus, what you describe could be either +1 or +2. That would be my only quibble, I think.