D&D 4th Edition RulesAsk questions about 4th-Edition rules and the like in here. General discussion about 4E or any other game belongs in General RPG Discussion, above.
Not really an optimal build considering no ability score bonus overlap with the druid's key scores, but . . .
Wildshape says, "While you are in beast form, you can't use attack, utility, or feat powers that lack the beast form keyword, although you can sustain such powers." No reference to not being able to use racial powers. The obvious one you can use is Elven Accuracy, but a shadar-kai or eladrin can teleport, a minotaur can turn into a small bull (or big weasel) and charge, and the coolest one IMO is that a dragonborn can breathe fire from his tiger form (or wolf, or hyena, or bear, etc.) The weirdest is the doppleganger, who can wildshape, then use Change Shape to look like "any Medium humanoid, including a unique individual" . . . while still being wildshaped!
~
__________________
Click above to see S7S's FREE Rune Soldier Heroic Tier Playtest
also check out Silent7Seven.com for information on The Lunar Scrolls,
and the Advanced Class line including "Druid — Favored Forms"
and "Sorcerer — Aberrant Blood"
A Dragonborn Druid cannot use his breathweapon in beastform because:
1. It is a racial attack power
What's a racial attack power? I can't find any such thing in the PHB. Dragonborn breath attacks are a Dragonborn Racial Power according to their stat-block.
Quote:
2. The Dragon Breath power do not have the Beastform keyword.
3. It is cheese that deserves a smackdown.
It's a racial power. Why is it cheesy for him to retain its use? Is it equally cheesy for a beastform halfling to use Second Chance?
A Dragonborn Druid cannot use his breathweapon in beastform because:
1. It is a racial attack power
2. The Dragon Breath power do not have the Beastform keyword.
3. It is cheese that deserves a smackdown.
1&2) It has the attack line, so i'd say it's an attack and it lacks the beast keyword, so i'd say that by RAW you can't use it while beastformed. But...
3) i totally disagree. Cheese? why? If (as other posters have said) an halfling or an elf can use their racial, why couldn't the dragonborn use it's own? It could also be thematic, for example, imagine a dragonborn druid shapeshifted in a snake beastform using a poison breath
1&2) It has the attack line, so i'd say it's an attack and it lacks the beast keyword, so i'd say that by RAW you can't use it while beastformed.
That's not what defines an attack power. Attack powers are distinct from utility and racial powers in that they have the word Attack in their power type description.
The only Attack powers are those granted to you by your class as At-Will, Encounter and Daily powers.
"While you are in beast form, you can't use attack, utility, or feat powers that lack the beast form keyword, although you can sustain such powers."
Isn't English an awfully imprecise language? The strictest reading of that means when wildshaped the only powers you can use are feat powers that have the beast form keyword. Clearly that isn't the intent though.
Regardless, racial powers seem to be separate from attack powers even when the racial power is used to attack. Consider for example the Druid power Flame Seed which is a "Druid Attack 1" vs Dragon Breath which is a "Dragonborn Racial Power". Both are cosmetically similar attacks that lack the Beast Form key word but only one of them is expressly an "Attack" power.
I believe the intent of allowing racial powers to function in wildshape is based on the understanding that races are balanced with the racial powers in mind. Denying racial power access to a wildshape focused Druid would put even more emphasis on race selection with regards to character effectiveness compared with other the classes.
"While you are in beast form, you can't use attack, utility, or feat powers that lack the beast form keyword, although you can sustain such powers."
Isn't English an awfully imprecise language? The strictest reading of that means when wildshaped the only powers you can use are feat powers that have the beast form keyword. Clearly that isn't the intent though.
That would be an inaccurate reading. The sentence is fairly simple - it refers to attack, utility and feat powers, and then it pares down the selection still further, to the subset of those particular powers that also lack the beast form keyword, saying that those powers may not be used in beast form, though they may be sustained.
Aside from that small subset of powers, the sentence doesn't mention any other powers at all, and therefore it has no bearing on whether other powers may or may not be used whilst in beast form.
Attack powers are at will, encounter, and daily powers gained at levels 1, 3, 5, 7 etc.
Racial powers are not attack powers. Elven druids can use elven accuracy, dwarf druids can use second wind as a minor action, halfling druids can use second chance, and yes, dragonborn druids can breath dragon breath.
__________________ I will build a throne with the skulls of my foemen.
Attack powers are at will, encounter, and daily powers gained at levels 1, 3, 5, 7 etc.
Racial powers are not attack powers. Elven druids can use elven accuracy, dwarf druids can use second wind as a minor action, halfling druids can use second chance, and yes, dragonborn druids can breath dragon breath.
So, just to be clear:
You would also rule that a wildshaped Minotaur Druid (lets say, in panther form) can use Goring Charge:
Goring Charge Minotaur Racial Power
You charge the enemy and gore it with your horns.
I am, at present, conflicted. Some powers (e.g. Elven Accuracy) seem to make sense when wildshaped, others (Goring Charge) do not. The breath attack falls somewhere in between - it makes more sense to me than the charge, but not as much as Elven Accuracy.
In the absence of greater clarity, I will probably allow the less plausible powers on the theory that they are part of a balance that includes the more plausible powers and that to deny one implies I should deny all.
But I'm not so sure that is the intent.
Carl
__________________ "And I concurred with Gary [Gygax's] assessment of "Why are these people calling us to answer their questions. They should just make something up. We are not gods. We do not lay down the rules from on high. These are guidelines on how to have fun with this mode of entertainment." -Frank Mentzer
Also, on the subject of the minotaur ... the wild shape power doesn't turn you into a specific animal. So, a minotaur that has wildshaped may still have horns of some sort. It could end up not making sense, but requires the person using the open ended flavor of the wild shape to deliberately make it not fit with the flavor of the goring charge.
You would also rule that a wildshaped Minotaur Druid (lets say, in panther form) can use Goring Charge:
Goring Charge Minotaur Racial Power
You charge the enemy and gore it with your horns.
I am, at present, conflicted. Some powers (e.g. Elven Accuracy) seem to make sense when wildshaped, others (Goring Charge) do not. The breath attack falls somewhere in between - it makes more sense to me than the charge, but not as much as Elven Accuracy.
In the absence of greater clarity, I will probably allow the less plausible powers on the theory that they are part of a balance that includes the more plausible powers and that to deny one implies I should deny all.
But I'm not so sure that is the intent.
Carl
I would totally allow that. And that's before even considering that players can change the names and flavor of any of their powers, describing it any way they choose. A minotaur player (completely off the wildhsape issue for a second) could describe his goring charge as a flying kick instead. So, double yes; I would allow goring charge in Medium weasel form.
Plus, there's what WalterKovacs mentioned. The wildhsape form chosen could easily have horns . . . or the black panther the minotaur's in the shape of could temporarily grow horns just for the goring charge attack.
~
__________________
Click above to see S7S's FREE Rune Soldier Heroic Tier Playtest
also check out Silent7Seven.com for information on The Lunar Scrolls,
and the Advanced Class line including "Druid — Favored Forms"
and "Sorcerer — Aberrant Blood"
Linear Mode
And yet another word from our sponsors
