General RPG DiscussionDiscussion of all RPGs and non-system-specific topics. DM/GM/player issues, settings, etc. Rules discussion belongs in one the forums below.
My local game store has the 1st edition of the game for fifteen dollars. Should I buy it? Or should I shell out another 15 bucks for a copy of the second edition?
Unfortunately, my best advice is "get them both".
If that's not feasible, I'd go for first edition at that price level. The two editions are by and large compatible, except for the rules for magic.
Of course, if you're lusting over the second edition tomes of corruption and salvation and the realms of sorcery book, I'd recommend you go for second edition.
Actually, if you're planning on getting more books for the game, go for second edition. Those supplements are more readily available at reasonable prices, and are also available as PDF:s.
But if you're only going for the one book, I'd say go for the 15 dollars option.
/m
__________________ iAltdorf. An interactive map of the capital of the Empire in WFRP! Download today! Can be used in any fantasy campaign!
http://altdorfer.blogspot.com - Check out the Altdorf Correspondent! A WFRP blog about life in the Imperial capital.
"All editions of D&D are awesome." - Fifth Element (EN World Forums, 2008)
”The tendency to confuse personal taste with objective quality is nearly universal.” - Robin D. Laws – Robin’s Laws of Good Gamemastering (Steve Jackson Games, 2002)
Since Emirikol brought up the Maptools thing for WFRP, which I think is pretty sweet, I'm going to add this to the op.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Emirikol
The Warhammer Fantasy Roleplay Maptool Project
This project's purpose is to encourage play of WFRP on Maptool by making it quick and easy for a GM to get a game started with little or now start-up work.
Here's how you do it:
1. Own the WFRP core rulebook (available as PDF at RPGnow.com)
2. Download Maptool version 1.3b56 or newer
3. Download a voice chat system such as Skype or Ventrillo
4. Download the campaign file (or any maptooled scenario) below and save it to your >.maptool>campaignthumb folder. If it's a zip, extract it.
5. Download the monster tokens below. Save it to your >.maptool>resources>default>tokens file folder. If it's a zip, extract them.
6. Download the guide to playing WFRP on Maptool below.
If that's not feasible, I'd go for first edition at that price level. The two editions are by and large compatible, except for the rules for magic.
Of course, if you're lusting over the second edition tomes of corruption and salvation and the realms of sorcery book, I'd recommend you go for second edition.
Actually, if you're planning on getting more books for the game, go for second edition. Those supplements are more readily available at reasonable prices, and are also available as PDF:s.
But if you're only going for the one book, I'd say go for the 15 dollars option.
/m
I got the second edition book. I figured it wasn't that much more expensive, and the number of supplements kind of pushed me over the edge.
I've book looking over the game, and I'm pretty excited to play. I'll probably get my group to run it sometime this upcoming week.
Thanks for the advice!
__________________ IF IT EXISTS, NERDS WILL ARGUE ABOUT IT
Here's some more advice, even though you didn't ask for it:
First things first: welcome to WFRP! An excellent choice!
1. You should also buy Sigmar's Heirs, to get a good picture of the Empire.
2. After that, go for Old World Bestiary, which contains more monsters (although I think it is totally possible to play with just the monsters in the core rulebook, the OWB is very useful).
3. Rather than buy an adventure, you should go here:
Download the four adventures you can find on that page (The Oldenhaller Contract, Burn After Printing, Grauschloss and The Nine Virtues of Magnus the Pious).
4. If you want even more adventures, go to this page:
Order as many different issues of Warpstone as possible. They contain adventures, as well as interesting articles about other aspects of WFRP not covered by official supplements. There are also downloads, e.g. an adventure right there on the starting page.
9. And if you still feel like you need to buy an adventure, go for The Thousand Thrones.
And ask away if there's anything else you're wondering about!
/Magnus
__________________ iAltdorf. An interactive map of the capital of the Empire in WFRP! Download today! Can be used in any fantasy campaign!
http://altdorfer.blogspot.com - Check out the Altdorf Correspondent! A WFRP blog about life in the Imperial capital.
"All editions of D&D are awesome." - Fifth Element (EN World Forums, 2008)
”The tendency to confuse personal taste with objective quality is nearly universal.” - Robin D. Laws – Robin’s Laws of Good Gamemastering (Steve Jackson Games, 2002)
1. You should also buy Sigmar's Heirs, to get a good picture of the Empire.
Sigmars's Heirs is an ok book, but since the actual chapters that detail the 4 great cities are in four other adventure books, IMNSHO, the book is woefully incomplete.
Thanks for all of the advice and resources. I think I'll definitely get the bestiary, and probably Sigmar's Heirs, too. I really wish I could find the game master's kit for cheap, since there are so many tables I would like to have at the ready.
I'll hit up my local game store tomorrow when they're open.
__________________ IF IT EXISTS, NERDS WILL ARGUE ABOUT IT
Thanks for all of the advice and resources. I think I'll definitely get the bestiary, and probably Sigmar's Heirs, too. I really wish I could find the game master's kit for cheap, since there are so many tables I would like to have at the ready. I'll hit up my local game store tomorrow when they're open.
All of the books are now available for purchase as PDF's at RPGnow.com and drivethrurpg.com. The cool thing is that they're fixing errata in the PDF versions too. The GM screen is handy. The toolkit isn't all that great. It's just tables of spur-of-the-moment adventure ideas (which, for some people, may be handy...).
Dont' forget to follow up on the official WFRP forums too. The guys there love to help.
Thought I'd bump the thread with Emirikol's latest announcement.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Emirikol
Just for fun, I went through and did a summary of the WFRP2 scenarios and made a list of their recommended max xp, and number of careers recommended. [edit: note this is author-recommended listings of xp..some GM's prefer 100 xp per night]
I hope some of you GM's find it useful.
It will probably grow to eventually include convention-style blurb and maybe some other info. Anything you guys would like me to add?