Proposal: Let Drivan become a staff wizard

Reklaw · 17th June 2009, 05:23 PM

Judges,

I've been playing Drivan as a Wand of Accuracy wizard for the past few months and have really started seeing him more as a Staff of Defense guy...

This is a proposal that I be allowed to change the appropriate stats as well and changing out the wand to staff. In game this was accomplished through the Battle Bone adventure with Kenhood.

Here is the character sheet with the proposed changes in place

Thanks,
Reklaw

JoeNotCharles · 17th June 2009, 05:55 PM

So, judges, how should we handle requests like this? Vote on the specific changes in this thread, or just vote yes or no on the general concept and if it passes let 2 people approve the character sheet as normal?

I'm leaning toward number 2: I doubt anyone has an objection to this in general, so it'll take no time at all to rubber-stamp it, and there's no reason for all the judges to need to scrutinize the sheet. Then we can add it to the pile like we would a level-up submission and any of the character reviewers can get a go at it.

The only problem I can see with that is then Drivan would probably have to wait until a bunch of other pending level-ups and new PHB2 characters are reviewed, and unlike levelling up, this doesn't come right after XP has been awarded. So if KenHood awards XP in the next couple of days while he's still in the queue he might miss out.

On the gripping hand, KenHood's already allowing him to use these stats in Battle Bone with the caveat that they're temporary until they're approved. So I think the best course is - we approve the general concept, after which Reklaw can submit the updated sheet whenever he feels best with a mail to l4w.judges (with the standard "L4W Character Submission" subject line). Then he can time the actual submission of the changes to whenever he feels best.

Ozymandias79 · 17th June 2009, 07:22 PM

I really don't think this should be at the forum, reklaw, i think you could have e-mailed us this and we could have handled fairly quickly there IE I am ok with the do-over but not with you posting it as a proposal on the board

OZ79

JoeNotCharles · 17th June 2009, 07:54 PM

We told him to post it as a proposal! (EDIT: Proposal: Retraining for New Material, and my followup two posts later, although I wasn't a judge yet.)

I think it's important to things like this in the open, so that we're not accused of secretly favouring some players. I'm seen things like that really blow up on other boards, although we seem to be a good drama-free group here.

covaithe · 18th June 2009, 08:19 AM

Yeah, I've got no problem having it on the boards.

As for general vs. specific... I feel pretty confident that we plan to approve a generalized version of this, but we haven't yet. And one hasn't been proposed yet. I think it's time to do something about that, but possibly not in this thread.

I'll be happy enough to approve it in this specific case if we don't get a general rule passed in a few days, though.

Reklaw · 18th June 2009, 06:18 PM

Sounds good! Will just wait for the voting to finish on the changes in other threads then. Will submit the character sheet with the changes via email once the XP has been distributed if that's fine?

Thanks!