TSR Q&A with Gary Gygax

Status
Not open for further replies.
This is the multi-year Q&A sessions held by D&D co-creator Gary Gygax here at EN World, beginning in 2002 and running up until his sad pasing in 2008. Gary's username in the thread below is Col_Pladoh, and his first post in this long thread is Post #39.

Gary_Gygax_Gen_Con_2007.jpg
 
Last edited by a moderator:

log in or register to remove this ad

Gentlegamer

Adventurer
BOZ said:
man, seriously, anyone out there have a time machine? if so, could you do us all a favor and go back and grab all of gary's old notebooks? ;)
Dr. Beckett stepped in the quantum leap accelerator . . . and vanished!
 

log in or register to remove this ad

JohnRTroy

Adventurer
Allow me to elaborate on the classes with my best guesses, based on descriptions in old dragons, and some of these former classes were mentioned as possible professions in MYTHUS, save for the Jester.

From what little I remember from this and Dragon, the Savant was mentioned to have powers to overcome some of the altered magics of other planes, and I would assume they were like mages, but more akin to a combination of 1st Edition Sage, Specialist Wizard (3e) Diviner, and 3e Expert or Prestige class Loremaster. Their abilities would likely deal with knowlege rather than evocations, so they might be better at things like Divination and Abjuration or even Conjuration spells than the typical mage. The 1st Edition Derro "savants" in 1e MM2 might also be akin to what the class would have been.

I assume mystics had more yoga like powers--Gary had mentioned that in playtest "mystics rated the lowest, since nobody had them at #1". Whatever that means. Maybe powers were randomly generated? I assume this involves communing and inner psychic powers and astral projection. Like Gary said, Divine Divination and Fortune-Telling would also be part of this class. Holy Men and hermits might be the way to go here.

Mountebanks--well, if we think Hop the Savant having those powers, it might mean a thief or rouge with powers to create potions--some fake, some real, and probably some "hedge-mage" types of powers. If we were going by the 3e, a mountebank template might be a rogue specializing in using magic items, con-games, and potion brewing, with maybe a bit of 3e sorceror or 1e Illusionist. (Sorry, best way to describe the class). They probably are seen as "pretenders" to magic--having just enough to get by, but a real mage or wizard would probably scoff at them.

Jesters--Probably similar to the bard, but it probably was akin to the mythus skill of buffonerry, which combines joke telling (think of something that either humiliates or puts a victim into a reckless rage, or incites a riot), with pranks (akin to setting traps, or getting hit with a pie or slipping on a banana peel), maybe some illusion or enchantment magic as well.

That's all I can surmise.
 
Last edited:

MerricB

Eternal Optimist
Supporter
dcas said:
Perhaps the Forces of Evil (tm) got it riled up, or perhaps it's a tree beast a la Dark Druids. :)

Even Treebeard very nearly squashed Merry and Pippin.

Merry & Pippin = Provocation. :)

Cheers!
 

Howdy Gary,


Col_Pladoh said:
Pish & Tosh!

A treant is neutral in regards to other alignments and does not attack without provocation;)

Perhaps it was the 50 Verbobonc heavy foot armed with axes that started swarming through it's grove looking to chop down a tree for use as a battering ram? I'm not sure but I think that is listed in treant etiquette books as a definite faux pas. :lol:


Futures Bright,

Paul
 

Gentlegamer said:
the "3e" take was completely different from what Gary proposed. They had too much of the typical "dungeonpunk" varnish, as does much of the 3e ruleset.

Dungeonpunks with their mandatory motorcycle helmet safety rules and magic item value audits, eh?

Back in the day, a man was a man, and played in an elf in regular old chain mail -- nothing fancy mind, dey hadn't invented master woik yet -- who died at -1 hp and was happy ta find 3 cp under the pile of orcs what he woiked all day to slain. And we didn't complain that elves were limited to 7th level as Fighters, no, we just took it, 'cause dats how things was. But kids today, oy vey, with da spikey armor and da ambidextrous rangers and da half drag-oins! It's all goin' to Eberron, I tells ya. It's getting so's you cain't even get a nice Greyhawk adventure without taking the bus into that Paizo place in Renton. It's no Lake Geneva, I tell you what. :eek:
 


Elfdart

Banned
Banned
gideon_thorne said:
You forgot the bit about caltrop dice. Even the dice have blunted edges now. Nerf dice! :lol:

I bought several round d4s -they're actually d12s numbered 1-4 three times. Where were these when I was a kid?
 

Col_Pladoh

Gary Gygax
dcas said:
Perhaps the Forces of Evil (tm) got it riled up, or perhaps it's a tree beast a la Dark Druids. :)

Even Treebeard very nearly squashed Merry and Pippin.
Again, Pish & Tosh!

The rules being used were Chainmail fantasy, so there are no evil treants. Furthermore, there were two druids leading the forces, a part of which the blasted wooden thing assailed :]

:lol:
Gary
 

Col_Pladoh

Gary Gygax
JohnRTroy said:
Allow me to elaborate on the classes with my best guesses, based on descriptions in old dragons, and some of these former classes were mentioned as possible professions in MYTHUS, save for the Jester. ...
Ciao, John,

Good work as usual. Just a couple of additions. The savant and mystic were meant to deal with critters from other planes as well. The mountebank could use disguise, impersonate, and with his patter or oration affect an audience of one or many more.The jester could use several hurled missile weapons such as daggers, clubs, knives, throwing stars, etc. with speed and accuraccy.

Cheers,
Gary
 

Col_Pladoh

Gary Gygax
Paul J. Stormberg said:
Howdy Gary,

Perhaps it was the 50 Verbobonc heavy foot armed with axes that started swarming through it's grove looking to chop down a tree for use as a battering ram? I'm not sure but I think that is listed in treant etiquette books as a definite faux pas. :lol:

Futures Bright,

Paul
:mad:

Butt out with your silly details :]

:lol:
Gary
 

Status
Not open for further replies.

Related Articles

Remove ads

Remove ads

AD6_gamerati_skyscraper

Remove ads

Upcoming Releases

Top