Proposal: Great Halberd, New Superior Reach Axe

renau1g

First Post

• Sep 4, 2009

• #31

Welcome back stonegod

 

log in or register to remove this ad

CaBaNa

First Post

• Sep 4, 2009

• #32

thats why I'm not a designer....

 

ukingsken

First Post

• Sep 5, 2009

• #33

I think I have been swayed. I dont have the time/inclination to crunch numbers about whether bonus to hit or damage etc s better, but I understand it all

I think I'm ok with this weapon and thus approve the Superior Reach Axe of joy!

YES

 

garyh

First Post

• Sep 5, 2009

• #34

So I've got "Yes" from renau1g, TwoHeadsBarking, and ukingsken, and a preemptive "No, until further reviewed" from stonegod.

Unless there's another "No" or a "Yes" flips to "No," this will pass Sunday at 5:50 PM PDT. Yay!

When does Divine Power go live here?

EDIT: Answered my own question. Divine Power is live today! Between DP being live and the great halberd looking to pass, I guess I ought to go stat my PC up and code her into the Wiki.

 

Last edited: Sep 5, 2009

hornedturtle

First Post

• Sep 5, 2009

• #35

renau1g said:

I'd require any reach weapon to be 2H

Click to expand...

How about a Whip?

 

renau1g

First Post

• Sep 5, 2009

• #36

I'm not saying every reach weapon is 2h, I'm saying I'd require a reach weapon to be one, especially a reach weapon that does decent damage.

 

D

dimsdale

First Post

• Sep 6, 2009

• #37

CaBaNa said:

thats why I'm not a designer....

Click to expand...

lol

It was worth a try though CaBaNa
I would have said yes.

but my vote means nothing...and for good reason!

 

E

EvolutionKB

First Post

• Sep 6, 2009

• #38

I'll vote YES.

 

Velmont

First Post

• Sep 9, 2009

• #39

Compared to the Waraxe, you exchange the Versatile attributes for Reach. Versatile is strong because it include the fact you can have a shield (So +2 AC and Refl). Compare to that weapon, the Great Halberd seems fine with me.

That was my 2 coppers.

 

elecgraystone

First Post

• Sep 20, 2009

• #40

Velmont said:

Versatile is strong because it include the fact you can have a shield (So +2 AC and Refl).

Click to expand...

Actually Versatile is the weakest attribute by far IMO. It only gives a non-scaling +1 damage if you use the weapon in two hands. The ability to use a weapon in one hand isn't an attribute and to use the +1 damage you have to give up that shield. The only time I see it as a real bonus is if your class can't use a shield. The ability to hit someone an extra square away seems a lot better than a possible extra +1 damage [if you're using a shield, the attribute does nothing for you].