HM, first let me say I consider you a friend on these board.
Have you thought of something to go with your stats first. A human alchemist would work, look at his physical abilities. He looks like an overweight mage always with his nose in a book or behind his chemistry set and never getting out.
No it wouldn't. I imagined a half crazy gnome alchemist, throwing medieval Molotovs and and if cornered, gulps his mutagen to fight like a cornered rat.
An alchemist needs some DEX to hit with his bombs. His mutagens are only suicide with that bad physical stats. So I just lost 2 of the 3 alchemist class features. And I would have to play a race I don't wanted to play.
I could
a) trying the hell out to optimize a character with bad abilities
or
b) go with it and play a tragic figure, who always wanted to be a hero, but never had the inborn talent.
The second sounds more like roleplaying.
If we would have done a 15 point buy you would have what? Taken one of those 10's and made it 14 and drop your cha down to raise your dex?
My monk has Cha 8, fine, but my other PF characters have 10, 13 and 17.
And with a 15 standard point buy, I would have 5 more points...
Don't want to rant but that is how everyone makes a character, so far there have been some great ideals from these "bad rolls" and the ideal isn't to have the great hero save the world it is to have the guy you wouldn't think could do it at all accomplish such a feat.
Was any hero of the fellowship so incompetent?
Any of the Heroes of the Lance?
What is the ideal you are talking about?
Your character WD play what you think is best with what you were dealt but I think there is possiblity in those for a good character.
...
Here they are (short stats version with abilities):
Fantalass, the Evoker (Elf Wizard) LN
Str 10
Dex 13
Con 8
Int 16
Wis 12
Cha 12
Feat: Point Blank Shot
Snobby elf who thinks he is better than anyone else. Nearly has always a light cold.
---
Alrik (Human Fighter) LG
Str 12
Dex 11
Con 10
Int 14
Wis 12
Cha 12
Young farmboy who found an armor and a weapon by accident. Always bullied for being a bright but frail kid, he trained for himself and left his home to defend the weak.
Feats: Endurance, Diehard
Fighter Feat: Combat Expertise.
---
Neebo (goblin rogue) CG/CN
Str 8
Dex 15
Con 10
Int 14
Wis 12
Cha 10
Feat: Weapon Finesse
Bright goblin who has joint the heroes because they killed him as they encountered him in a cave.
---
All: Please vote my character.