Poll: Ability scores - How intrinsic are they to D&D?




What's on your mind?

View Poll Results: What is the importance of ability scores in D&D?

Voters
97. You may not vote on this poll
  • Very important; they should mechanically impact everything within reason.

    61 62.89%
  • Important, but they should primarily serve to inform RP, not mechanics.

    10 10.31%
  • Ability scores should be limited for mechanical reasons (ex. modifier bloat).

    24 24.74%
  • Unimportant; D&D would still be D&D without them.

    5 5.15%
  • Replace them with an alternative (for example, aspects from FATE).

    4 4.12%
  • It all depends on specific implementation. I need more details.

    5 5.15%
  • Other (please elaborate)

    5 5.15%
  • The cake is a LIE!!! (Or I don't care.)

    3 3.09%
Multiple Choice Poll.
+ Log in or register to post
Page 1 of 2 12 LastLast
Results 1 to 10 of 15
  1. #1
    Registered User
    Myrmidon (Lvl 10)

    Fanaelialae's Avatar

    Join Date
    Jul 2007
    Location
    Old Bridge, NJ
    Posts
    1,035
    I Defended The Walls!Dragon Age RPGD&D

    Ignore Fanaelialae
    My communities:

    Poll: Ability scores - How intrinsic are they to D&D?

    I'd intended to include a poll with my original thread, but I didn't realize that the system would time me out if I wasn't quick enough. So, here it is.

    Would some kind moderator be willing to merge the two threads? Pretty please?

 

  • #2
    Registered User
    Grandfather of Assassins (Lvl 19)

    ExploderWizard's Avatar

    Join Date
    May 2008
    Location
    Fredericksburg
    Posts
    6,078

    Ignore ExploderWizard
    I voted "Other".

    Ability scores have always been a part of D&D and should remain a part of D&D.

    The impact of ability scores on the mechanics of the game has changed drastically over the years. This is the bit that needs to be overhauled.

    In general, bonus fixation & bloat has done more to drag the game away from its RP roots than anything else. The endless collecting of plusses is a minigame all in itself and has IMHO become too large a part of the game.
    Death is for amateurs -Charlie Sheen

  • #3
    Registered User
    Myrmidon (Lvl 10)

    Fanaelialae's Avatar

    Join Date
    Jul 2007
    Location
    Old Bridge, NJ
    Posts
    1,035
    I Defended The Walls!Dragon Age RPGD&D

    Ignore Fanaelialae
    My communities:

    Quote Originally Posted by ExploderWizard View Post
    The impact of ability scores on the mechanics of the game has changed drastically over the years. This is the bit that needs to be overhauled.

    In general, bonus fixation & bloat has done more to drag the game away from its RP roots than anything else. The endless collecting of plusses is a minigame all in itself and has IMHO become too large a part of the game.
    I agree with this.


    I wouldn't mind seeing the list expanded to something like The Arcanum's:

    Strength
    Dexterity
    Constitution
    Speed
    Intelligence
    Willpower
    Perception
    Charisma

    Wisdom, in particular, has always seemed to me like a mish-mosh of leftover characteristics.


    Although to be honest, I wouldn't exactly be heartbroken if ability scores went the way of the dodo. Due to their history with the game though, I realize that's quite unlikely.

  • #4
    Registered User
    Grandfather of Assassins (Lvl 19)

    delericho's Avatar

    Join Date
    Aug 2004
    Location
    Falkirk
    Posts
    8,019
    I Defended The Walls!

    Ignore delericho
    My communities:

    As I said in the other thread, I'm fine with games that don't use the six ability scores. However, in D&D they are a sacred cow that simply cannot be slaughtered - it isn't D&D without them.

    You could maybe get away with removing the stats and just using the modifiers instead, but probably not. Certainly, I would oppose such a move.

    I also agree with ExploderWizard that ability scores have become far too important in the game. Actually, this was true even as far back as 1st Edition - BD&D was considerably better in this regard. A scaling back of the importance of the stats is long overdue, IMO.

  • #5
    Registered User
    Grandfather of Assassins (Lvl 19)

    delericho's Avatar

    Join Date
    Aug 2004
    Location
    Falkirk
    Posts
    8,019
    I Defended The Walls!

    Ignore delericho
    My communities:

    Quote Originally Posted by Fanaelialae View Post
    I wouldn't mind seeing the list expanded to something like The Arcanum's:

    Strength
    Dexterity
    Constitution
    Speed
    Intelligence
    Willpower
    Perception
    Charisma

    Wisdom, in particular, has always seemed to me like a mish-mosh of leftover characteristics.
    While in theory you might be able to set up a better arrangement, I don't think you can even tinker with the stats and have the game remain D&D.

    Basically, the game has to have ability scores, it has to have six ability scores, and they have to be those ability scores. Or it isn't D&D.

    (And, yes, I'm aware of Comeliness, as added in Unearthed Arcana. I'm also aware that this attempt to add a seventh score just didn't gain any real traction.)

  • #6
    The poll seems confused about whether it is asking whether ability scores SHOULD matter or if they DO. Whether the should or not, they do matter. A lot. I'd go so far as to say that the six ability scores with those names define the game as D&D as much or more than the d20 does. Most RPG's can be identified by the names of their major ability scores and nothing else.
    No, you are not paranoid. Everyone really IS out to get you!

  • #7
    Registered User
    Spellbinder (Lvl 16)

    Ahnehnois's Avatar

    Join Date
    Mar 2004
    Posts
    6,708

    Ignore Ahnehnois
    My communities:

    The six ability scores are the basic language of D&D. Looking at those numbers is the first way I understand a character. It's like beng a doctor and looking at a standard set of bloodwork that tells you all kinds of important things about your patient. If you changed the things being measured, the units, or even the names, it would throw the entire medical profession for a loop (and for no good reason). Same with D&D.

    Not saying that other ability systems are invalid, but I am saying that Str/Dex/Con/Int/Wis/Cha are fundamental to D&D.
    "Clear Eyes, Full Hearts, Can't Lose"

  • #8
    Registered User
    Grandfather of Assassins (Lvl 19)



    Join Date
    Jan 2008
    Posts
    5,008
    Circvs MaximvsForgotten RealmsD&D

    Ignore El Mahdi
    There is no Cake!

  • #9
    Registered User
    Magsman (Lvl 14)

    MarkB's Avatar

    Join Date
    May 2006
    Location
    England
    Posts
    3,839

    Ignore MarkB
    My communities:

    Ever since 3e unified ability score modifiers, I've wondered whether it's actually useful in any way to keep the scores themselves, since they're hardly used in any game element.

    99% of the time, I don't need to know that my Strength score is 18 - I just need to know that I have a +4 bonus to Strength-related actions. So why not make the +4 the only entry for that ability?

    I'd keep the actual ability names as they are - there's room to argue for slightly different definitions of physical and mental attributes, but the current set serve well enough.

  • #10
    Registered User
    Myrmidon (Lvl 10)

    Wiseblood's Avatar

    Join Date
    Jul 2006
    Location
    Grayson Valley area north of Birmingham
    Posts
    484

    Ignore Wiseblood
    My communities:

    The unification or standardization cost ability scores some of their sizzle.

    They are critical to D&D but I'll admit their current iteration could use some retooling.
    Sanjuro: "Stupid friends are dangerous."

  • + Log in or register to post
    Page 1 of 2 12 LastLast

    Similar Threads

    1. Ability scores - How intrinsic are they to D&D?
      By Fanaelialae in forum General RPG Discussion
      Replies: 151
      Last Post: Tuesday, 8th November, 2011, 08:14 AM
    2. [Poll] Which ability scores?
      By loseth in forum General RPG Discussion
      Replies: 0
      Last Post: Thursday, 3rd July, 2008, 12:06 PM
    3. Replies: 9
      Last Post: Thursday, 8th December, 2005, 03:04 PM
    4. Return of Creature by Poll - Poll #24 (ability scores)
      By Shade in forum General Monster Talk
      Replies: 7
      Last Post: Wednesday, 7th December, 2005, 06:19 AM

    Posting Permissions

    • You may not post new threads
    • You may not post replies
    • You may not post attachments
    • You may not edit your posts
    •