(OOC: Yes, I think you can.
However, I just realized, since Kalli dealt Arthur nonlethal damage, I think that it's apparent to Arthur that by continuing to pursue this goal he's putting himself in danger, which breaks the effect.)
Kalli, struggling on the ground with Arthur, can't avoid smacking him on the head a few times, dazing him. Suddenly, Arthur realizes that Kalli is willing to do him harm if he continues on this path. And suddenly, as though from a dream, Arthur wakes up. The pie smells as delicious as it did a moment ago, but he no longer feels compelled to seek it out.