Which team will win Super Bowl XLVI?

Holy Bovine · Feb 6, 2012

Goodsport said:
And why?

I'll say the Giants!

Because they just did

Crothian · Feb 6, 2012

GreenLantern said:
After watching the "Brady 6" ESPN special, I hope Tom Brady wins it this time around. If a sixth round draft pick can reach Montana-esque levels in terms of Superbowl wins, it gives us all hope.

How? None of us are 6th round draft picks.

El Mahdi · Feb 6, 2012

Crothian said:
How? None of us are 6th round draft picks.

Well I don't know about you, but I stayed at a Holiday Inn Express last night...

jaerdaph · Feb 6, 2012

I never want to hear about how great Tom Brady is ever again. Maybe one day, if he's lucky, he can be in Eli's class. B-)

Dannyalcatraz · Feb 6, 2012

Eli wins because he has a top-notch defense and (occasionally, like now) has talented receivers. Brady wins because- like Payton- he is a ridiculous talent at his position and always has talented receivers.

Eli is like a slightly better version of Romo- he has all the QB tools, but occasionally reverts back to his rookie year and makes truly boneheaded mistakes...from which his D rescues him.

(No, I don't have a dog in this fight- I'm a Saints fan.)

Krug · Feb 6, 2012

Exciting game. Great game Giants. You deserved that win.

Crothian · Feb 6, 2012

jaerdaph said:
I never want to hear about how great Tom Brady is ever again. Maybe one day, if he's lucky, he can be in Eli's class.

Over all Brady is a better quarterback then Eli. He's had the better career and better numbers. Eli has the better team around him. Football is the ultimate team sport.

Ahnehnois · Feb 7, 2012

jaerdaph said:
I never want to hear about how great Tom Brady is ever again. Maybe one day, if he's lucky, he can be in Eli's class.

Both of them were outplayed head to head by Rex Grossman. After having beating the Giants twice, convincingly, I think the Redskins should be awarded the trophy.