But Is It Art?





+ Log in or register to post
Page 1 of 2 1 2 LastLast
Results 1 to 10 of 13

Thread: But Is It Art?

  1. #1

    But Is It Art?

    [ame=http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=e_e_vibklDI]20 Special: But Is It Art? - YouTube[/ame]

 

  • #2
    Registered User
    Gallant (Lvl 3)

    Jupp's Avatar

    Join Date
    Jun 2004
    Location
    Switzerland
    Posts
    677
    I Defended The Walls!

    ° Ignore Jupp
    Interesting video. Interesting question.

    My answer would be:

    "I could not name a single TT RPG product to be a piece of art"

    My longer explanation:

    I would not consider roleplaying games as art per se. But some of the things that make out RPGs can be considered art to some extent. Though one has to make a distinction between "Design" and "Art" which usually are considered two different things, at least in the classical sense and definition. Also in that regard an illustration is not considered art in a classical sense.

    Some side products like novels can be considered as art. The same goes for for certain paintings and artistic illustrations that often come with an RPG product. Good examples would be the covers of RPG rules/setting books. Though it is debatable if depictions of monsters in a monster manual are are art or just illustrations/design. I think there is a grey zone there.

    Perhaps when you actually play a roleplaying game at the table all those things mingle and mix together and would produce some kind of artistic product in your head. Let us call it "Brain Art" because only you can "see" and feel it. Well perhaps it is not art but it can feel like it for you personally.

    I am a bit torn here while trying to find an answer to the question asked. On one side you have the classic definitions of what is considered art and on the other hand you have the libertarian mindset of our modern times that everything can be considered art if one wants it to be so. I prefer the classical definition, thus my answer as it is stated above.
    "It is a mistake to bow to the wishes of munchkins who whine." - E. Gary Gygax 1938-2008, we will never forget you!
    "Yes, even at twelve years old, I was already old school... " - The Shaman
    "Look up at the stars and not down at your feet. Try to make sense of what you see, and wonder about what makes the universe exist. Be curious." - S.Hawking
    ----
    Currently DMing: Rappan Athuk, Kickstarter Version (set in Greyhawk, Castle&Crusade Rules)
    Currently Playing: nothing
    Last campaign: Expedition to the Ruins of Greyhawk (Castles & Crusades Ruleset)

  • #3
    Reminds me of a thread I started about a year ago. There was a lot of back and forth; the majority unsurprisingly did not look at D&D as art but a pretty substantial moniority did.

    Personally, I look at D&D as a creative medium. I see it as having a lot in common with film and television, and as directing is very much my lost passion, art is absolutely what I intend when I run a D&D session. D&D is an interactive improvisational form of dramatic art (with some game-y rules attached).

    I do not, however, look at the rulebooks as being art themselves any more than I would look at a textbook on music theory to be art; the art is the gameplay itself. I suppose content books (published adventures and the like) could be more likely to merit that designation, but I still think they are only preparation for the final product at the table.
    "Clear Eyes, Full Hearts, Can't Lose"

  • #4
    Registered User
    Grandfather of Assassins (Lvl 19)

    Stormonu's Avatar

    Join Date
    Jun 2007
    Location
    Mississippi
    Posts
    3,952
    Blog Entries
    7

    ° Ignore Stormonu
    I believe I stated in the other thread that I don't believe RPGs to be art, much as I disagree with him that any video game is art - it's an experience. I think he's trying to stretch a point, a "The sky's not really blue" sort of analogy. A roleplaying game can contain artistic depictions and story text, but it's not art. It's a game, nothing more.
    "If it has stats, we can kill it." - T.G. Jackson, intro to 3rd ed Hackmaster

    Homebrew 4E material | My campaign world - Amberos

  • #5
    Registered User
    Cutpurse (Lvl 5)

    Dndungeoneer's Avatar

    Join Date
    Dec 2009
    Location
    Kansas City
    Posts
    282

    ° Ignore Dndungeoneer
    I can consider it art. And by that I mean the game play involved not the role play itself. It evokes an artistic emotion for me I guess.

  • #6
    Registered User
    Magsman (Lvl 14)

    Hobo's Avatar

    Join Date
    Jan 2002
    Location
    Michigan S. S. R.
    Posts
    18,976
    Blog Entries
    20

    ° Ignore Hobo
    Quote Originally Posted by Ahnehnois View Post
    D&D is an interactive improvisational form of dramatic art (with some game-y rules attached).
    Yes. This.

    Although, I have to wonder; why does it matter? I mean, the stuff on regretsy is often art too... and yet the whole reason it's on regretsy is because people are making fun of how terrible it is. Being "art" isn't something that's really cool in and of itself.

    And that's where I think a lot of the discussion on this issue goes wrong; a lot of the "RPGs are Art!" crowd are trying to elevate their hobby somehow; to give it more prestige, or possibly just give themselves an excuse to be smug about their hobby. Personally, I just don't see the point in that. I call it art--or potentially so, at least--but I don't think that means anything particularly significant.

    "I realize that I am generalizing here, but, as is often the case when I generalize, I don't care." Dave Barry

  • #7
    Quote Originally Posted by Hobo View Post
    Although, I have to wonder; why does it matter? I mean, the stuff on regretsy is often art too... and yet the whole reason it's on regretsy is because people are making fun of how terrible it is. Being "art" isn't something that's really cool in and of itself.

    And that's where I think a lot of the discussion on this issue goes wrong; a lot of the "RPGs are Art!" crowd are trying to elevate their hobby somehow; to give it more prestige, or possibly just give themselves an excuse to be smug about their hobby. Personally, I just don't see the point in that. I call it art--or potentially so, at least--but I don't think that means anything particularly significant.
    I don't think it's necessarily about getting people outside the hobby to recognize it as such. I think it's more about getting other people inside the hobby to recognize what the rest of the community is doing. Online message boards have far too much discussion of game balance minutiae and far too little that reflects the roleplaying part of the hobby. I just think it's good to reinforce the artistic people.
    "Clear Eyes, Full Hearts, Can't Lose"

  • #8
    Registered User
    Magsman (Lvl 14)

    Hobo's Avatar

    Join Date
    Jan 2002
    Location
    Michigan S. S. R.
    Posts
    18,976
    Blog Entries
    20

    ° Ignore Hobo
    Quote Originally Posted by Ahnehnois View Post
    I don't think it's necessarily about getting people outside the hobby to recognize it as such. I think it's more about getting other people inside the hobby to recognize what the rest of the community is doing.
    Oh, I agree. But like I said, I wonder about the motivation behind getting that kind of recognition.

    "I realize that I am generalizing here, but, as is often the case when I generalize, I don't care." Dave Barry

  • #9
    Registered User
    Acolyte (Lvl 2)



    Join Date
    Jul 2012
    Location
    Toronto, Canada
    Posts
    177

    ° Ignore VinylTap
    Absolutely its art. It has all the factors involved in story-telling, just re-arranged in a new way.

  • #10
    Registered User
    Waghalter (Lvl 7)



    Join Date
    May 2006
    Location
    Calgary SE
    Posts
    544

    ° Ignore Meatboy
    Sure it's art. Just like any well crafted tool can be ttrpgs can be beautiful in and of themselves and they can be used to make things of beauty. But just like a well made car, knife or a superbly designed kitchen the people using it are (aka the artists) are far more important than the medium. You could give joe schmoe a fully stocked super kitchen and barbeque but that doesn't mean you are getting a gourmet meal out of it.

  • + Log in or register to post
    Page 1 of 2 1 2 LastLast

    Posting Permissions

    • You may not post new threads
    • You may not post replies
    • You may not post attachments
    • You may not edit your posts
    •