Saturday, 17th November, 2012, 12:41 PM #1
Myrmidon (Lvl 10)
Gamehackery: The Initiative Initiative
One of my gadget-strewn quests over years of gaming has been finding a good way to track initiative. I've seen a lot of methods -- and everyone loves what they're doing (or doesn't obsess about it), but I've got my favorites.
What We Need
Initiative is important for DMs, who need to keep things running in an orderly way.
Taking control of initiative is critical to good tactical play. Players that manage initiative well have a huge tactical advantage -- one DMs often have and take for granted. If your game isn't particularly tactical, it may not matter as much to you, but our group loves tactical combat, and being able to take control of initiative is a big part of that.
It's also important for DMs and players who would like to speed up play -- it's much more difficult to plan your next turn if you don't know when your turn is going to come up -- so keeping players aware of their place in the initiative order is a big part of trying to play faster.
So; we need a system that is accessible and transparent to players, easy to change as players and DMs tweak their place in the initiative order, and so on.
Writing it Down
Lots of folks do this -- write it on the corner of the battle mat, or on a notepad. Maybe you just write down numbers or write the orderů whatever. This is the most basic way to handle it, and for the sake of not hurting anyone's feelings we'll discard it because it's not using anything remotely gadgety. I mean, really. Get some toys, people. It's a game. it's supposed to be fun, and toys make it fun.
Back in 3.0 and 3.5 days, I loved index cards for initiative. In most cases I copied out the monster stat block onto index cards and could run the entire encounter from my initiative stack. Everything I needed was right there.
Index cards make it easy to manage things like changes in initiative -- just reorder cards. When a player wants to delay, give them their card, they can hand it back to you when they want to come back in, and so on. You can write conditions on the cards, etc. Very handy.
Cards break down, a bit, when it comes to trying to share information with players. Unless you're in the habit of announcing who's on deck, there's no way for the players to keep an eye on when their turn comes up, and it's very difficult for them to visualize how they can bend initiative to their benefit.
These Gamemastery gadgets are pretty cool -- a magnetic dry erase board with movable magnetic name widgets -- its flexible and movable and very popular.
I like the idea, but they have a lot of the same problems index cards have -- because it's in the DM's hands, it's hard for the players to see it and make plans. Also, my fat fingers and gnawed fingernails are not the best implements for prying the magnetic nameplates up and moving them around -- the process of adjusting initiative is always just a little time consuming.
Software & Apps
There's no lack of options out there -- iPhone and iPad apps, android apps too, as well as Mac and PC software that will manage initiative for you. If you're curious, check out DM Minion, or DM's Tracker.
We started with Excel, just creating a list with names and numbers and sorting by the initiative roll. Once you start doing that, you can play around with tricks like repeating the name information in other cells in another part of the sheet, and spreading the sheet out onto a second monitor so it's visible to the players, too. There are problems, though -- it's a kludge, and takes a lot of work to get set up. And then there are the mistakes -- accidentally deleting characters, copy and paste errors, all kinds of problems. If excel didn't have an "undo" function, it could have been really impossible.
For a long time I was a big fan of one called Turn Watcher, which is very good. Turnwatcher is a PC program that managed initiative for you and included a lot of extra information -- defenses, current hit points, conditions, and so on. Eventually they added support for a second, player-facing monitor which was a huge improvement. Now players could see the initiative order, make plans ahead of time, which was one of the critical ideas I wanted to have.
There are other apps out there that do similar things -- Turnwatcher was the most robust one I found, but there's a tool associated with PCgen that handles initiative, as well as a host of apps for iPads and iPhones that make decent initiative and condition trackers.
My frustration with all of these tools winds up being at the point at which I need to manage the information. If I'm using turn watcher to track initiative and hit points and conditions, that means that each time a target is hit, or healed, or subject to a condition, I need to make a change in the program -- a few clicks of the mouse, a few keys, shouldn't take too long.
It should have been fast, but it sure felt slow. To record a change in hit points I can make a couple of strokes with a pen or I can do a mouse click to select the victim, type in the damage, hit returnů the pen still feels faster to me. It probably has everything to do with the mental work required to go from playing an analog game, switching to using a digital device, then going back to the analog game - it feels like a long path to go when all we're trying to do is make it possible for Dingo the Stalwart to delay until after Scooter the Wise takes his turn and casts' Bull's Strength.
So, when we pack up to to go conventions, we don't take our computers and external monitors and most of the electronics. A DM friend of mine -- the one who first mastered the Excel spreadsheet initiative tracker in our group -- started using little folded bits of card stock (cut down from index cards), about 1" wide and about 2" long, folded in the middle so you end up with a little tent with 1"x1" sides.
We use different color card stock for players and monsters. One side of the card stock has the PC or NPC name, written large enough to be visible across the table. The other side (which faces the DM) has the name again, the initiative bonus, and the initiative total.
There are variations on this out there already -- people using a DM screen can hang folded cards over the top of the screen and get the same effect. I often use the tents to track conditions, too. And I've seen people who add other key details to the cards (key skills or defenses, etc). I'll use Post-It Flags to quickly attach a marker to a tent that indicates a condition -- and if I need to I can write something on the flag to indicate what it is or when it expires. Others use a variety tokens set in front of or behind the tent to indicate conditions. (Gale Force Nine makes a great line of tokens that work well for this)
In the end, this method is so fast and effective we're using it at home, in place of all the higher tech solutions we've tried in the past.
- It's fast for getting player initiative (distribute cards, they roll and write their new number on the card and pass it back)
- player can see where they are in the initiative order at all times
- it's very fast and easy to manipulate the initiative order (delay, held action, etc).
And, as an added feature, it compartmentalizes the task in a nice, neat way that can be handed off to a player to manage. It's a little unnerving at first, but from time to time, when I have a large, complex encounter, I'll ask a player to manage the initiative so I can focus on more important things.
So, what do you think? Do you have a better solution? Are my criteria out of line?
Saturday, 17th November, 2012, 10:00 PM #2
Orcus on an Off-Day (Lvl 22)
Greta article, as always. Re. the Gamermastry Pads - I see you note that "they have a lot of the same problems index cards have -- because it's in the DM's hands, it's hard for the players to see it". My question would be - who says it's in the DM's hands?
In our game, we use the pad, but players keep track, not the DM. The players have the pad. The DM just asks "who's next?" at the end of each turn.
Saturday, 17th November, 2012, 10:22 PM #3
Myrmidon (Lvl 10)
Putting initiative in the hands of the PCs is a great idea -- we do it from time to time with the tents. IMO making it visible to everyone is why I like the tents best, but those pads sure are popular, and you all can't be wrong.
Saturday, 17th November, 2012, 11:17 PM #4
Gallant (Lvl 3)
- Join Date
- Aug 2002
° Ignore Aluvial
I use a white board that hangs in sight of the players, behind me. I can make changes when needed. I keep LOTs of game info on this, including watch orders, essential stats, marching order... and so on.
I'm changing this to a magnetic white board soon, and will have all the PC's names printed cut to length magnets. I will still write monsters... and be able to peel and drop the PC's as they change position... Like the board for tracking celebrity track times on Top Gear...
Once it is printed, then you just switch them up as you go. The "magnets" come on a roll and your just cut them to length after you print them. Perhaps coat them with a layer of poly to seal the name...
AluvialThe big thing is to avoid snark and an overly antagonistic attitude. - M. Mearls
Sunday, 18th November, 2012, 02:33 PM #5
Minor Trickster (Lvl 4)
- Join Date
- Jan 2002
- Panama City, Florida, United States
° Ignore Nathal
Tuesday, 20th November, 2012, 05:30 PM #6
Spellbinder (Lvl 16)
- Join Date
- Jul 2004
- A Nation's Capitol
° Ignore TerraDave
Tuesday, 20th November, 2012, 05:35 PM #7
Myrmidon (Lvl 10)
Cool! I'd encourage you to think about what will be fast and easy. Putting the card over the screen with names on it works well, but if you're going to write conditions on it that means pulling it down, writing on it, putting it back up -- that's a lot of fiddling.
That's why I love the post-it flags. For a few bucks you can get a pack with multiple colors. You can write a little something on the flag so you can remember what it is, and just stick it on the card so it sticks up where it's visible to everyone. The cards don't have to come down, flags are easy to re-use as conditions get passed around, etc.
Wednesday, 21st November, 2012, 12:35 AM #8
Novice (Lvl 1)
- Join Date
- Dec 2010
° Ignore golem64
Initiative-less Dungeon World
We're going to try Dungeon World this week which is supposed to dispense with initiative. Not sure how my players will react to this, so I'm bringing my combat pad just in case.
Wednesday, 21st November, 2012, 02:47 AM #9
Myrmidon (Lvl 10)
By Frylock in forum Miscellaneous Geek Talk & Media LoungeReplies: 23Last Post: Friday, 22nd June, 2007, 02:02 PM
By dagger in forum D&D and PathfinderReplies: 13Last Post: Sunday, 4th March, 2007, 10:58 PM
By Alpha Polaris in forum D&D and PathfinderReplies: 83Last Post: Wednesday, 14th February, 2007, 03:27 PM
By darkelfo in forum D&D and PathfinderReplies: 9Last Post: Monday, 25th April, 2005, 08:35 PM
By Wolfix in forum RPGs & Tabletop Gaming DiscussionReplies: 16Last Post: Friday, 3rd September, 2004, 06:38 PM