How do you fit monks into Occidental campaigns?

pawsplay · Nov 5, 2010

Hungry Like The Wolf said:
It astounds me that people think like this. It's easy to say you'd be amused from a place of privilege. As an Asian dnd player, I can tell you most assuredly the monk is no walk in the park.

The class is tolerable. People doing terrible racist accents and playing up stereotypes while playing that class isn't.

I'm not even Asian, and I can't figure out what's up with sticking Okinawan weapons, samurai throwing stars, and a made up Malaysian weapon from the Palladium Book of Exotic Weapons and giving them to Cain from kung fu, to represent legendary Asia in fantasy. I mean, seriously, and no spears or curved broadswords, either?

What D&D needs is a Brother Man class that wields zulu spears, khopeshes, pool cues, and five-bladed swords.

Ok, time for me to walk away from the thread...

prosfilaes · Nov 5, 2010

Hungry Like The Wolf said:
People doing terrible racist accents and playing up stereotypes while playing that class isn't.

Because people doing terrible racists accents and playing up stereotypes while playing dwarves as A-OK.

Hungry Like The Wolf · Nov 5, 2010

prosfilaes said:
Because people doing terrible racists accents and playing up stereotypes while playing dwarves as A-OK.

No it's not but I'm not British, if a Brit found it offensive then it's on him to speak up. However, you're barking up the wrong tree as I've never play a Dwarf or had one in a campaign that I've run. I have, on numerous occasions, had to sit through offensive behaviour in fear of being "the over-sensitive minority".

mach1.9pants · Nov 5, 2010

Whereas the cool thing (well interesting) is that the Monks in Greyhawk, IIRC, are blond haired blue eyed quasi Aryan-supremacists! ADnD Greyhawk Monks were my first Monks -weren't they Mystics or some-such in BECMI? I haven't my book in front of me.

Anyway, OnT, I have no problem including Monks in my otherwise 100% western European DnD games. Cos as Pawsplay says, polytheism and western Europe do not mix. If there was polytheism throughout western Europe's history it would not look at all like the middle ages as I play it (or it actually was). I let it ride. It is a game.

And I like Monks. And Bards. And Half-orc Fighter-Assassins.

There is room for all.

Rassilon · Nov 12, 2010

Hungry Like The Wolf said:
No it's not but I'm not British, if a Brit found it offensive then it's on him to speak up. However, you're barking up the wrong tree as I've never play a Dwarf or had one in a campaign that I've run. I have, on numerous occasions, had to sit through offensive behaviour in fear of being "the over-sensitive minority".

And now you've offended all the British people. Because everyone knows that Dwarves are Scottish; and the Britains who aren't Scottish are offended at being confused with Scottish, and the Scots are offended at being labelled merely 'British'...

prosfilaes · Nov 12, 2010

Hungry Like The Wolf said:
No it's not but I'm not British, if a Brit found it offensive then it's on him to speak up. However, you're barking up the wrong tree as I've never play a Dwarf or had one in a campaign that I've run. I have, on numerous occasions, had to sit through offensive behaviour in fear of being "the over-sensitive minority".

I see your behavior as unproductive; you see no need to stand up for others, and you refuse to stand up for yourself, so nothing will ever change. And by requiring a person of that minority to stand up for themself, you're letting this behavior become normalized in society and making anyone who complains seem to be that over-sensitive minority.

Plane Sailing · Nov 12, 2010

Rassilon said:
And now you've offended all the British people. Because everyone knows that Dwarves are Scottish; and the Britains who aren't Scottish are offended at being confused with Scottish, and the Scots are offended at being labelled merely 'British'...

Amongst Brits I know, Dwarves are more likely to have Russian accents than Scottish. In my last campaign all Dwarves had Klingon accents and culture.

El Mahdi · Nov 12, 2010

Plane Sailing said:
Amongst Brits I know, Dwarves are more likely to have Russian accents than Scottish. In my last campaign all Dwarves had Klingon accents and culture.

Were they modeled after Original Series Klingons, or Next Gen/Movie Klingons...or is that something you don't talk about...?

...and I almost forgot - In Russia, accent has you...

gamerprinter · Nov 12, 2010

If you're running a 'western setting' but you have a large coastal city, then include a 'china town' neighborhood of 'chinese' immigrants, and get some monk love in that way. I've done that for several campaign.

GP

ProfessorCirno · Nov 12, 2010

I find it horrifyingly hilarious that people are jumping on a guy who literally just said "Yeah I'm asian and it's incredibly horrible when people turn the monk into a racist stereotype."

Seriously? We're going to get mad at someone for saying "Yo don't be racist?"

How do you fit monks into Occidental campaigns?

pawsplay

Hero

prosfilaes

Adventurer

Hungry Like The Wolf

First Post

mach1.9pants

Hero

Rassilon

First Post

prosfilaes

Adventurer

Plane Sailing

Astral Admin - Mwahahaha!

El Mahdi

Muad'Dib of the Anauroch

gamerprinter

Mapper/Publisher

ProfessorCirno

Banned

Similar Threads