Players in my game got themselves caught in a good old bar fight. Flying chairs, broken bottles, etc. Everyone was fighting.
One of the bouncers, sword in hand, takes its chances against the Battlemaster. Bad luck, the Battlemaster keeps shoving and hitting him when he's down. The guy just can’t get up.
The PCs are clearly winning so the remaining "bad guys" scatter into the night. Everyone except our bouncer, who decide to yield.
Battlemaster "I kill him"
DM (me) "What?"
Battlemaster "I kill him"
DM (still me) "He's no threat, he's got his hands in the air"
Battlemaster "He tried to kill me, I kill him"
Coup de grace, bouncer's dead.
I didn't say anything and we kept on gaming and having fun. Now, thinking back on it, I keep wondering, was this act evil?
One of the bouncers, sword in hand, takes its chances against the Battlemaster. Bad luck, the Battlemaster keeps shoving and hitting him when he's down. The guy just can’t get up.
The PCs are clearly winning so the remaining "bad guys" scatter into the night. Everyone except our bouncer, who decide to yield.
Battlemaster "I kill him"
DM (me) "What?"
Battlemaster "I kill him"
DM (still me) "He's no threat, he's got his hands in the air"
Battlemaster "He tried to kill me, I kill him"
Coup de grace, bouncer's dead.
I didn't say anything and we kept on gaming and having fun. Now, thinking back on it, I keep wondering, was this act evil?