D&D 5E Monk rules question

Baph0met

First Post
This is specifically regarding the Path of the Kensei feature "Agile Parry"

Agile Parry states: "If you make an unarmed strike as part of the Attack Action on your turn and are holding a Kensei weapon, you can use it to defend yourself if it is a melee weapon. You gain a +2 bonus to AC until the start of your next turn, while the weapon is in your hand and you aren't incapacitated."

Does this mean that a Kensei must be holding a Kensei weapon WHEN he makes that unarmed strike during the Attack Action to trigger Agile Parry, or could he draw a weapon after making the attack? Can he trigger Agile Parry by making an unarmed strike, then drop the weapon (foregoing the bonus AC for the moment) but pick it up again before the end of the Attack Action to "reclaim" the bonus from Agile Parry? If yes would it need to be the SAME weapon or could the Kensei draw a NEW Kensei weapon?

According to Sage Advice, droping a weapon does not count as "interacting with an object/environment" which a character may do once per turn during either their move or (attack) action. Since 5e allows players to split up their Movement between Attacks during their Attack Action, is it possible for a Kensei to hold one weapon, make an unarmed strike triggering Agile Parry, drop that weapon, move, attack a new target, draw a new weapon, and still claim the bonus AC from Agile Parry?
 

log in or register to remove this ad


Oofta

Legend
I would rule that you need to be holding the weapon your entire turn to get the benefit since it states "If you make an unarmed strike as part of the Attack action on your turn and are holding a kensei weapon, you can use it to defend yourself if it is a melee weapon".

But why would you need to drop your weapon? Unarmed strikes can be kicks, elbows, head butts, etc. There's nothing stopping you from making an unarmed attack just because you could have attacked with your weapon.
 


Baph0met

First Post
Player wants to hold a crossbow (crossbow expert) and a Longsword at the same time, take the attack action at lvl 5, to deliver an unarmed strike with the first attack (a kick) proccing Agile Parry, then drop the sword, shoot the crossbow with the second attack during the attack action and use the crossbow expert's bonus action to fire the crossbow again (with hand free) and then pick up the sword.
 


G

Guest 6801328

Guest
Normally I would simply rule "no", but this situation may require not only ruling "no" but also hitting the player with something heavy.
 

FrogReaver

As long as i get to be the frog
the part that says "and are holding a kensi weapon" isn't qualified with an on your turn or when you attack or etc. so it's ambiguous. DM is fully in his right to rule out the ambiguity any way he sees fit.
 

As it is worded it should be fine. The benefit duration isn't until you release the weapon, only the effect of the benefit itself. I don't see an issue with it really.
 

Yunru

Banned
Banned
Player wants to hold a crossbow (crossbow expert) and a Longsword at the same time, take the attack action at lvl 5, to deliver an unarmed strike with the first attack (a kick) proccing Agile Parry, then drop the sword, shoot the crossbow with the second attack during the attack action and use the crossbow expert's bonus action to fire the crossbow again (with hand free) and then pick up the sword.

Instead the player should shoot with the crossbow, shoot with the crossbow as a bonus action, then make the melee attack after pickup up/drawing the sword.
 

Remove ads

Top