Search Results - Morrus' Unofficial Tabletop RPG News

Search:

Type: Posts; User: robus

Page 1 of 26 1 2 3 4

Search: Search took 0.08 seconds.

  1. Replies
    56
    Views
    1,029

    This thread contains a poll. The action is the character recalling their...

    The action is the character recalling their knowledge and experience for help in interpreting the tracks. Yes, they're not moving their body, but that doesn't mean they're not doing something. And by...
  2. Replies
    20
    Views
    469

    You could also create a new "Parkour" skill that...

    You could also create a new "Parkour" skill that covers both acrobatics and athletics. :) If the players want to climb walls (where there's some cost of failure, of course) I would ask for Strength...
  3. Replies
    11
    Views
    649

    Doesn’t Xanathar’s Guide add some magic item...

    Doesn’t Xanathar’s Guide add some magic item creation rules (ok guidelines...)?
  4. It seems to me that once you have the broad...

    It seems to me that once you have the broad strokes of the campaign world sketched in: what are the playable races/classes and what generally is the setting: hot/cold/temperate (helps when choosing...
  5. It really could be anything from medieval type...

    It really could be anything from medieval type witch-hunter, through Dracula, and into Cthulhu (and perhaps even to some kind of Doom/Quake type scenario, so leaving the gothic there a bit :)) The...
  6. And as the most recent threadcrapper, I’ll make...

    And as the most recent threadcrapper, I’ll make an effort to get it back on the rails...

    Other genre’s I’d like to apply D&D?

    * Humans vs creatures of the night. Basically gothic horror type of...
  7. How about starting it over with a “no guns...

    How about starting it over with a “no guns allowed” proviso? :)
  8. Not to me, HP loss is modeling the effort to turn...

    Not to me, HP loss is modeling the effort to turn that potentially lethal knife blow into just a scratch, requiring both mental and physical effort. For a gun fight I would say HP is simply tracking...
  9. Yeah I’m probably too wedded to my interpretation...

    Yeah I’m probably too wedded to my interpretation of HP to bend it towards firearms against PCs. Not that I’d run a game like that in D&D anyway. So it was mostly a thought experiment.
  10. To me, HP works to model your ability to defend...

    To me, HP works to model your ability to defend against these attacks, generally they’re attacks you can see coming or come at a speed (if ranged) that you can react to in time to reduce the lethal...
  11. My point was that HP should only come into play...

    My point was that HP should only come into play when the defending character is putting up a fight. They don’t model a character’s ability to dumbly absorb damage, but to actively resist damage.
  12. It's all fun and games until the lead starts...

    It's all fun and games until the lead starts flying... :)
  13. I mis-spoke, I meant "point", but I take your...

    I mis-spoke, I meant "point", but I take your point :)



    Sure, I'm just not sure it'll give the right feel for me is all.
  14. Well, I'm not that kind of DM. :) It's actually...

    Well, I'm not that kind of DM. :) It's actually entirely feasible for me, as DM, to kill any PC, at any moment, for any reason, but that wouldn't be much fun would it?
  15. I addressed that by discussing the fact that HP...

    I addressed that by discussing the fact that HP is recording your ability to defend yourself from the attack. If you're not defending yourself then that dagger attack is going to kill you no matter...
  16. Sure, there are solutions in *some settings*, but...

    Sure, there are solutions in *some settings*, but most action adventure scenarios don't have people running around in kevlar :)
  17. HP, in my opinion, is not plot armor, it is...

    HP, in my opinion, is not plot armor, it is tracking a character’s ability to continue to defend themself from attack. It’s why HP shouldn’t factor into PCs taking out sleeping baddies. If they’ve...
  18. I’ll bite. Leaving guns aside, I think the...

    I’ll bite.

    Leaving guns aside, I think the best way to apply D&D rules to a different genre is to basically remove player options that aren’t appropriate. While WotC seems to want to allow all...
  19. Just dropping in to say that I've found this...

    Just dropping in to say that I've found this thread to be really informative for this style of campaign.
  20. Ah I was thinking it would entail a less...

    Ah I was thinking it would entail a less fantastical adventuring world.
  21. My issue with D&D rules in other genres is...

    My issue with D&D rules in other genres is challenging the characters at higher levels given their HP and damage dealing increases. In the Age of Sail setting, for example, how does that work out? Or...
  22. interesting. My issue with adapting 5e to these...

    interesting. My issue with adapting 5e to these purposes is scaling monster CRs to the higher PC levels. One hopes there are suitable monsters/aliens for the higher levels.
  23. A “whoosh” for me then! :D

    A “whoosh” for me then! :D
  24. Have you considered the Guildmasters Guide to...

    Have you considered the Guildmasters Guide to Ravnica? It includes an intro adventure and the book has tons of lore for him to devour once the adventure is complete?
  25. I’m not aware of that old saw. I thought...

    I’m not aware of that old saw. I thought “political correctness” was invented to dismiss people’s efforts to “treat people with respect”?! That’s how it seemed in the 90s at least...
  26. My theory on this is because it’s the combination...

    My theory on this is because it’s the combination of two major forces: male supremacy and social media amplification. Male supremacy has been taken for granted, basically forever, and now there is...
  27. Replies
    11
    Views
    649

    They had to draw the line somewhere and knew they...

    They had to draw the line somewhere and knew they had Out of the Abyss in the plan to fill in those gaps.



    It’s a good question. Stamina seems like a fine skill. My question would be they just...
  28. Replies
    10
    Views
    506

    i feel your pain. most of WotC’s contributions...

    i feel your pain. most of WotC’s contributions leave much to be desired, Dragon Heist especially has been maligned here at least. You’ve not mentioned Tomb of Annihilation? While I wouldn’t go with...
  29. Replies
    44
    Views
    1,469

    I wish WotC would take this advice!

    I wish WotC would take this advice!
  30. Replies
    7
    Views
    418

    These look cool, but the missing element is the...

    These look cool, but the missing element is the motivation for these villains. Why are they doing these things now? For example, to what purpose is the powerful necromancer raising legions and why...
  31. Replies
    44
    Views
    1,469

    No.

    No.
  32. Replies
    6
    Views
    478

    It seems unfortunate that WotC didn't rescale...

    It seems unfortunate that WotC didn't rescale vessels from tiny to huge. Having a 20x10 ft sloop described as gargantuan seems very strange. :) These seem like more reasonable categories for vessels:...
  33. Replies
    33
    Views
    1,297

    Instead of asking for what you're missing,...

    Instead of asking for what you're missing, perhaps tell us what you're looking for? :)

    More monsters? Tomb of Beasts and Creature Codex add a bunch of variety.

    More treasure? Arcanis: Forged in...
  34. Replies
    106
    Views
    3,866

    Oooh, you got me! Actually it’s the most...

    Oooh, you got me!



    Actually it’s the most brutal criticism because you’re saying that it is so far removed from D&D that it is not even worthy of discussion. It is apparently “meaningless” in...
  35. Replies
    106
    Views
    3,866

    Calling a legitimate D&D game meaningless, when...

    Calling a legitimate D&D game meaningless, when it’s probably the most meaningful game around? We’re all ace DMs but no-one actually sees our game. This one guy (and players) actually show a game and...
  36. Replies
    11
    Views
    488

    Way too little info to provide useful advice, and...

    Way too little info to provide useful advice, and your tone makes it appear that you’re in over your head?!

    What is your experience level? And why have you apparently rejected the published...
  37. Replies
    106
    Views
    3,866

    You guys need to stop maligning the show. It...

    You guys need to stop maligning the show. It started before they began streaming and will likely continue after we all move onto the next big thing. It’s incredibly hard to perform for an absent...
  38. Yeah random generators have their place but this...

    Yeah random generators have their place but this is not it. A good villain and threat needs some design (and motivation). Perhaps that’s the key. We at least need to know why the villain is doing...
  39. Yeah, but this is for when there are no published...

    Yeah, but this is for when there are no published adventures for the setting :)
  40. I also want to give a big thumbs up to the Time...

    I also want to give a big thumbs up to the Time Tracker on DMs Guild: https://www.dmsguild.com/product/253286/Time-Tracker

    It’s been great to have a clock sitting right in the middle of the table...
  41. Would campaign skeletons address the lack of adventures for minor settings?

    CapnZapp raised an interesting point in the Expanse thread on the lack of adventures for settings once the rulebook is published.

    Now we all know writing a comprehensive adventure path/campaign is...
  42. That was fun, sad that it had to be so rushed...

    That was fun, sad that it had to be so rushed though. A 3 hour game with a couple of fellow adventurers would be awesome. Really hope he makes it an annual charity event with fellow celebs (and run...
  43. After two sessions the adventurers have made it...

    After two sessions the adventurers have made it to the gate of the hill top town the provides the location for the main adventure. Our party has grown to 7 which is quite a handful, and the players...
  44. Replies
    58
    Views
    1,844

    Something I've been toying with is using the...

    Something I've been toying with is using the Constitution score to handle "out of combat" knocking out situations. Reducing a guard to 0 HP just to knock them out doesn't fit my vision of how...
  45. Not sure why it is. Bonus actions should be...

    Not sure why it is. Bonus actions should be listed after actions as Reactions are. This is a good reason (among others) to transcribe them into a format you can use at the table. I find the...
  46. Well that was kind of like herding cats! A table...

    Well that was kind of like herding cats! A table of 6 newbies that all kind of want to do their own thing is hard to wrangle!

    It seems they all had fun though and are keen for the next session, so...
  47. Caustic? I’m frankly amazed. Biting sure, because...

    Caustic? I’m frankly amazed. Biting sure, because it’s on target. But caustic?

    Anyway MNblockhead has it right. He’s a huge geek and a D&D player from way back. This should be pretty entertaining...
  48. First session kicks off tonight. 7 players! All...

    First session kicks off tonight. 7 players! All pretty much novices. Looking forward to that new player smell! :D
  49. A good option for maintaining a serious mood is...

    A good option for maintaining a serious mood is to just have things generally turn against the party. Some general misfortune is suffered rather than singling out the poor player who rolled the one.
  50. An interesting list, not sure I agree 100% but...

    An interesting list, not sure I agree 100% but it’s a decent starting point.

    1. Make it your story.
    I think the best goal is your (DMs) story mixed in with the PCs stories. In other words they...
  51. Yeah I was trying to be funny. And I’m not sure...

    Yeah I was trying to be funny. And I’m not sure there’s been many (any?) positive reviews of that starter set.



    I believe he has his hand in pretty much every product so far? I think he’s the...
  52. I love the “warmly received” description of the...

    I love the “warmly received” description of the Stranger Things starter set... I guess “hated with the heat of nine suns” could be described as “warm”?!

    A Chris Perkins authored starter set also...
  53. The pie chart does give the impression that 5e is...

    The pie chart does give the impression that 5e is chomping down on all the others...
  54. Replies
    46
    Views
    1,698

    OK dude, you're obviously up in arms over this....

    OK dude, you're obviously up in arms over this. Good luck on your vendetta.
  55. Replies
    46
    Views
    1,698

    If you like complex battlefields and players...

    If you like complex battlefields and players making precise tactical choices then, yes, TotM is not going to give you the granularity you need. It's for more casual tables that want the story of...
  56. Replies
    46
    Views
    1,698

    Huh, I checked out your link and my eyes rolled...

    Huh, I checked out your link and my eyes rolled back in my head with all the detail. While Volanin has admitted to being inspired by some of the approaches described there, there's nothing like the...
  57. Replies
    46
    Views
    1,698

    The Roshambo approach to TotM addresses a lot of...

    The Roshambo approach to TotM addresses a lot of these tactical issue with a very neat system. Check it out if you haven't already. (I linked to it earlier in the thread).
  58. Replies
    46
    Views
    1,698

    It's the DMs job to keep track of the state of...

    It's the DMs job to keep track of the state of the combat and clearly narrate the situation for the current player. The players job is to simply pay attention to the ongoing narration and be ready...
  59. Replies
    46
    Views
    1,698

    I think this might be a failure of a DM narrating...

    I think this might be a failure of a DM narrating the results of the action. With TotM (as Iserith noted above) narration is key. The DM has to keep telling the story of the battle and reminding the...
  60. Replies
    46
    Views
    1,698

    If you’ve not read the Roshambo approach to TotM...

    If you’ve not read the Roshambo approach to TotM combat, do it, it’s cool and puts a lot of new options back in front of players....
  61. Replies
    42
    Views
    2,783

    I love your style in these. The top down...

    I love your style in these. The top down perspective effect is very effective. I imagine you cook these up in Photoshop?
  62. Whoosh! I’m done with this.

    Whoosh! I’m done with this.
  63. It’s actually a neologism (language evolves, who...

    It’s actually a neologism (language evolves, who knew?!) to describe exactly what Scott was doing:



    While the quote is from somewhere else, there’s more here if you’re interested:...
  64. Replies
    3
    Views
    383

    You can’t take a gamble with < $2? :) Two 5 star...

    You can’t take a gamble with < $2? :) Two 5 star reviews already makes it seem a safe bet if you’re in the market...
  65. Simple question for men. When you leave your...

    Simple question for men. When you leave your house do you *ever* think about how you will avoid, or protect yourself against, sexual assault? I know I don’t and nor do most men. Women do, though, all...
  66. Really not wanting to get dragged into a...

    Really not wanting to get dragged into a “debate”. Is there a culture of sexual harassment/assault against men? No. Is there against women? Yes. The pushback is part of an effort to change the...
  67. Let’s cool it with the himpathy. Men have been...

    Let’s cool it with the himpathy. Men have been :):):):):):):)s to women for millennia and now we get some pushback it’s “oh no, his life is ruined”. I know too many women whose lives have been...
  68. Replies
    296
    Views
    13,497

    That’s a pretty brutal exposé, wow! Edit: and...

    That’s a pretty brutal exposé, wow!

    Edit: and I was wondering why this wasn’t on Kickstarter...
  69. Replies
    22
    Views
    928

    I'll bear that in mind if/when I kick off a new...

    I'll bear that in mind if/when I kick off a new campaign :) - at the moment, I'm just wanting to swap my dull predictable ending with something with a bit flash and bang. Something that'll last 6-8...
  70. Replies
    22
    Views
    928

    That's cool.

    That's cool.
  71. Replies
    22
    Views
    928

    @Ovinomancer...

    @Ovinomancer - I do love the idea that as soon as they liberate the wizard for this one infraction, he's immediately arrested by the Marut for meddling with the timeline. It has taken all this time...
  72. Replies
    22
    Views
    928

    That does sound cool, but sadly that's not the...

    That does sound cool, but sadly that's not the type of play experience my group enjoys. They're more driven by exploration and adventure (which is why the Underdark has become a drag - despite my...
  73. Replies
    22
    Views
    928

    Folks that own Dungeon of the Mad Mage: what is...

    Folks that own Dungeon of the Mad Mage: what is Halaster's Home like as a mini-dungeon? Wondering if I can scavenge it for parts for this new direction? (I guess I'll take a leaf through this...
  74. Replies
    73
    Views
    8,399

    I think this thread is heading in a predictable...

    I think this thread is heading in a predictable direction. Mods, can we please lock it down before the mud starts really flying? I can feel my temperature rising at least! :)
  75. Oh and there’s no such thing as a skill check in...

    Oh and there’s no such thing as a skill check in 5e. It’s always an ability check and sometimes you can your proficiency bonus if you have an applicable skill.
  76. I’m not sure this the easy approach :) I...

    I’m not sure this the easy approach :)

    I thought you were going to start with how easy the core system of the game is to master. I.e. the fundamental conversation that drives the game. Then you...
  77. Replies
    73
    Views
    8,399

    Nothing, but it’s got a lot to do with Gnome...

    Nothing, but it’s got a lot to do with Gnome Paladins...
  78. Replies
    22
    Views
    928

    This is quite inspiring for the pocket dimension...

    This is quite inspiring for the pocket dimension (inside the "globe") :

    106361

    From here: https://www.artstation.com/artwork/APG8V
  79. Replies
    296
    Views
    13,497

    No consensus as there are good arguments on both...

    No consensus as there are good arguments on both sides. Paizo is caught on the horns of a dilemma. Shift to 5e compatible products and potentially reap larger profits (from the larger market) at the...
  80. Replies
    296
    Views
    13,497

    As the Capn notes, this has been thoroughly...

    As the Capn notes, this has been thoroughly debated throughout this thread. Take a tour through the earlier posts.
  81. Replies
    22
    Views
    928

    Yeah - a similar thought came to mind too. That...

    Yeah - a similar thought came to mind too. That would be very cool - trying to avoid demons being the big bad though :)

    My current thought is that in the new time-line he "borrowed" the "tome of...
  82. Replies
    296
    Views
    13,497

    I'm not sure what you mean by that? PF and 5e are...

    I'm not sure what you mean by that? PF and 5e are pretty fundamentally incompatible? :)
  83. I dunno, the Dutch generally speak better English...

    I dunno, the Dutch generally speak better English than the natives! Let’s just just call this what it probably is. Someone tried to avoid doing original work and got caught.
  84. Ouch!

    Ouch!
  85. Replies
    296
    Views
    13,497

    Yep my daughter grew up quite the nerd, Star Trek...

    Yep my daughter grew up quite the nerd, Star Trek characters at halloween, devouring Harry Potter. Briefly turned away during high school (as you do), but now thoroughly happy to indulge her...
  86. Replies
    22
    Views
    928

    I see there's a Lich Queen adventure on DMs Guild...

    I see there's a Lich Queen adventure on DMs Guild by M T Black. That might be a good resource (as well as Mordenkainan's of course). But I don't want things to get too dark and dreary :)
  87. Replies
    22
    Views
    928

    Players want to get all the way to 20 - first...

    Players want to get all the way to 20 - first time ever for all of them. Just weren't loving the Underdark (and the somewhat repetitive plot - my doing, but I also thought we'd be done by now but...
  88. Replies
    22
    Views
    928

    Really wanting to wish those Demon Lords away :)...

    Really wanting to wish those Demon Lords away :) so this is reboot.
  89. "Enlightenment" :D

    "Enlightenment" :D
  90. Replies
    22
    Views
    928

    Blowing up my campaign

    The rumblings of dissatisfaction have gotten stronger and I'm getting bored too of my high level reboot of OotA. It's just too samey and the grand finale is basically more of the same with knobs on....
  91. Replies
    18
    Views
    620

    Sounds like you have it in hand. Glad you found...

    Sounds like you have it in hand. Glad you found some of it useful.
  92. Yeah I’m guilty of that, trying to wean myself...

    Yeah I’m guilty of that, trying to wean myself off it.
  93. Replies
    18
    Views
    620

    Leather goddesses of Phobos! :)

    Leather goddesses of Phobos! :)
  94. Replies
    18
    Views
    620

    And here's my feedback on the latest update: ...

    And here's my feedback on the latest update:

    General:

    * Page numbering - nice to see them - but having them down at the bottom centered would make them more obvious :)
    * Synopsis - this is...
  95. Replies
    18
    Views
    620

    Cool, I'll have a read over lunch :)

    Cool, I'll have a read over lunch :)
  96. Thread: New boxed set

    by robus
    Replies
    33
    Views
    2,011

    All I can say is I ran it as a first time DM and...

    All I can say is I ran it as a first time DM and I felt overwhelmed and confused from the get go (despite devouring the PHB and the Basic Rules).



    More annotations and advice in the actual...
  97. I’ve learned that the adventures work much better...

    I’ve learned that the adventures work much better when you devise your own connecting story for the events. WotC seems to have no feel for story (or they just tack some stuff on the end and hope no...
  98. Replies
    296
    Views
    13,497

    How are you judging that? Not saying it’s not, I...

    How are you judging that? Not saying it’s not, I just haven’t seen evidence of it?
  99. Replies
    18
    Views
    620

    Don't overthink it. The basic system is simple....

    Don't overthink it. The basic system is simple. Leave HP out of it (you keep mentioning health but that's not a thing in 5e so I think you're talking about HP?) Use Advantage/Disadvantage where...
  100. Scott Graves - if you've not looked at Storm...

    Scott Graves - if you've not looked at Storm King's Thunder, the second half slots in beautifully to the overall ToD campaign and helps explain why the giants are sitting out the plot. The chromatic...
Results 1 to 100 of 2552
Page 1 of 26 1 2 3 4