G
Guest 6801328
Guest
And accepting that a fellow PC might be a decent guy worth listening to in a tight spot is a pretty darn small amount of agency to cede. I mean, does mastermind rogue cause that same amount of agita when he uses the help action to give you advantage? "Gosh darn it, I don't accept your PC is actually smart enough to help me in combat!"
There's further evidence you don't understand.
Go read the fluff for "Master of Tactics" and show me where it implies anything at all about how the target PC feels about the rogue. The only fluff relates to the Rogue him/herself, not his/her relationship with the other PC. Which means it can easily be narrated as interfering with the monster. Or just about any other way, depending on how the other player wants to participate.
The reality is that in practice, I would be totally happy to let the Rogue give me expert guidance, or whatever. I just don't want that interaction built into a particular class.