ECMO3's latest activity

For most PCs from the Fighter, Monk and Rogue classes I think casting spells is something they do. So I don't believe this is true in...

I can't comment much on top tier play with D&D2024, having only played through a single level 20 one-shot and watched a few actual play...

That may be the distinction when you are white rooming it and talking about classes, but when you are talking about actual PCs I think...

Being "not a bad business tactic" (and that is debatable) is not the same as being a "successful business tactic"

Creamcloud said the first two were not martials. This illustrates the problem, we can't even agree on what we are talking about here as...

A few of the higher level martial features are equal or better than a 5th level spell (Indomitable for one off the top of my head). I...

All things which were part of 2E. You are saying 2E was a failure because of how they rolled out the new edition, not because they...

Ok, that still does not explain the logic regarding why releasing 2E was a "successful business tactic" There is absolutely no evidence...

Personally, I think Martial and Caster are talking about two different things, two different traits and they are not exclusionary. IMO...

Ok. Then we accepted that spells are ok on a martial (i.e. High Elf Champion), so logically spells are a viable way to balance them at...

i think we need some definitions. So a Ranger, paladin or High elf champion are not martials on this discussion? Reguarding high-level...

Giving martials spells does not kill martials, they are still martials with spells (like Rqangers and Paladins already are). Also I am...

I don't think this is true. Plenty of people love fighters, and other martials. I don't think very many people like non-casters...

No I mean spell slots and spells prepared. They are still martials, Rangers and Paladins all cast spells, would you say they are not...

First off this is not the easiest way. By far the easiest way to close the gap at levels where casters are better is to leave the...