Enrahim's latest activity

Not one person though; one side.

So what you say is that this won't stop until trad players are accurately describing nar play, and nar players are accurately describing...

Have you met this group? :P

That's fine. I disagree, and I think there is a clear difference with bundling that roll into the player's roll--and your language, 'let...

I think you are purposfully twisting "made up for the pc" here. While it technically is true in the everyday meaning of these words...

The clear message sure seems to be that if they were experienced they'd like it just as much as you. That's the problem. Because we...

I'm not talking about preferences here or ignorance. I'm talking about experience. Narrative games run differently than trad games. If...

The fiction always allows for several possible outcomes, as far as I can see. Eg the player has their PC sneak into a house via the...

Yes, I am sorry. I didn't realize before it was too late. I edited my previous post but clearly after you already had started writing...

Doesn't seem like the determinism strawman :) Good. Why is an outcome/event needed if this isn't "because the logic of the fiction...

No in-fiction reason for what before which rolling of the dice? I thought the what here was "characters are surprised" and the "which"...

In games that use "fail forward" adjudication, the roll is functionally related to the consequence that gets narrated: the whole point...

This is cool! The thing is that it is the prior state of the fiction that informs the GM's choice whether to use the tool or not ;)...

I think this points to 2 important things. The first is that in both "GM driven" and interpret the result play the "metaphysics of...

Where how I read the kind of trad @Faolyn appeared to want to discuss in this reply chain being exactly what you describe as "the most...