Paul Farquhar's latest activity

I meant the exact quote, since lots of things you say are in the rules, are your inferences, not part of the text.

Source?

True Strike is a Sorcerer spell you cast. No one is arguing against that. *presuming you took it as a Sorcerer It's an attack...

Question Max. Is your position that the attack with the weapon is part of the spell but the attack roll with the weapon is not? Or is...

This. It's an attack. That's the only condition. You're adding a word that isn't there. It says "Advantage on the attack rolls" Not...

Which are exactly the games played by forum theorycrafters, not the general public.

Which is completely irrelevant - the ability says nothing about components or “spell attacks” either way. Maybe think about what the...

No. The rules do not state that. You are doing “the rules state X therefore Y follows…” when that is not at all implied.

Thats fair. Folks who enjoy 5E constantly being told its bad and that being popular is no substitute for "objectively" better design but...

Nope. Most of the players wanted the game to stay as it was. Which is what we got. It’s only forum theorycrafters who always want stuff...

That seems unlikely to me. In a truly equal and multicultural society it seems to me that kind of relationship would be a quirky...

There was a lot of wailing during the beta test and when BG3 first came out that being good was not sufficiently “rewarding”. I do think...

A “drastic shift” is a bad idea. When people buy a game called D&D they expect to be able to play D&D, not some other game, no matter...

That's at best though. No risk of open playtest revealing that the whole system/concept was a bad idea? Essentials didnt save 4E...

She was already on the Enterprise as a non-Starfleet scientist when they met. So I think we have to assume that there are a significant...