Search results

  1. Gantros

    On being self centered - Spells that is

    You're right, the rules for this are ambiguous. Other spells in the SRD besides Control Weather that have "centered on you" in their area of effect but don't specify if they move with the caster (and are not instantaneous or burst effects) include Crown of Glory, Locate Object, and Repel Vermin...
  2. Gantros

    Silly rules thoughts

    I don't think this is silly at all. Dealing with magic in a game like D&D can get pretty messy if you don't attempt to apply some logic and internal consistency to it. The rules for catching on fire state that once a character fails their Reflex Save, not only do they start taking fire damage...
  3. Gantros

    Polymorph Any Object question- Types and Subtypes

    Actually the answer is yes. The rules for the Polymorph spell explicitly state, "The subject’s creature type and subtype (if any) change to match the new form." And as was pointed out, this characteristic is inherited by PAO. As for taking forms with templates, these are disallowed in the...
  4. Gantros

    D&D 3E/3.5 figments in combat (3.5)

    Here are some more ideas for Silent Image: Baiting an ambush or trap Creating an illusion of a wall, bush, etc. slightly displaced from its true position, so allies can hide or move stealthily behind it Creating a diversion (e.g. a pile of treasure to distract greedy creatures, a...
  5. Gantros

    Graphics card recommendations

    For the best recommendation I'd need to know your budget, your monitor resolution, and what kinds of games you expect to play. Typically a mid-level card like your old GTS 240 would be something in the $100-150 range, which is enough to run demanding games at 1680x1050 resolution, or even...
  6. Gantros

    "Everyday" Spells

    Monte Cook posted some of his ideas for everyday spells here: Everyday Magic
  7. Gantros

    Explosive Rune Goodness

    That seems like a valid tactic for insta-killing a powerful opponent, though it obviously requires a lot of preparation, and still has to contend with spell resistance. And even if you managed to overcome the Tarrasque's SR, its regeneration means your victory would only last a couple of...
  8. Gantros

    Explosive Rune Goodness

    It's on pg. 81 of the PHB, under the Search skill description. It's also repeated on pg. 172 in the section describing Abjuration. The meaning of a Search DC of 0 is open to interpretation, but I think it's fair to assume it would apply to something that is plainly obvious to anyone within 10...
  9. Gantros

    Explosive Rune Goodness

    Don't forget this little rule though... If one abjuration spell is active within 10 feet of another for 24 hours or more, the magical fields interfere with each other and create barely visible energy fluctuations. The DC to find such spells with the Search skill drops by 4. So once you have 3...
  10. Gantros

    In Defense of the Theory of Dissociated Mechanics

    I'd like to try nudging this discussion in a different, hopefully more productive direction. There seems to be a pretty clear divide between the people here who grok the idea of dissociated mechanics and take issue with them, and those that have a "blind spot" for them (either not understanding...
  11. Gantros

    In Defense of the Theory of Dissociated Mechanics

    I think you're still missing the distinction between abstraction and association. Certainly HP, saves, and besieged foe all involve a fair amount of abstraction. The difference is that the mechanics for the latter are not associated with a description of the in-game actions they are supposed...
  12. Gantros

    In Defense of the Theory of Dissociated Mechanics

    Just wanted to point out that none of these are examples of dissociated mechanics, as defined in the Alexandrian essay. #1, 6, 7 & 8 are examples of metagaming, in which out-of-game information or resources (such as player's knowledge of the pros & cons of various races, or DM's knowledge of...
  13. Gantros

    disintegration v regeneration

    It's actually interesting to see how this bit of rules text has changed with each Monster Manual. In MM III & IV, they removed "disintegration" as an example, but left "most poisons". In MM V, they removed the examples altogether (including poisons), which matches the SRD text. This would...
  14. Gantros

    Did gem dragons get updated to 3.5?

    I believe this is the link you're looking for.
  15. Gantros

    Arcane Strike and Arcane Boost

    Assuming you're talking about the Abjurant Champion's Arcane Boost ability, they both grant untyped bonuses to attack and damage rolls, so they stack.
  16. Gantros

    The "That's Unrealistic!" Retort Compendium

    In 3.5e & Pathfinder, when it comes to resisting damage, a Flesh Golem is as hard as wood, a Clay or Stone Golem is as hard as iron, and an Iron Golem is as hard as Mithral. DR for these creatures is higher than the hardness of objects made of the same substance (aside from the vulnerability to...
  17. Gantros

    The "That's Unrealistic!" Retort Compendium

    I assume the magical force animating the physical body only has a finite amount of power to hold it together and keep it moving. If enough stress is applied to the physical body in any one location, or in multiple locations over time, then the animating magic is expended and the physical body...
  18. Gantros

    Need some advice on a gaming rig

    The first system sounds a bit better - newer and faster CPU, better power supply, more storage (also has matched hard drives so you can RAID them if desired). It's missing a sound card, but unless you're an audiophile you'll probably be satisfied with the onboard sound. Graphics card choice is...
  19. Gantros

    Is Entangle supposed to be limited by the available vegetation?

    I think you missed the second half of the Line of Effect rule... "You must have clear line of effect ... to any space in which you wish to create an effect" Entangle's area of effect is a spread, which doesn't pass through solid barriers that block line of effect. It's further limited to...
  20. Gantros

    Best use for figment spells?

    From the SRD: "A successful saving throw against an illusion reveals it to be false, but a figment or phantasm remains as a translucent outline." A translucent outline won't block line of sight. As for the mobile light source, it is somewhat debatable if you could create a figment of something...
Top