Search results

Ok, I guess I see what you’re doing. I just don’t normally see it explained that way. Typically I see a cost for PDF only, cost for Book only, and a cost for the two together.

I think the question is: why are you making so little profit off the print version?

Back on topic, excited for the book and hope it is available soon!

Do you understand how AI works to make images? Did you understand @dave2008’s example? It is completely reasonable to not like or want AI art. However, AI art =/= theft of an artist work (at least not really anymore than any artist copies another to some extent). It is more nuanced than that.

Did the actually say class groups (which I liked) were removed for backwards compatibility? I don’t remember that, I just recall them being unpopular

I meant it mostly literally. Examples from the op: First. Hit points were lower, yes. No disagreement. Second: We didn't do any encumbrance or resource tracking in 1e. It wasn't fun for us, and it didn't impact the game in a meaningful way for us so we didn't do it. Third. Gritty Realism...

Thank you for the response! I should be clear that I don’t think character building at any stage is “fun,” just a necessary task. So not having to mess with skills at level up is a bonus for me. 2nd, I realize I wasn’t completely “honest” in my previous comment as I did not clarify that we...

That is what I guessed, but it seems so removed from play that I wouldn’t have described as boring. Skills function pretty much the same, you just have more/ more granularity in 3e/PF which to me is more boring in play. I find free wheeling more fun then strict structure. But I understand that...

Curious what makes the 5e skills boring to you compared to PF?

You don’t like spells?! Well that was a shocker I wouldn’t have expected!

The 2014 books are a toolbox, the 2024 rules less so

You can also cap scores at 18 or 16 (if you want that old +3 bonus max) and then remove ASIs.

But what if you can get the “1e feel” you want in less than a page. I mean the OP would take about half a page

The post and the OP reminded me of what my experience with 1e AD&D was like, except in almost the completely the opposite direction. Our games in the 80s and early 90s looked nothing like what is described here. Just goes to show there is no one way to play 1e AD&D or any edition really

Glad to have you onboard and welcome to these forums!

The lore was one of the best parts for us - fit right into our settinf

I will just agree to disagree on that!

You as well! I will say that I am aware of my ignorance on this subject.

This response show your ignorance. I will this conversation on that

You seemed to miss the point of the OP. They gave there scenarios: you provide what tou would do in each scenario