Search results

I see no meaningful difference between module writer fiat, game designer fiat, gm fiat, and gm fiats a table fiat.

yeah whats the important difference between “Dm decides goblin is eating ratonastick” “Dm rolls on their goblin lunch table” “gary gygax says goblins eat ratonastick” “Module J4 room 37 says the goblins are eating ratonastick”

Im sure i can find a letter in an early White Dwarf complaining that AD&D is an unwieldy over-ruled cash grab .

ahah . +1 for d4/d6 classes Alternating +1/+2 for d8 Im coming round to no saving throws. Slowly

Ok so im a wuss who likes average hitpoints instead of rolling. What to give dwarves in lieu of hitpoint advantage rolls?

No they don’t

is anyone?

Wheel of Cheese ive ignored, i dont want to watch a mid version of a mid book

HoD is an honest attempt by competent professionals to bring a talented novelists work to screen. We can discuss how successful it is. RoP is just crap. Amazon incompetently paid billions for the rights to a few pages of footnotes covering 3 and a half thousand years of history and then paid...

I think youve got a software problem rather than a hardware problem. I think we should be recommending what 5E adventures to buy.

And the point of me adopting a new system is that it supports some sort(s) of gameplay better than the systems I already have. What is Shadowdark/B-X/AD&D/3E/5E/DCC/Powers and Perils/ going to do better ?

Absolute pish and piffle. The whole point of a new system is it does something better.

Can anyone recommend a shadowdark adventure. What I want is a proper shadowdark adventure, one where I think, "This is a good adventure! AND I can see how it would work better as Shadowdark adventure than a BX / OSE etc etec adventure !

But the targets power level should factor in as well as the casters.

Seems that enemy spellcasters are going to wipe parties out. In a bad way.

No Saving Throws??

id like magic to be bad at permanence. A wall of fire that lasts for a fight? Ok A wall of iron that lasts for ever? Nope A wall of iron that lasts forever and destroys the iron -mining industry? Nope nope nope Id lkie magic to be a lot more expensive than the nonmagical method for mundane...

Middle Earth is a boring rpg setting.

look i just cant see dragonborn and tieflings wandering around my quasi-medieval gygax-tolkein-CAS-Leiber funland hitting goblins with a stick what breaks your vibe? Grell paladin-monks?

Or they think the breath weapon attack will come in handy. Why cant you kids today just be happy playing gnomes?