Search results

Oh, I'm less familiar with 6 year old Pedantic. Pretty sure he was still figuring out how to hyperfocus on reading.

Yeah. We're talking about D&D, you don't enter the room if you're not cool with sanctified fantastic violence, that's basic price of admission stuff that's so fundamental to the activity you can't do it without that.

I certainly wouldn't want to hang out with 20 year old me. He was kind of a dick, and it's really only by having been him that I understand how confused, angry and scared he was.

Generally I think specificity is better for classes. If we have to live in a subclass world, differentiation like Warlocks have where you're some flavor of X specific thing is more consistently compelling.

I think that's actually 2 different problems, which highlight a lot of the ongoing archetypal problems with the classes in general. The Fighter and Rogue suffer from being too generic to actually be a profession or vocation. All soldiers, swashbucklers, knights and even paladins are fighters...

I'm finally sitting down with The Red Knight, by Miles Cameron, which is the genre pseudonym for Christian Cameron. I was not particularly sold by the descriptions of the series, and found myself here after reading the author's bibliography in reverse publication order. His Against All Gods...

I can absolutely empathize with that. Reading is an abnegative, borderline dissociative experience for me. I use to routinely have a problem where I'd accidentally put the book down, and then have a jarring moment where the narrative suddenly stopped and it would take me a second to sort out...

I'm on track to hit 200, but I'm likely to run out of books I want to read before I get there. It's a significant part of my entertainment/media diet; if a book makes it longer than a couple days, I must not like it very much, or I'm reading some other book simultaneously and this one has been...

Ah, I misunderstood the prompt. You're starting and sticking at 20th level. That makes more sense.

If that's the goal, I'd probably go further. Pick a level to fix the PCs at to get the base character level differentiation you want, then tie progression entirely to magic items/quest boons. Maybe pick a small range, and provide "training" as a potential reward that can get characters from say...

To be fair, I would be totally cool if we went the other way and shifted some hoary mechanics to match more modern fiction. Druids that shapeshift a lot more and cast a lot less spells would be fine.

That's such a solvable problem, and more an issue of feat design than anything else. Creating a simple set of feats by role for monsters/NPCs would have dealt with most of it. Plus we live in a modern age of digital tools. CR and magic item scaling are issues in their own right, but that's a...

Differing NPC and PC rules. The difference should be a matter of encounter adventure design, not mechanical interaction.

Careful. That's the first step on the dark path that leads to extrapolating setting norms from specific magical effects.

This is the primary strength of magic (or other unreal phlebotinum powered effects). It yields to definition into specific techniques in a way that's significantly more complicated for mundane effects. You can spell out the rules and requirements and they aren't beholden to any tests beyond...

I'd go one step further, and say "and PCs largely get encounters in a level appropriate order," but that's quibbling. There's also nothing wrong with making PCs a special case in the established universe of the game, as long as it's sufficiently explained. Exalted is the classic example of a...

This is a different issue, but also one encouraged by the lack of a firm goal of play; players should ideally know (or at least want to know) the rules of the game they're playing. My preferred approach goes a step further and maintains should not only know, but attempt to use, the rules of the...

I'm legitimately not joking when I say this should be the only option presented to players. Modern fantasy is even trending this direction, strict magical/non-magical skill separation is pretty rare in modern fantasy protagonists. Characters can still use swords, they should just also get...

Ah, see I can imagine nothing more disrespectful to a game (or more precisely, to the other players) than not trying to win it, and no worse design sin than asking me not to do that sometimes. The "integrity" of the game is a matter for the design and systems to solve, not for the players...

Yes, it is unethical to print the Fighter. In this talk I will...