A Completely Unbiased XP System

I can't remember your take on balance in other areas of the game, so I'm not sure if not caring about wealth balance matches your usual take on balance or not.
I don't believe balance is achievable across all playerbases with RPGs on all axis of measurement, especially given the "All rules are optional" approach many GMs take, because too many variables are introduced. So the goal of perfect balance is, to me, a fool's errant.

I don't see combat balance as essential, but as a nicety — when it works. Especially encounter balancing.

On topic, I think the goal of an XP system should be that PCs have equal access to earning XP and that general XP totals describe roughly equal power at the same XP total, even if that's different levels. But, at the end of the day, players won't take all of the opportunities to earn XP that are available, so balance is in potential, not in the outcomes.
 

log in or register to remove this ad

For what it's worth, I'm zeroing in on some criteria for XP awards. This is the general idea: each challenge is worth XP. No challenge, no XP. Each award is multiplied by its expected appropriate level, and quest-critical criteria are worth twice the non-critical criteria.

Befriend NPC
Defeat NPC
Collect treasure
Discover secret
Quest-specific other

They're intentionally vague - they need to apply to a lot of different quests. As in, an NPC isn't necessarily a "monster,"* defeating doesn't have to mean killing, treasure is about anything of value (intentionally placed as a reward for PCs), a secret could be door/information/etc. The quest-specific other is basically things you need to complete the quest, as long as they're discrete and challenging.

So I probably added your idea or ignored it (sorry). Are some character archetypes left out of this scheme? What did I miss?
the artist, architect, and enchanter types - create thing of value
 

For what it's worth, I'm zeroing in on some criteria for XP awards. This is the general idea: each challenge is worth XP. No challenge, no XP. Each award is multiplied by its expected appropriate level, and quest-critical criteria are worth twice the non-critical criteria.

Befriend NPC
Defeat NPC
Collect treasure
Discover secret
Quest-specific other

They're intentionally vague - they need to apply to a lot of different quests. As in, an NPC isn't necessarily a "monster,"* defeating doesn't have to mean killing, treasure is about anything of value (intentionally placed as a reward for PCs), a secret could be door/information/etc. The quest-specific other is basically things you need to complete the quest, as long as they're discrete and challenging.

So I probably added your idea or ignored it (sorry). Are some character archetypes left out of this scheme? What did I miss?

* Insert D&D 5/6e definitions crack here.
I would say that it reads pretty disconnected from a lot of social interactions where terminal states like "befriend or defeat" are rare --- gaining favor with an important person, joining a faction, sabotaging a faction, influencing a court, etc. I think you could have a lot of PCs that have made important relationship changes but didn't reach a completion point, and so differences of opinion on the experience gained vs. XP granted may occur.

Kind of an offshoot of social space stuff, if your game incorporates it, any kind of leadership or realm goal seems lacking --- gathering followers, maintaining a keep, establishing a kingdom, creating an organization, etc. Perhaps those fold into "quests" but it sounds not very character-motivated.

Exploration stuff seems light as well, unless activities there distill into "discover secret". I might expand "exploration" as a concept into uncovering and solving mysteries, as well, but maybe again that's a "secret" or a "quest".

Creation activities, as aramis erak said, also seem missing. I would also take Lanefan's suggestion of taking a risk of some sort to help another; assisting others in general seems missing.
 

That's biased too, in the metagame: you're rewarding players for showing up (or, if by hour, for playing longer sessions and-or more often). In itself this might not be a bad thing, but it doesn't reflect what those players each do in-character once they're at the table.
Perhaps. There is an assumption that players are there to play the game, not to just sit and stare at one another across the table.
 


Perhaps. There is an assumption that players are there to play the game, not to just sit and stare at one another across the table.

I like XP systems that incentivise playing the game - I have dealt with groups who will happily do nothing for hours, typically because they are 'turtling'. A Savage Worlds XE type system where you get 1-3 XP per session depending on achievements and advance at 5 XP works decently. I ran Primeval Thule with a level up at 20 XP and typically around 5-8 XP per session, this gave the standard 5e 2.5 sessions per level & worked ok, but PCs advanced out of the 5-10 'sweet spot' a bit too quickly for the swords & sorcery setting IMO. If doing it again I'd probably use 100 XP/level and aim to award 10-30 XP per session (or 10 XP/level and 1-3 XP per session, but I prefer more granularity) so that it was more like 4 or 5 sessions per level.

I'm pretty happy with the standard 5e XP table though, it works much better in practice than in theory. :) In my Under Illefarn 5e online game with 8 players and ca 3 hour sessions I use individual XP, the PCs typically level up every 5 sessions or so. They get standard monster XP, quest awards of usually 500 XP (at level 5-10) every couple sessions, and ca 100-300 XP between quests spending money on my Shadowdark-inspired Carousing table.
 
Last edited:

Aha - should I add Give Treasure and/or Create Secret? The catch is that they have to be challenges.
Perhaps "Make valuable thing of great difficulty"?
(One of my L5R players is playing a swordsmith... lots of play revolves around his goals of making a major sword. Which is not an easy task in L5R.)
 

Are milestones not very biased? On DM-Discretion is basically the definition of bias, if you dont play solo and use an oracle die.
I think gold for exp and carousal are the best options for general adventuring.
 

Are milestones not very biased? On DM-Discretion is basically the definition of bias, if you dont play solo and use an oracle die.
I think gold for exp and carousal are the best options for general adventuring.
I would say the opposite, milestones just reward playing the game how the players want as long as they typically either push the story forward or accomplish their goals (typically both) and not for any particular type of gameplay (i.e. Combat, Social etc).

@GMMichael specifically brought up combat as being something they want to move away from as the primary provider of xp. Which is something that gold-for-xp at least would not come to mind as a solution for, unless you can talk lots of gold off of people or steal it without combat. Don't really know what carousing is. I guess that's like the old-timey version of networking? That seems interesting, but also biased in favor of doing only that.

I have 2 games going right now that both effectively use milestone. In one the milestones are explicitly based on what point of the story the party is at, in the second (a more sandbox game), its based on how many "main quests" the party has done combined with a separate total for how many hex nodes they have completed. In both cases their is no bias towards rewarding any type of gameplay, whatever the players do, progresses them.

Though I will say @Lanefan brought up an interesting point about milestone being somewhat biased in favor of PC's that are less active in gameplay or decision making (they get the same XP as everyone else).
 

Milestone levelling is subjective to GM fiat, and biased in favour of less active characters and uninvested players.

Gold-as-XP is subjective to the amount of gold the GM includes as reward, and biased against altruistic characters.

Success/failure-as-XP (or critical/fumble-as-XP) is subjective to the number of rolls asked/allowed by the GM, and biased in favour of character with lots of abilities and players initiating a lot of rolls.

Combat-as-XP (default D&D) is subjective to the amount of fighting introduced by the GM, and biased against players circumventing combat and characters focused on other tasks/interests.

Achievements-as-XP is subjective to what is included on the award table and to the XP weight distribution among such achievements, and biased in favour of players choosing reasonable or easy achievements to focus on.

Challenge-as-XP is subjective to how the GM interprets challenge difficulty levels and what challenges are introduced by the GM, and biased in favour of characters specializing in the tasks thus introduced.

Metacurrency-as-XP is subjective to how the meta currency is spent and renewed, and biased in favour of players apt to renew/accumulate metacurrency and "safe"characters who have no use for the metacurrency.
 

Remove ads

Top