A Concept about warfare in a Black-powder Fantasy World

Anonym

Explorer
This is a D&D-style fantasy world similar to Eberron, except that the knowledge of how to manufacture black powder, musket,matchlock firearms, and cannons is widespread across the world.of course,they still don’t know how to make robots.

its a world of magocracy. although the specific forms vary enormously across the world, the ruling classes almost everywhere consist of various spellcasters and their relatives (non-spellcasting relatives of mages hold very low status within the nobility although). in most cases the rank of these mage-nobles and lords are directly determined by their magical power: only a 20th-level wizard is permitted to hold the title of king, a 15th-level wizard accepted as a marquis, and even the lowest-ranking noble must be at least a 1st-level wizard, and so on.

theocracies also exist, ruled by the servants of various gods; their status determines how much magical power their masters grant them, so the practical effect is much the same.

this being a D&D-style fantasy world, so there is a distinction between wizards and sorcerers. However,becoming a truly powerful mage usually requires exceptional gift and talent, mysterious bloodline, diligent study, and no small amount of luck. excellent mentors, systematic education and tradition, and large research budgets are also essential. only the most powerful mages can afford such things, and correspondingly they prefer to sponsor their own descendants even when other, more gifted young people exist.

these mage-nobles are not necessarily human. dwarves and elves maintain similar institutions of their own and interact frequently with human countries. even dragons, undead, angels, and fiends can be recognized as political powers provided they are reasonable and willing to respect the rules of the game. clearly a dragon or a pit fiend might, for various reasons, be (reluctantly) acknowledged as holding the rank of marquis,duke or even king along with matching territories; a Balor, however, is far less likely (perhaps possible when it is in a good mood, but never for long).

Mage-nobles hold a strong sense of superiority over non-spellcasters. across the world they employ various derogatory terms for them—such as “Muggle.”


For a very long period of their history, high-level spellcasters were the main stars of war. when war broke out, battles were usually fought between two group of a handful of powerful mages and a small group of lower-level mages. once one side had suffered heavy losses (for example, three wizards of 15th level or higher killed while their enemy had lost only one), the outcome was effectively decided and the losing side would acknowledge defeat and surrender. if they really feel the need for some expendable foot soldiers, various golems and undead are better choice than the feeble muggles, even in the era those muggles can use matchlocks and muzzle-loading cannons.

Mundane armies composed of large numbers of muggles had little value except to help their mage masters deal with goblins and small orc tribes; their usual roles were maintaining social order and collecting taxes. on the battlefield they were of little use.

even the existence of musket,flintlocks and muzzle-loading cannons did not change this situation, because a single Fireball or Cloudkill could wipe out an entire formation of muggle soldiers, and they could not fight in skirmish order—doing so would only make them easier prey for the enemy.

their overall technological level is roughly equivalent to that of 17th- and 18th-century Earth. nevertheless, thanks to magic and alchemy, some more advanced regions have begun to popularize percussion-cap firearms, especially various forms of the Pauly cartridge and breech-loading rifles and even breech-loading artillery. this means they can now fight in open skirmish order and no longer need to crowd together to generate combat power, thereby becoming preferred targets for enemy fireball and cloudkill spells.

Bolt-action rifles have only just been invented, and only as prototypes made by a few inventors. What they are pursuing is cheap, large-scale industrial production that does not rely on magic, but their technology is still not equal to the task. In fact, most places do not even know of the steam engine; they instead rely on various magical-alchemical creations made by mages to serve as fuel.


——Simply put, their wars look like this:

when two armies prepare to engage and fight, large numbers of muggle soldiers equipped with over-under double-barreled rifles firing Pauly cartridges and Minié balls,fight in skirmish lines. elite units among them may, as missions require, be issued magically enhanced ammo or adamantine AP rounds.

behind them are masses of black-powder artillery, along with a smaller number of advanced but expensive breech-loading cannons.

golems and undead are employed as assault troops, specifically assigned to the most dangerous, most important targets, or highest-casualty missions.

the mage-nobles remain the decisive factor. these guy full of the feeling of superiority are usually do not stay with their mundane muggle armies; instead they operate within their own combat system. they function as special forces, air force, or even nuclear weapons. in most cases the outcome of a war is determined by which side fields the stronger and/or more numerous mages.


by the way,in this era some of the more enlightened mage-nobles have begun attempting popular educational reforms—most likely Prussian-style rather than ancient Chinese-style.
 
Last edited:

log in or register to remove this ad

I am not sure what you want from this post. I really do not agree with your conclusion as to how war would develop and I have to wonder why the mageocracy would permit the widespread development of firearms. Which I think would be lot more effective than you seem think and a real threat to the status quo.
 

War drives innovation. Bolt action rifles coupled with optical sights equals long range sniping. That 20th level mage 500 yards away is within range of a skilled muggle sniper who is out of range of most retaliatory spells. The mage has to have "protection from normal missiles" type protection up all the time. The sniper only has to succeed once. Plus the sniper may have its own magical assistant to cast spells on the bullet that can bypass many magical protections.

In our real life world, WWI was mostly trench warfare Two decades later WWII Europe was fast moving tank combat supplemented with air power. I see no reason to assume that that combat in the Magocracy wouldn't similarly change and evolve as technology advanced. Also, no reason to assume that spell tech would stay static. Things like Acid Rain spells to cause fast wide spread damage to metal based delicate parts in firearms and vehicles. Or maybe spells that can cause gunpowder to go inert. Illusion spells to provide camouflage.

As for how gunpowder tech might evolve in a magocracy, possible a country losing a mage war might fund gunpowder as a way to change the outcome or at least force a more favorable loss.
 

There is a wealth of development between early western experiments with guns in say, the 100 Years War and French deployment of artillery in the battlefield in say the Italian Wars and the emergence of pike and shot infantry.
I would also say that early modern artillery is much more effective and longer ranged than fireballs. There is even a greater development gap between early modern era and effective breechloading sniper rifles.
What I find intriguing about such a situation, is what incentivises a bunch of mage aristocrats to risk their monopoly of power by encouraging to peasants to develop technology that would undermine their power monopoly.
 

because a single Fireball or Cloudkill could wipe out an entire formation of muggle soldiers, and they could not fight in skirmish order—doing so would only make them easier prey for the enemy.

A long bow or a musket has a lot better range than a fireball. Do you really want to cover the distance to get 150 feet away from 100 guys firing in mass at you?
 


A long bow or a musket has a lot better range than a fireball. Do you really want to cover the distance to get 150 feet away from 100 guys firing in mass at you?
invisibility,fly,teleport,Alter self or Polymorth themselve as enemy's officiers or even merely rats.
in that black powder era,the mage-nobles would be much more like subtle special forces than brutal air force ever before.
 

The widespread use of breechloading firarms and cannons will severely trouble mid-level and low-level mages below the 15th tier, but it still poses no threat to the high-level mages at the top of the social pyramid.

this will be a significant impact, maby it would indicating that the power of monarchy will further strengthen?
and there are no rigid restrictions preventing mages from serving as military officers, a regiment commanding by mages will always be stronger than a all muggles regiment. the things these mage-nobles need to do is just put their outdated sense of traditional superiority away.
 

I am not sure what you want from this post. I really do not agree with your conclusion as to how war would develop and I have to wonder why the mageocracy would permit the widespread development of firearms. Which I think would be lot more effective than you seem think and a real threat to the status quo.
Yeah, agreed. If you want your fantasy world to look that way, then fine, declare it works that way by DM fiat. What do you need us for? All we’re going to tell you is that your ideas aren’t particularly defensible and it’s now how we’d do it.

The level of military technology you propose is well beyond 18th century - it’s 19th or beyond - and at those levels, any mage-noble who thinks his magical bloodline will make him a superior and unstoppable force on the battlefield is going to end up looking like a colander in his first engagement. I’ll be amazed if any of them make it anywhere near 15th level.
 


Remove ads

Top