D&D General A Fifth Pillar of D&D: Creation


log in or register to remove this ad

The funny thing is this "creation" pillar in most of my games is a way to consume wealth. Yeah, its kind of downtime but its also linked to social. You need contacts, artisans, suppliers, etc that you can trust to handle rediculous sums of money. That requires some social activity, at the very least, I teaching eith trusted NPCs who facilitate the hiring.

It is often also a way to influence NPCs ( "...I could host you at the estate for a week or two this fall so you can enjoy the harvest festival...") or motivate the players ("the river has gone brackish, something must have happened upstream!")
Social and exploration can happen during combat scenes. Combat and exploration can happen during social scenes. Social and combat can happen during exploration scenes. None of the pillars represent mutually exclusive modes of activity.
 

Assuming the GM is a player, I'd agree that creation is a pillar and that games that make it easy and fun for the GM to create their own new stuff benefit from more engagement and longevity.

I created homebrew stuff for TSR versions of D&D, but 3E making it so easy and fun to do it -- with lots of explanations of how the pieces fit together, how they were nominally balanced, etc. -- really made it a core part of how I approach all RPGs now. Today, Pirate Borg and Shadowdark are doing the same for me, and it looks like Mothership is going to scratch that itch as well.

WotC has waxed and waned on how much explicit support they give homebrewers and I wish they'd devote more energy to it. The 3E Unearthed Arcana was one of the best books ever published for any RPG, IMO, as it was basically explaining how to homebrew the game, with tons of examples of it, including designers' notes. More of that, please.
This is where my head went with this question too.

Creation isn't primarily a thing characters do. It's a thing players, especially the DM, do. But it is a huge part of the joy of the game, and it's the main mode in which the game can be participated in solo. Whether that's designing encounters, NPCs, magic items, dungeons, or whole worlds. Or just a player noodling around on character builds.
 
Last edited:

Another thought occurs to me about this:

There's one major element that, in play, often fights against a lot of [downtime-shenanigans-creation] pillar activities, and that's the passage of in-game time - or, more accurately, the extreme lack thereof - over a typical party's adventuring run.

As written, and as often played particularly in AP-style campaigns, a character and its party can easily go from 1-20* in maybe half a year of in-game time. Many downtime projects such as base-building, spell research, and so on would reasonably take much longer than this; meaning a character who wants to take the time to do such things while her companions continue adventuring has effectively just ended her own (played-at-table) adventuring career unless she can talk her party into waiting...and that ain't always easy, especially if - as is IMO far too commonly done - the DM has the party on any kind of a plot-related clock.

There's a few ways to mitigate this issue but IME they often end up being something forced by the DM or game state^, as trying to get parties to take any significant time off just because they want to is like pulling teeth.

* - or as high as that campaign is gonna get, if not 20.
^ - examples: training rules to level up that force parties to take downtime, or plot-related developments e.g. the McGuffin is in the Vanishing Castle, but the castle has vanished and will not reappear until three full moons have passed.
 

What if we treated Creation as a pillar in its own right? What other activities might fall under it, and what would D&D look like if it gave Creation the same kind of attention it gives Combat, Exploration, and Social Interaction?
An absolutely sensible pillar IMO. I suppose a lot of it would fall under what you'd traditionally call "domain play": establishing strongholds, raising armies, fighting large scale battles, etc. In many ways, looking back to the roots of the hobby.

There certainly bits of older or adjacent editions (many of the activities in the AD&D DMG, the "Ultimate X" type books for Pathfinder, certain OSR titles that lean into this like Adventurer Conqueror King) that have strong elements of this. I think what it needs to flourish is a (presumably quite optional) "simulationist" backbone to things - a coherent economy (how much should magic research or creation or funding an army or stronghold cost to be fun and something of a sustainable challenge), interesting things to spend loads of money on that keep money as an interesting resource to unlock new levels of play, a good reckoning of time at different scales (how long should various activities of creation take, how should one track these things), good mechanics for larger scale combat (where the challenges are logistical/political/creation oriented as much as tactical), and good reasons why normal "man to man" scale adventuring can't simply be solved by the aforementioned activities.

Obviously not for every table or every game, but I do think it's a natural direction for many games to go, or a natural interlude to other types of adventuring. You sometimes hear people say "why would you play D&D for this just play a proper war game or 4x game" to which I would say that part of the appeal of a long term rpg campaign is exploring conflicts and influencing the world at different scales. I want to have that war game or kingdom management or industrial scale magical research or whatever happening in the setting I'm adventuring in! I want consequences of choices bouncing up and down between different scales of activity! I want players getting creative and solving challenges in unexpected ways! I want a game that varies in activity from session to session while accumulating the history and consequences of each!

EDIT: I'll add that some of the above might sound like what's needed is a game of spreadsheets (at least for the DM), but I don't think that's a necessary undergirding, even though some go in that direction.

I think what is needed is:

1) careful attention to the right level(s) of abstraction for things (allowing for zooming in and out where wanted, and for natural conversion between these levels, e.g. domain management and dungeon delving) - some attempts at this sort of play (Kingmaker for Pathfinder 2e, and arguably the 5.5e Bastion system) get stuck in the "bad quadrant" of being simultaneously too abstract and too fiddly. If you have a complicated system for generating abstract "Resource Points" you've gone in the wrong direction IMO - ideally I want something more concrete but simple enough that these activities feel more like being an Arthurian Lord or Eccentric Vancian Wizard than an accountant, while detailed enough to make for interesting choices and maintain coherence with the base game.

2) Well thought out constraints on activity: money/resources, pushback from other factions/powers/players in the world, logistical sense (in essence, the opposite of the last few seasons of Game of Thrones, with characters and armies popping up anywhere anytime to support the needs of the plot), so that meaningful choices and challenge are maintained, creativity is encouraged and exciting conflict is generated naturally.
 
Last edited:

Another thought occurs to me about this:

There's one major element that, in play, often fights against a lot of [downtime-shenanigans-creation] pillar activities, and that's the passage of in-game time - or, more accurately, the extreme lack thereof - over a typical party's adventuring run.

As written, and as often played particularly in AP-style campaigns, a character and its party can easily go from 1-20* in maybe half a year of in-game time. Many downtime projects such as base-building, spell research, and so on would reasonably take much longer than this; meaning a character who wants to take the time to do such things while her companions continue adventuring has effectively just ended her own (played-at-table) adventuring career unless she can talk her party into waiting...and that ain't always easy, especially if - as is IMO far too commonly done - the DM has the party on any kind of a plot-related clock.

There's a few ways to mitigate this issue but IME they often end up being something forced by the DM or game state^, as trying to get parties to take any significant time off just because they want to is like pulling teeth.
Its like pulling teeth because it's boring AF and players dont want to do it. Maybe?

I think downtime needs to be an adventure specific thing and/or put in a supplemental module. Players only want to do it if they actually sign up to do it, IME.
 

Its like pulling teeth because it's boring AF and players dont want to do it. Maybe?

I think downtime needs to be an adventure specific thing and/or put in a supplemental module. Players only want to do it if they actually sign up to do it, IME.
I think it benefits certain campaign structures and paces a lot: episodic / West Marches/ Megadungeons / sandbox sort of things, where players repeatedly return to a home base. If it's relatively simple and there are clear benefits, I've definitely had players get into it, especially asynchronously (if you can't make a session but can send some downtime instructions plans, it's a great way to keep someone involved.
 

No, Patrick, engaging with the preexisting pillars of play in an absurd manner is not itself a pillar of play.
nopatrick.jpeg
 

Its like pulling teeth because it's boring AF and players dont want to do it. Maybe?
How can the following exchange be considered "boring AF"?

Player A: "Sheilagh wants to take the winter off so she can put some time into building her temple."
Other players, in aggregate: "Sounds fine with us, we got nothing on the docket right now anyway"
DM: "OK. Pam, we'll email during the week to work out how well things go for Sheilagh's project. Otherwise... <rolls some dice> ...looks like nothing bothers you lot for the winter. Each of you knock off 90 g.p. for living expenses during that time."
Player B: "Johann is doing some serious partying, I'll up his living expenses to 140."
DM: "OK. So now it's spring 1085, and if nothing else Johann really looks like he could use some fresh country air! There's rumours floating into town of bands of Ogres to the northwest getting an early start to their summer raids....."

That wouldn't take more than two minutes, tops; and if that counts as boring AF I don't know what to say.
 

How can the following exchange be considered "boring AF"?

Player: "Sheilagh wants to take the winter off so she can put some time into building her temple."
Other players, in aggregate: "Sounds fine with us, we got nothing on the docket right now anyway"
DM: "OK. Pam, we'll email during the week to work out how well things go for Sheilagh's project. Otherwise... <rolls some dice> ...looks like nothing bothers you lot for the winter. Each of you knock off 90 g.p. for living expenses during that time."
Player: "Johann is doing some serious partying, I'll up his living expenses to 140."
DM: "OK. So now it's spring 1085, and if nothing else Johann really looks like he could use some fresh country air! There's rumours floating into town of bands of Ogres to the northwest getting an early start to their summer raids....."

That wouldn't take more than two minutes, tops; and if that counts as boring AF I don't know what to say.
You... you need rules to tell you how to do that?
 

Remove ads

Top