D&D General A Fifth Pillar of D&D: Creation

You... you need rules to tell you how to do that?
Specific to this example:

Yes, for the temple construction piece as regards costs, time, possibility of complications.

Yes, for the base per-diem downtime living expenses piece.

After that, and more broadly in general, I just need the game to tell the players that should they so decide there's potentially a lot more they can do with a character beyond adventuring; and to offer a few suggestions and examples for non-adventuring activities.
 

log in or register to remove this ad

Specific to this example:

Yes, for the temple construction piece as regards costs, time, possibility of complications.

Yes, for the base per-diem downtime living expenses piece.

After that, and more broadly in general, I just need the game to tell the players that should they so decide there's potentially a lot more they can do with a character beyond adventuring; and to offer a few suggestions and examples for non-adventuring activities.
Yeah I still see this as campaign/adventure specific and shouldn't be a core element. Although, 3E DMG II and Paizo GMG did this thing awesomely, WotC dont seem to be too into making books for GMs these days.
 

Yeah I still see this as campaign/adventure specific and shouldn't be a core element. Although, 3E DMG II and Paizo GMG did this thing awesomely, WotC dont seem to be too into making books for GMs these days.
Ahh, but you fell victim to one of the classic blunders — the most famous of which is 'Never get involved in a land war in Asia' — but only slightly less well-known is this: 'Always phrase your negative statements as being true for some people, never an absolute truth for all people!'
 
Last edited:

Eye roll Ahh, but you fell victim to one of the classic blunders — the most famous of which is 'Never get involved in a land war in Asia' — but only slightly less well-known is this: 'Always phrase your negative statements as being true for some people, never an absolute truth for all people!'
Come On Please GIF by NBA
 


No, Patrick, engaging with the preexisting pillars of play in an absurd manner is not itself a pillar of play.

Important discussion note:

The Normal Form is a game model. GNS is a game model. The Loop of Play is a game model. These are all methods (with varying levels of academic credibility) to represent the complete process/system of how an RPG works.

The "pillars of play" were never intended to be a game model. They make no attempt, neither explicit nor implied, to be complete, accurate, or even logical. They are design notes. A developers crib sheet. Advice. It's a general guide for fun, not mechanics or theory.

If you want to change the pillars, just change the pillars. Asking "Why don't we have pillars for X?" is like asking why you have to decorate in red and green at Xmas, or what meat goes on an Italian sandwich. There's no actual rules, just vibes and angry nerds. Of course, you also need to accept that you have very limited space for variation before your creation bears no resemblance to the original thing, and no one recognizes it. But why is that a problem?
 
Last edited:

Another thought occurs to me about this:

There's one major element that, in play, often fights against a lot of [downtime-shenanigans-creation] pillar activities, and that's the passage of in-game time - or, more accurately, the extreme lack thereof - over a typical party's adventuring run.

As written, and as often played particularly in AP-style campaigns, a character and its party can easily go from 1-20* in maybe half a year of in-game time. Many downtime projects such as base-building, spell research, and so on would reasonably take much longer than this; meaning a character who wants to take the time to do such things while her companions continue adventuring has effectively just ended her own (played-at-table) adventuring career unless she can talk her party into waiting...and that ain't always easy, especially if - as is IMO far too commonly done - the DM has the party on any kind of a plot-related clock.

There's a few ways to mitigate this issue but IME they often end up being something forced by the DM or game state^, as trying to get parties to take any significant time off just because they want to is like pulling teeth.

* - or as high as that campaign is gonna get, if not 20.
^ - examples: training rules to level up that force parties to take downtime, or plot-related developments e.g. the McGuffin is in the Vanishing Castle, but the castle has vanished and will not reappear until three full moons have passed.
One can also deliberately pace the campaign so that it has individual adventures which are on a limited timer for the plot/events, but then have downtime between them when characters can do spell research or whatever.

I do this with my current Shadowdark game.
 

Combat is a core pillar because D&D has an entire combat mini-game baked into their rules since the beginning of its existence and for which most of its gameplay is built around.

Exploration is a core pillar because D&D was originally designed around dungeon crawling and discovering things within a location in order to acquire treasure. And the rules now include an entire skill list with which to test characters when they do things to explore areas. Discovering and making known unknown things is the primary activity in D&D.

Social is a core pillar because almost all roleplaying games involve the improvisation of speech between the PCs of the players and the NPCs of the GM to get across wants, needs, and ideas. Communication between characters (whether player or non) is now the foundation in which decisions get made. This can also include rolls on the skill list if necessary... but oftentimes are just the GM arbitrarily deciding what communication succeeds or doesn't succeed based upon how well the players convey their ideas and arguments. If a player's argument "makes sense" (especially when being made to an NPC for whom the argument is really geared towards)... then the GM will respond back in kind.

Creation, Shenanigans, and Downtime are all things that tables can do and that rules can be made for them... but for which many tables have not, do not, and will not use. Domain management, item creation, mass combat, training, rumor collection and carousing (which oftentimes is just played out as Social interactions anyway)... these are all things that oftentimes are outside the "adventuring sphere" that most D&D games are founded on, and thus many tables don't bother with them. And for that reason I myself do not see any of it turning into a "core pillar". At least not of the same level as Combat, Exploration, and Social Interaction. They just don't seem to really be a key part of the D&D experience for many tables.
 
Last edited:

Hmmm... :unsure:

I'm not convinced there is a strong need for more "pillars", but it's fun to think about. The core pillars do a fairly reasonable job of illustrating the three mjor modes of play (i.e., the most common activities that all characters are expected to do in any given scenario).

Outside of that, we have behaviors and extra activities that players can engage with directly or outright ignore. They don't necessarily engage with the primary pillars, but rather engage with the game world in a different way.

In classic JRPGs, these are mini-games within the games that players can spend a lot of time with that don't deal with the main quests or storylines, like fishing, crafting, or card games. Their efforts may yield unique rewards, but ultimately, they can achieve the story quests and narratives without them.

I think a pillar has to be something that every player is expected to engage during play, even if in small doses. They can't get around it. That's why they are "pillars".

However, if there were one more aspect of the game that I think is core to everyone's experience, it would be Preparation. That would be the time spent gathering resources (shopping), crafting materials, practicing or applying skills, improving equipment, establishing connections, and fortifying their bases.

These things don't necessarily take place during the main part of the story or adventure, but as part of the environment or setting where they may take place. More importantly, it is not something players want to spend a whole lot of time doing at the table, especially if their time is limited and precious.

Just my thoughts, of course.
 

One can also deliberately pace the campaign so that it has individual adventures which are on a limited timer for the plot/events, but then have downtime between them when characters can do spell research or whatever.

I do this with my current Shadowdark game.
In theory, this should be possible.

In practice, IME when as DM I for some reason want to space things out, oftentimes the players-as-characters will look for adventures to fill the gaps; and when as player I want to space things out the DM immediately drops an adventure in our laps. Both have happened to me within the last month.
 

Remove ads

Top