Let's start this with the requisite warning- I am going to discuss Season 4 of Star Trek: Strange New Worlds in this post.
A little warning of my own - I am going to repeat a few things I've already said in the SNW spoiler thread. Sorry if that bores folks. I am not nearly as entertaining a writer as Snarf.
I also love Star Trek. I have watched it all, except for Season 2 of Picard, and the Section 31 thing that by all accounts is a bit of a debacle. I intend to get to the Picard, at least, when I have TV time for stuff my wife is uninterested in. Oh, and I did watch Starfleet Academy... and liked that too! So there!
I'm going to present some reasons for why they're doing what they are doing. For me, understanding that has greatly enhanced my own appreciation of it. Folks are free to not like it. But folks should understand why it is happening, because it ain't just writers screwing around with something you like.
A. First, We Have to Talk About Buffy
Per my previous note - "The Body" might be classified as a VSE, but OMWF is mode definitely not. OMWF does not deal with a topic the show normally avoids - it is using a musical as a genre frame to resolve the stuff it has already established in previous episodes, as you already noted - folks are singing about what they feel, and we already knew they were feeling these things. OMWF is just a vehicle for people to reveal their inner issues, and then have to deal with them
And that's what EVERY weird episode of SNW this season has been doing - and what Subspace Rhapsody, which is very clearly a OMWF homage, was doing. Every single one of them is using a specifically chosen frame to address and enact character development points, just like you claim OMWF does.
B. Why Strange New Worlds Feels Off to Me in Season 4
I am going to start with a note of sadness. Seasons 1 and 2 of TOS had a total of 55 episodes. When season 5 of SNW completes and the show is over (pour one out for Hemmer) .... it will have 46 episodes. Think about that for a second. The entire run of SNW is approximately two Buffy seasons. This is going to be important later.
And this is tied to that short season. Trelane directly tells us this in "Like Chronitons Through the Hourglass" (emphasis below is mine):
"The premise is simply 'Space adventures leave little time for humans to deal with their inner struggles.' So I’ve crafted some individualized situations just to get around all that."
They are actively telling you that if they did all this as typical space adventure, they'd not actually be able to get through the character development! They are using various frames to raise up and accelerate these developments. If this were the 20+ episode seasons of Next Gen, DS9, or Voyager, they wouldn't need to do this. But they've only got 10 episodes to work with - this stuff would normally be part of the "filler" episodes, but they have no filler to work with.
Now, let's look at the ten episodes of Season 4.
E1- Dinosaurs/Time Travel
E2- Horror genre exercise (VSE)
E3- Pleasure Planet
E4- Noir/ B&W (VSE)
E5- Muppets (VSE)
E6- Theoretical Neutrinos
E7- Soap Opera (VSE)
E8- Another Crazy Admiral
E9- Fantasy / Dragon (VSE ... probably)
E10- Two Uhuras and a space Baby (VSE)
So, are you aware that this was not the originally intended ordering of the episodes?
The intended order was:
1) Dinosaurs/Time travel
2) Pleasure Planet
3) Noir
4) Horror
The show is episodic enough that this doesn't pose any logical plot holes, but it does muck with two arcs from a character development point of view:
Spock - it should be that Spock accidentally opens up to Kirk (on the pleasure planet), and then has his "symbolic ear-shearing" in the horror episode - his issues with how he's handling his human/vulcan mix were mis-ordered, which impacts their resolution.
La'an: Should punch a dinosaus with no harm, then be an aggressive-gang-appropriating drunk, then get a bit paranoid and talk to Chapel about it, culminating in her near psychotic break in the horror episode.
Mucking with these two arcs has muddied the water around what they're actually trying to do with their genre frame shifts.
The reason that this matters is that when you have so few episodes ... blowing them all on genre exercises means that we spend less time on "bread & butter" episodes that this show is so good at and has excelled at in prior seasons ... you know, exploring strange new worlds. This isn't like old Star Trek or Buffy with their 22+ episode seasons.
Yes, that's exactly the point.
If they did a bunch of space adventures, exploring new worlds... they might be neat, but they wouldn't ultimately go anywhere. They'd just be space adventures.
Folks who remember the original talk around this show, before it aired, they specifically said they were eschewig extended plot arcs, and that instead you'd have character development arcs that spanned what looked like disparate logical plotlines.
And, given how disparate the genre frames have been, I outright reject that they aren't exploring strange new worlds! Like, they've gone from Barsoom, to the Maltese Falcon, to Muppets man! How strange do you want this show to be?
More importantly, most of the VSEs don't do much for the overall show. Let's use a few examples ... E2 had some great atmosphere and horror, but it was absolutely 100% against the entire spirit of Star Trek.
My dearly departed father had a word for this: Horsehockey.
Anyone remember what they very first episode of Star Trek to ever air was?
"The Man Trap", in which a shape-shifting, salt-sucking VAMPIRE hunts people down - that's a horror frame!
Oh, and since 1984, we have established that the Vulcans can preserve their "katras", their memory and spirit, apparently for centuries, and sufficient to nearly possess Bones and resurrect Spock from the dead, given an appropriate body. And immaterial evil spirits from wormholes (pah-wraiths) possess folks over on DS9.
Spiritual wackiness and psychic shenanigans after death are clearly in-bounds!
Look, not to get on a high horse about this (because I liked a lot of the genre trappings) ... but in Star Trek, you have to at least make up some technobabble, or a super-advanced race, or something.
There is nothing in the sci-fi format that requires that the main characters personally resolve all questions within forty minutes of episode. Science is not about certainty. It is about learning, and sometimes that takes a while, and other experts.
Like, dude, your main Science Officer was getting his ears chopped off by his ex-fiancee. He was a little busy for scanning and reversing the polarity of the neutron flow.
That's the whole point! You don't just shrug your shoulders and say, "Eh, looks like we just got haunted. Could be anything."
That's not what they said. They said, "This is so deeply weird, we need to hand it off to the experts."
And don't get me started on the Soap Opera- yes, I enjoyed it, yes, I appreciate the long line of Q interference, but .... for such a swing, the actual payoff was miniscule.
They payoff was resolution of Pike's emotional life from an entire life and family. I am terribly sorry if that doesn't mean anything to you.
Which brings me to the muppets episode. I loved the muppets. It was fun. But c'mon.... you have 10 episodes and one of them was wiped away entirely as being a dream? Not, like, a temporal issue ... but just an actual "I found my dead husband alive in the shower" dream?
Four things:
1) Consider the possibility that T'Pring is an unreliable narrator. She would rather lie than admit to anyone that she was involved in such illogical shenanigans.
2) Discard any idea that this was a cheap gimmick - in real terms it was probably the most expensive and effortful episode they've ever made. You don't engage Jim Henson's Creature Shop, their performers, and cut up the set you are also still using for normal filming for six months for a cheap gimmick.
3) It was not "wiped away" - the impact on Spock is permanent, regardless of whether the events were physical.
3) Even as a dream, this episode was perfect for doing what it needed to do - give us an image we can understand of what humans seem like to Vulcans, and show how Spock realizes he fits into a crew of chaos. This episode shifts Spock from experimenting with his human side, to being the creature of logic we see in TOS, and why he does that in spite of the apparent conflict.
This is why I think the season was such a miss for me. I love genre exercises and taking big swings. But .... when you only have ten episodes in the season, you shouldn't spend half the time making genre exercises to surprise and delight.
They aren't, "to surprise and delight". They aren't stunts or gimmicks. Each one is chosen for its use as a metaphor and/or frame for the development focus in the episode.
The reason that (for example) people still remember Once More With Feeling is because Buffy did it once. Once in the sixth season of 22 episodes. Once over 144 episodes.
Yes. But you know what? The specifics of many/most of the other 143... tend to blur together. When you've got these ten episodes, each one will be remembered.
More importantly, the OMWF was an actual important episode of the show. It served an important purpose other than "just have 'em sing, man." Other than "muppets," there is nothing I can say about that episode of SNW- it has no importance or relevance to Star Trek or the plot or the characters; arguably, none of the episodes do.
My frumious response - you are so incredibly, entirely, missing the point of those frames.
And maybe the fact that you can miss the point is a bit on them, though they do literally tell you what they are for a couple of times. Maybe that's the swing and the miss - the audience isn't into the thinking about stories to appreciate them.






