AI is destroying crowdfunding

Correct. That is basically the line. The established ethical protocol, whether it be games, movies, test drives in cars, whatever, is that the reviewer can be provided with the thing to be reviewed (often not given, just loaned, in the case of expensive things like cars or watches), but should not be otherwise compensated or influenced.

Being paid to review something by the creator/publisher is so far over the ethical line, the line is just a dot.

There's a weird grey area, especially with movies, where reviewers are invited to advance press screenings and given luxury treatment and made to feel special. I'm not super familiar with that world, and I think most professional movie critics are kind of immune to it by now, but 'influencers' aren't, which is why you see all those breathlessly positive early social media reactions from influencer screenings of genre movies, because they were all treated like royalty and given free stuff and made to feel special, and they want more of that. I think most professional critics are too jaded to let that influence them. But it's definitely an ethical grey area.
The converse is also true. How many times do we see reviews with the tag line that basically says, 'this product was provided for free for a review.'
 

log in or register to remove this ad


I don’t understand. How is that the converse? It’s exactly what is said, isn’t it?
You know you're right; I was approaching this from a different perspective. In both cases someone receives something for free in exchange for a review. Your post discussed everything around getting the free thing in exchange for a review. I was thinking of all the reviews where only the product was given freely for a review.
 

Or this "creator", who is churning out projects left and right, and they are all Ai. It's garbage. All of it. And what it does is hurt all of us who are actual creators, who do actual human writing or artwork. It hurts us because it's taking money we'd normally get from customers and going towards these projects. It's hurting us because we're getting lost in the ocean of AI garbage.


I really disagree with this part. I am not personally investing in any Kick Starters, but I do buy products from 3rd party creators, including some creators that use AI art. In addition to the art, I am sure some of the macros and other digital tools are AI coded. I have not yet bought anything that uses AI for writing, but I am not opposed to it philosophically.

That is my money I am spending though and I am purchasing things from them based on my choices. You could argue those creators using AI are "taking" money from me, but they are not taking money from you, because it is not your money to start with.

When Foundary Marketplace kicked AI art off of their platform I could no longer get high quality products from some of the people I previously purchased from. But it is not like I all of a sudden started buying stuff from other creators who do not use AI art. I didn't. I simply don't buy anything at all on Foundary Marketplace any more. It is not a boycott per se, they just don't have much available that appeals to me any more.
 
Last edited:

I really disagree with this part. I am not personally investing in any Kick Starters, but I do buy products from 3rd party creators, including some creators that use AI art. In addition to the art, I am sure some of the macros and other digital tools are AI coded. I have not yet bought anything that uses AI for writing, but I am not opposed to it philosophically.

That is my money I am spending though and I am purchasing things from them based on my choices. You could argue those creators using AI are "taking" money from me, but they are not taking money from you, because it is not your money to start with.

When Foundary Marketplace kicked AI art off of their platform I could no longer get high quality products from some of the people I previously purchased from. But it is not like I all of a sudden started buying stuff from other creators who do not use AI art. I didn't. I simply don't buy anything at all on Foundary Marketplace any more. It is not a boycott per se, they just don't have much available that appeals to me any more.
It's as I mentioned above. There is a finite amount of money people spend on RPGs. When the products go from 100 to 300, that money is split up to accommodate the additional choices. The original 100 see revenue drop as the money is now going to the additional 200 products.
 

I don't think it can be answered in this thread, but I wonder how many people are browsing crowdfunding sites. If it is quite common to do so then yes, I agree, the AI generated stuff will crowd out the other creators. Personally though, I think I've only really browsed kickstarter once or twice; most of what I've backed in the past is something that I've seen advertised elsewhere (often on this site). I sort of think that more people who would browse will be put off if all they see is AI gen products if that isn't what they're after so that they'll stop bothering to look and wait for someone else to advertise something that they might be interested in.
 

It's as I mentioned above. There is a finite amount of money people spend on RPGs. When the products go from 100 to 300, that money is split up to accommodate the additional choices. The original 100 see revenue drop as the money is now going to the additional 200 products.

That is just not entirely true though. The total amount spent on RPGs changes every year and exploded during COVID.

I don't have an RPG budget, I buy what I want to buy based on product and price point. I am not buying different 3rd party products because I can't buy on Foundary Marketplace, I am just for the most part only buying WOTC products now.

The extra money I might have spent on RPG products if products I wanted were available is going to other things.
 

That is just not entirely true though. The total amount spent on RPGs changes every year and exploded during COVID.

I don't have an RPG budget, I buy what I want to buy based on product and price point. I am not buying different 3rd party products because I can't buy on Foundary Marketplace, I am just for the most part only buying WOTC products now.

The extra money I might have spent on RPG products if products I wanted were available is going to other things.
Try not to think of it anecdotally. As a general rule, the more product, the more diversified the spending becomes among those products and the less each individual company gets. It's the entire concept of market share. The more companies, the less market share for each. For example, if the TTRPG market increases by 7% CAGR each year (a figure I got from Market Trends), but the number of publishers increases 40%, that's less money for each, especially for small publishers since we make up a tiny % of the market share. If 1000 small publishers make up 1% of market share, but the number of publishers goes to 1,500, that's a 50% impact on us and not so much the big guys like Hasbro or Paizo.

A few years ago, human-created products were 100%. From what I can gather by trying to look it up on various forums where people are trying to track it, it looks like between 30-40% of kickstarter RPG products are AI now.

None of us buy all the rpg stuff we'd like to have. Most of us have a finite amount of money to spend on things. I'd love to have every single metal miniature from Grenadier and Ral Partha, but it's not gonna happen lol. Actually, that's a good analogy. Look at how 3d printing has affected traditional miniature sales. Just walk into a convention and look at how many booths are selling Reaper or Wiz kids minis vs. those that are selling 3d printed minis. At least with miniatures, they aren't being created with all of the unethical and legally murky way AI is being used.

If we are looking at anecdotes, I know dozens of small publishers (1 or 2 person companies) and dozens of artists, and every single one has reported loss of income from prior years. AI isn't the only reason, of course, but the deluge of AI products we are seeing, and seeing that number rapidly increase as a ratio of total products, certainly is a factor. This isn't just business competition. That I could live with it. It's the way AI works that bothers me and how the people using it aren't putting in the work the rest of us are. (That is, it might take me a year to do a project because of the time needed for writing, editing, and getting the artwork while someone using AI churns it out in weeks). It's the resources AI uses to "create" something that was taken from my artist and writer comrades without consent or compensation. (I won't continue my diatribe on that topic because, as Morrus said, it becomes an echo, and we've discussed that to death).

Back to the point, it absolutely is true that a flood of AI products does hurt the bottom line of all the other publishers for reasons I gave above.
 

You need to look up what market share is. Your fundamental argument and position is flawed and not true. Consumers don't have an infinite amount of spending dollars. They have to choose. When you flood the market with additional products, it takes away from others' revenue. This is business economics 101.
I never talked about infinite money. I clearly said that the number of backers is enormous, and in fact a good Samaritan has corrected me, so now we know that the number of potential buyers is at least almost three times higher. For practical purposes, for people like us, that is almost the equivalent of having an infinite number of backers.
This is all just opinion and guesswork to justify what you're doing. That's not how it works. And that's not how the data I have shows.
Okay, then simply take the figure of a 5% annual increase in backers. Now that we know there were 80,000 people willing to fund TTRPG projects on Kickstarter in 2021, and five years have passed, that means there are at least another 20,000 people now compared with back then, and another 4,000 in 2027. Is that enough people for your projects, or do you need more?
Your assumption has one flaw: it's wrong. The biggest TTRPG crowdfunder in terms of backers is Avatar Legends with 80,000 backers, followed by both Cosmere and Dungeon Crawler Carl, both of which had 52K. Let's not wander around telling people their assumptions are "wrong" until you are sure you know what you're talking about eh?
Thank you very much, this really strengthens my theory.
My personal opinion, if you have to use AI, then you should not be selling it at all.
True. Fortunately, that's just your opinion.
It's as I mentioned above. There is a finite amount of money people spend on RPGs. When the products go from 100 to 300, that money is split up to accommodate the additional choices. The original 100 see revenue drop as the money is now going to the additional 200 products.
We already understand that you want people to buy from you rather than from others, but you are replying to a comment that you do not seem to have understood: there are people who not only have no problem with AI art, but may actually prefer it.

No one owns other people's tastes and preferences, no matter how much that bothers you. When you sell a product, you are competing, and there will always be someone whose strategies you do not approve of, but that is irrelevant.
 

I have to assume its some level of 'well even if its AI, this person must have tested it, polished it, and had it finished professionally...right?'

Queue up the Anakin/Padme meme.
If a person is using AI to write their text, for example, they might not have the writing skills to properly polish it, or even know what good and bad writing looks like. Same goes with AI images or vibe coding. Or want to pay someone else who could.
 

Remove ads

Top