D&D 5E (2024) Amyone have Experience with Hollow Warden Ranger

I saw a Hollow Warden in play recently but it was wildly different from @ECMO3 's ideas here so idk how useful it is, but at level 5 it had IIRC 2 levels of monk with a plan to go to level 4 monk and all other levels Ranger. I wanna say she was thinking Mercy Monk or the new arcane monk, or a homebrew Kensei update. For now though the two levels mostly give added utility and a bonus action attack when not needing the BA for other stuff. Dagger becomes a d6 weapon, and then she has shortbow for advantage when she has to do range.

Seemed like a lot of fun, but for my money...I would use a different ranger subclass on that sort of build. Maybe Fey Wanderer, maybe Hunter if i am feeling like the build has enough complexity already.
 

log in or register to remove this ad

Booming Blade, Green Flame Blade, and True Strike, do not need any focus, the material component is the weapon.
None of these are as good as Shillelagh after the Hollow Warden gets their second attack, and a lot of tables disallow the "blade" cantrips in 5.5 (some even disallow them in 5.0). And you want to have your focus in hand for casting those higher level ranger spells (this is another one that is more important for Winter Walker if they want to use Ice Knife without juggling).
Yes, for anyone but a druid, they do.
Shillelagh is the one you want, and that was buffed in 5.5. After that Starry Wisp is a handy ranged attack (Frostbite for Winter Walker). Picking up utility spells with a Fighting Style feat is a waste no matter which one you use.
they really do not need any druid cantrips
Sure. That character is past helping and should try and get their head bitten off by a troll. Ranger/Clerics haven't been good since BG1/2.
 
Last edited:

I saw a Hollow Warden in play recently but it was wildly different from @ECMO3 's ideas here so idk how useful it is, but at level 5 it had IIRC 2 levels of monk with a plan to go to level 4 monk and all other levels Ranger. I wanna say she was thinking Mercy Monk or the new arcane monk, or a homebrew Kensei update. For now though the two levels mostly give added utility and a bonus action attack when not needing the BA for other stuff. Dagger becomes a d6 weapon, and then she has shortbow for advantage when she has to do range.

Seemed like a lot of fun, but for my money...I would use a different ranger subclass on that sort of build. Maybe Fey Wanderer, maybe Hunter if i am feeling like the build has enough complexity already.
Yeah, Monk is a good multiclass option. And Warrior of the Mystic arts stacks spell slots and uses the same casting stat.

Rogue works too, but I haven't thought it though enough to suggest a subclass. Need to check if you can still get extra sneak attacks when it's not your turn in 5.5.
 

I saw a Hollow Warden in play recently but it was wildly different from @ECMO3 's ideas here so idk how useful it is, but at level 5 it had IIRC 2 levels of monk with a plan to go to level 4 monk and all other levels Ranger. I wanna say she was thinking Mercy Monk or the new arcane monk, or a homebrew Kensei update. For now though the two levels mostly give added utility and a bonus action attack when not needing the BA for other stuff. Dagger becomes a d6 weapon, and then she has shortbow for advantage when she has to do range.

Seemed like a lot of fun, but for my money...I would use a different ranger subclass on that sort of build. Maybe Fey Wanderer, maybe Hunter if i am feeling like the build has enough complexity already.

Monk dips work great on Ranger's in general. My default Ranger, if I am playing a mostly Ranger PC is a Fey Wanderer with 1 level of Monk.
 

None of these are as good as Shillelagh after the Hollow Warden gets their second attack, and a lot of tables disallow the "blade" cantrips in 5.5 (some even disallow them in 5.0). And you want to have your focus in hand for casting those higher level ranger spells (this is another one that is more important for Winter Walker if they want to use Ice Knife without juggling).

This has never been a problem for me in play, mostly because juggling is so easy, but also a lot of Ranger spells use a weapon as the Material Component.
 

Druidic warrior cantrips are Ranger cantrips. Which means you can cast them with your spellcasting focus (staff). Arcane Warrior Cantrips are wizard spells, so you can’t.

A Quarterstaff is an Arcane Focus too, moreover though the Wizard Cantrips you would cast in combat either don't require material components or use a weapon.
 

None of these are as good as Shillelagh after the Hollow Warden gets their second attack, and a lot of tables disallow the "blade" cantrips in 5.5 (some even disallow them in 5.0).
I have never seen anyone ban them, and they are a completely legal option in "5.5", because the edition hasnt changed. Tasha's is still 100% part of the current rules.
And you want to have your focus in hand for casting those higher level ranger spells (this is another one that is more important for Winter Walker if they want to use Ice Knife without juggling).
Not really an issue. "Juggling" isn't a problem in the current rules.
Shillelagh is the one you want, and that was buffed in 5.5. After that Starry Wisp is a handy ranged attack (Frostbite for Winter Walker). Picking up utility spells with a Fighting Style feat is a waste no matter which one you use.
Shillelegh cannot be used with a bow, and bow with truestrike or two normal bow shots is much better than starry wisp or any other druid cantrip.
Sure. That character is past helping and should try and get their head bitten off by a troll. Ranger/Clerics haven't been good since BG1/2.
Eh you are exagerating the case.
Yeah, Monk is a good multiclass option. And Warrior of the Mystic arts stacks spell slots and uses the same casting stat.

Rogue works too, but I haven't thought it though enough to suggest a subclass. Need to check if you can still get extra sneak attacks when it's not your turn in 5.5.
You do. They tried in one playtest packet to take thst away and everyone said nah.
This has never been a problem for me in play, mostly because juggling is so easy, but also a lot of Ranger spells use a weapon as the Material Component.
Yeah i dont know anyone playing rangers as mini druid spellcasters, unless they are MC druid to begin with. (Not a dip, a real MC)

ALTHOUGH, Hollow Warden with at least 3 levels of druid could be fun potentially. Very different thing from what you are shooting for though.
 

Sure. That character is past helping and should try and get their head bitten off by a troll. Ranger/Clerics haven't been good since BG1/2.

I think this PC is going to work out pretty well. It has worked so far, but I have never played a Hollow Warden so I could be wrong I guess. Like I said earlier, with all her bonus actions Shillelagh would not be a good option on this PC.

In addition to heavy Armor, there are a lot of great 1st level Cleric spells I would not otherwise have access too and it helps my spell casting progression. I've done a lot of Monk multiclasses with Ranger and some Rogue multiclasses. They have positives, but they really put a dent into your spell casting. I have not done any Clerics before with Ranger but I have done Bards, Warlocks and Wizards with Ranger .... and one Druid level on one PC, and not weakening your spellcasting with a level is really nice.

Sometimes I think people get too wrapped around traditional class identity, like the earlier comment on not wearing heavy armor for Stealth. I think the mechanics are going to work well though for the kind of PC I want to play (not a stealthy scouting one).

I play more Rangers that any other class, but they are rarely the Ranger stereotype. Usually they are a high Charisma, high wisdom Face PC with the Fey Wanderer subclass really driving Frightened and control options. When not that it is usually a dip for another PC to get weapon masteries and low level Ranger spells.
 
Last edited:

I think this PC is going to work out pretty well. It has worked so far, but I have never played a Hollow Warden so I could be wrong I guess. Like I said earlier, with all her bonus actions Shillelagh would not be a good option on this PC.

In addition to heavy Armor, there are a lot of great 1st level Cleric spells I would not otherwise have access too and it helps my spell casting progression. I've done a lot of Monk multiclasses with Ranger and some Rogue multiclasses. They have positives, but they really put a dent into your spell casting. I have not done any Clerics before with Ranger but I have done Bards, Warlocks and Wizards with Ranger .... and one Druid level on one PC, and not weakening your spellcasting with a level is really nice.

Sometimes I think people get too wrapped around traditional class identity, like the earlier comment on not wearing heavy armor for Stealth. I think the mechanics are going to work well though for the kind of PC I want to play (not a stealthy scouting one).

I play more Rangers that any other class, but they are rarely the Ranger stereotype. Usually they are a high Charisma, high wisdom Face PC with the Fey Wanderer subclass really driving Frightened and control options. When not that it is usually a dip for another PC to get weapon masteries and low level Ranger spells.
It does seem like an odd (but totally valid) choice to ignore most of what makes the ranger distinct when building a ranger. Especially when the mechanics themselves arent exactly what normally attracts anyone to the class. Is the Hollow Warden subclass really that appealing?
 


Remove ads

Top