D&D 5E (2024) Amyone have Experience with Hollow Warden Ranger

Because the whole idea that heavy armor is incompatible with dexterity is ridiculous. Pate armor is lighter than the body armor and gear a modern infantryman wears into battle.

Here is a video of a guy doing cartwheels in plate:


The whole idea that armor is incompatible with dexterity is a D&Dism designed to provide mechanics and a design space for the fantasy of a light fighter that does not use "heavy" armor while also providing design space for a different design of a fighter that gains mechanical benefits for armor.
look, I agree with you, but mechanics are that you really do not want heavy armor with high dex.

only thing that is real is that you Stealth is destroyed with full plate.
you can hear that cartwheel at night at couple of KM distance.
 

log in or register to remove this ad

another view would be, why would a dex fighter even bother to look at heavy armor let alone practice to be proficient with it?
Seems like stealth course would be a better semester in fighter school for that specific individual.
Dex characters already have enough advantages. They certainly dont need more benefits for nothing, which is what a dex character trading away heavy armor proficiency is.
 

Back to the original topic. I am 4th level now (Ranger 3/Cleric 1) so Wrath of the Wild just came online last session. I don't have enough for Splint Mail, let alone Plate yet so that is hurting AC a bit and I really need to drive AC higher. The reaction attack with wrath of the wild up and Graze is pretty awesome... the first time they hit you they take damage.

I am really digging the subclass though. Enough that I wat to try it again in another Campaign coming up. That new campaign will be level 9-20, so starting at a higher level. It will also have a significant social pillar. This particular group has 3 other players that really despise being in a talking role. One of them often plays a Bard or Sorcerer, but they still won't actually do any talking to NPCs. As a result, I need to play the party "Face". Normally that is easy - a Fey Wanderer with max Wisdom and a 13 or 14 Charisma is the best face build in the game, but I really want to try another Hollow Wardnen.

For this new campaign I theorycrafted 2 different ways to solve this with a 2-level dip in another class. Both use a Human with Arcane Infiltrator Origin Feat wearing medium armor and expertise in Persuasion at Ranger 2 (level 3), expertise in Deception and Intimidation at Ranger 9 (level 11)

1. 2-level Fighter dip, extra origin feat is Magic Initiate (Wizard) for Truestrike and Light. D17/C14/W16/CH10. I will not be awesome at face skills with a 0 Charisma, but I will be ok with expertise for most of the Campaign and I can bolster them with Tactical Mind from Fighter. This PC would use Druid Warrior(Shillelagh, guidance) and Two Weapon Fighting (S. Sword/Shillelagh club and Scimitar) with a Longbow for ranged attacks. Would have Defensive Duelist Feat and then Wisdom ASIs. This also uses either thrown daggers or truestrike-Javelins for Wrathful Smite at range. This build has a 5 weapon masteries, letting me use Nck with thrown daggers and Topple with a Truestrike Trident in addition to L.Bow-Slow, S.Sword-Vex and Scimitar-Nick .

2. 2-level Warlock dip, extra origin feat Magic Initiate (Druid) for Shillelagh and Light. Start as a Warlock D14/C12/W17/Ch15, for Warlock Invocations use Pact of Blade, Agonizing Eldritch Blast and Lessons of the First Ones-Cult of the Dragon Initiate). Use Dueling fighting with a shield and a Pact Rapier/Battlaxe or Shillelagh Quarterstaff. Use Eldritch Blast for Ranged attacks. Ranger 4 get Dragonscarred feat (CH16). Ranger 8 get Inspiring Leader on Wisdom, Ranger 12 Wisdom ASI. This character would have great Charisma skills because of the higher Charisma, but lack the boost tactical mind offers. This PCs has more spell power and more damage-type options with Pact Of the Blade and at most levels is a lot better at long ranged attacks (up to 120 feet). Also this really leverages Frightened getting it from both Dragonscarred and Wrath of the Wild. Picking up Dragonscarred makes Wrathful Smite mostly redundant but saves spell slots. I should get an extra Heroic Inspiration every short rest with this design and 2 Pact Slots for Hunter's Mark without cutting into Ranger spells or Favored Enemy uses would be good.

Another thing to consider is this is a campaign going to 20th level and having a couple Warlock levels opens up a bunch of good high-level magic staffs, while 2 fighter levels don't do much for that.

Thoughts??
 
Last edited:


I am 4th level now (Ranger 3/Cleric 1) so Wrath of the Wild just came online last session. I don't have enough for Splint Mail, let alone Plate yet so that is hurting AC a bit and I really need to drive AC higher. The reaction attack with wrath of the wild up and Graze is pretty awesome... the first time they hit you they take damage.
Sounds like HAM was the right choice for a feat next level then.

It does make me wonder how the typical Hollow Warden deals with this. It does seem like most builds go for high AC, but not so many for Heavy Armor. I can't really recall any specific builds I've seen though.
 

Sounds like HAM was the right choice for a feat next level then.

It does make me wonder how the typical Hollow Warden deals with this. It does seem like most builds go for high AC, but not so many for Heavy Armor. I can't really recall any specific builds I've seen though.
It’s like heavy armor monk or barbarian. Wearing it disables key ranger abilities like stealth and mobility. And a Dex build ranger is only one pip behind anyway. Their AC is good enough to do the job. It’s the fear effect that is important to the hollow warden, which they also deliver through Wrathful Smite. So their spell save DC also matters.

If you just want a higher AC ranger (generally overkill) there are better ways to do that than Hollow Warden.
 
Last edited:


Sounds like HAM was the right choice for a feat next level then.

It does make me wonder how the typical Hollow Warden deals with this. It does seem like most builds go for high AC, but not so many for Heavy Armor. I can't really recall any specific builds I've seen though.

I have not seen any specific builds, the one I am playing now is the only Hollow Warden I have seen played. Using White Room analysis though, I think high dexterity with Defensive Duelist feat would be a good option. The reaction for Defensive Duelist will bite into your AOO from Wrath of the Wild .... but then if you are using a Finesse weapon you really are not doing much damage on an AOO anyway.
 
Last edited:

It’s like heavy armor monk or barbarian. Wearing it disables key ranger abilities like stealth and mobility. And a Dex build ranger is only one pip behind anyway.

It is disingenuous to compare it to a Monk or Barbarian that actually loses their signature class-defining ability in heavy armor. As a point of fact at 4th level this is not true at all.

I don't have any extra movement yet, so my base mobility (30 feet) is exactly the same as a single class Ranger in medium (or light) armor. However with 2 more spell slots my situational mobility is higher considering I can cast Jump, Zephyr Strike and/or Longstrider more often. I agree Heavy Armor will bite into mobility at higher levels.

My stealth in heavy armor is also exactly the same as it would be wearing medium armor I can afford (and light armor would be more than 1 point worse). I would also not consider Stealth a key ability for this PC, her key skills from the Raner class are Athletics and Survival.

So this is factually not true at this point, some of it will be true later.


Their AC is good enough to do the job.

This also has not been true in play so far either. Right now my AC is limited by funds, but I have an equivalent AC to a Dex Ranger in Scale and I had a difficult time near the end of level 3 despite having the Shield spell.

I think the basic medium armor AC will get the job done if you are playing a skirmisher or a Gish, but it will not get the job done for a front liner, not without some help.
 
Last edited:


Remove ads

Top