Baldur's Gate 3: Astarion, a review

Astarion, the charming vampire spawn rogue companion NPC from Baldur's Gate 3 gets the spotlight in this new novel detailing his backstory.
One of the most popular NPCs in the Baldur’s Gate 3 video game was the high elven vampire spawn rogue Astarion. His performer, Neil Newbon even won Best Performance at TGA in 2023 for the portrayal.

So it’s no surprise that a prequel novel delving into Astarion Ancunin’s backstory was commissioned, and Penguin Random House didn’t skimp. Baldur’s Gate 3: Astarion was written by Hugo Award-winning author T. Kingfisher. Neil Newbon is the audiobook narrator.

BG3-Astarion-Cover.jpg

The book covers two parallel periods in Astarion’s life. It opens with Astarion bleeding in an alley after a severe beating, but rather than dying, vampire Cazador Szarr discovers him, turning Astarion into a vampire spawn in his thrall. It then cuts to Astarion as a child growing up on a vineyard with a father who doesn’t understand him and a druid mom who shape-shifts and flies away when stressed.

It’s during that rural upbringing that Astarion learns to follow the letter of instructions while ignoring the intent as he sees fit, an ability that eventually leads to him becoming a magistrate years later. But is it just a learned trait? Or something specific to Astarion’s personality? Probably a bit of both according to this novel.

If you’re thinking that Astarion growing up on a vineyard isn’t what you expected from his foppish behavior and obsession with style and fashion, that’s because it was the smallest part of his upbringing. Eventually, due to a promise his mother made before he was born, Astarion is whisked away to be raised as a noble in a fading but previously formidable Silverymoon household. The luxury suits Astarion’s temperament much better and, with the aid of a cousin, eventually leads him from practicing law in Silverymoon to becoming a magistrate in Baldur’s Gate.

Those flashbacks are not without mystery or danger, and yet are lighter in tone from the other timeline. Cazador may have “saved his life” in a fashion, but in exchange Astarion alternates between luring prey back to Cazador’s lair for him to feed and evading or surviving the sadist’s games, as well as torment from others in the vampire spawn "family."

One of those games, “a friendly competition” leads to the main part of the story. Cazador orders his spawn to compete to bring him the most rare blood. The winner might be turned into a full vampire, granting freedom Astarion longs for.

While he knows it’s likely a trick, Astarion cannot resist the prospect of freedom from the abusive vampire. He'd also be punished if he refused "to play." A rumor about the blood of a dead god hidden under Baldur’s Gate seems like his best chance, assuming he survives.

As if dealing with a cult and its undead army isn’t enough, Astarion has to team up with an Aasimar paladin, Hahn den Suriel, at one point. Hahn doesn’t realize at first that Astarion is a vampire spawn. Being caught between oaths keeps him from killing Astarion when he does discover Astarion's true nature it.

I found the story engaging, and alternated between wanting to shake Astarion and feeling for him. That said, whether this prequel fits what you might have imagined as Astarion’s backstory could vary widely. It worked for me, blending Astarion’s guile, selfishness, vulnerability, and wit.

Regardless, the audiobook production is excellent. For most books, choosing between ebook, physical book, and audiobook will depend will entirely depend upon one’s usual reading preferences. For this book, if you can tolerate audiobooks at all (not everyone can), the audiobook is absolutely the way to go. It’s more than just reading the words. Newbon delivers a full vocal performance as in depth as anything he did for the video game.

The book does open with a content warning for torture and sexual assault. It’s definitely not juvenile reading, but neither was Dungeons & Dragons Ravenloft: Heir to Strahd. The horror side of D&D novels doesn’t soft pedal the horror.

I really enjoyed Baldur’s Gate 3: Astarion, and recommend it not just for Baldur’s Gate 3 fans, but anyone who enjoys fantasy horror or fiction set in RPG worlds. Rating: A-.
 

log in or register to remove this ad

Beth Rimmels

Beth Rimmels

What a horrible review which actively ignores all the issues with this book. Shame on you. What a shill.
I see the issue. You seem to have confused EN World with the YouTube comments section. Since you created an account for the sole purpose of calling people names, I'll help relieve you of it. Folks, if you want to post here, you need to know how to interact with other human beings.
 

log in or register to remove this ad

While... some posters may have trouble expressing issues with the book in a positive and constructive manner, I do think there's plenty worth criticizing.
Spoilers Ahead:
The book retcons/gets wrong a lot of stuff about Astarion from the game. Astarion is a lot nicer, Cazador is still cruel but not as relentlessly so as the game. Astarion gets a very kind paladin boyfriend that literally breaks his oath to be with Astarion. The spawn know about the ritual room in the book, and one of them even sneaks into it... somehow not noticing the thousands of vampire spawn captives Cazador is holding for the ritual. Astarion's racism against the Gur is removed and he was attacked by just some random thugs in the book (that last one was apparently an editorial mandate, but I can't help but feel even then it could have been handled better.)

Basically there's a lot of stuff that seems there to soften or sanitize the character for mass consumption. On the other hand, Astarion isn't required to seduce people before bringing them back to Cazador--he chooses to do that. I would argue that the book makes Astarion an active rapist rather than someone forced into sexual slavery. So it both softens him in many ways but then makes him far worse in others. The retcons also make many of the things he tells you in the game lies. It's... IMO, just not a respectful or nuanced portrayal of abuse. It basically makes the shallow mask Astarion presents in Act 1 as his whole character.
 

I had no idea this book existed, I only came into the thread because I was wondering why someone was reviewing the character of Astarion from baldur's gate 3. I could imagine someone reviewing the game, but just one of the characters I thought was a little weird.
 

While... some posters may have trouble expressing issues with the book in a positive and constructive manner, I do think there's plenty worth criticizing.
I was honestly curious what was being criticized about the book, so thanks for the summary of your own criticisms. Are you aware of others? I'm not here to argue about it, I just wonder about the general discussion. It's interesting, because in the game, Astarion can become a monster if you make the wrong choices, or he can turn out to be relatively kind, if you lead him by example for long enough, without disrespecting him. There's really no one single version of him. So I can imagine how some will struggle with any given portrayal. With that in mind, I'm also curious about issues beyond that, and you certainly point to a few.
 


I was honestly curious what was being criticized about the book, so thanks for the summary of your own criticisms. Are you aware of others? I'm not here to argue about it, I just wonder about the general discussion. It's interesting, because in the game, Astarion can become a monster if you make the wrong choices, or he can turn out to be relatively kind, if you lead him by example for long enough, without disrespecting him. There's really no one single version of him. So I can imagine how some will struggle with any given portrayal. With that in mind, I'm also curious about issues beyond that, and you certainly point to a few.
Well to be clear, I haven't read it myself. I'm relaying the criticisms of others after hearing several very in depth reviews.

Obviously quality is subjective but just in terms of what the novel retcons or changes from the game, this video is a great breakdown.
 

I was honestly curious what was being criticized about the book, so thanks for the summary of your own criticisms. Are you aware of others? I'm not here to argue about it, I just wonder about the general discussion. It's interesting, because in the game, Astarion can become a monster if you make the wrong choices, or he can turn out to be relatively kind, if you lead him by example for long enough, without disrespecting him. There's really no one single version of him. So I can imagine how some will struggle with any given portrayal. With that in mind, I'm also curious about issues beyond that, and you certainly point to a few.
He comes across as different again if you run him as the PC, as I am doing in my current run. Astarion is a particularly ambivalent character. I'm sure the novel is based on the author's experience of them, and probably consultations with his original writers.

But I noticed during early access that the EA forums were dominated by people with rather extreme views about the characters, alignment, and FR lore. For some reason the property seems to attract these people.
 

Seriously. The same tendency has led the Baldur's Gate 3 subreddit to become a very strange place over time. I unsubscribed because it seemed every second post was someone taking deep personal offense at this book (or at the upcoming TV series for which we have no details).
We're talking about the same subreddit that gave Withers big naturals? What do you mean "become" strange?
 



Remove ads

Remove ads

Top