D&D General Basic 5.5 Classes

My friend and I were discussing classes the other day, and while he hasn't played in a while, he buys all the books and reads them. And we eventually came to the same conclusion: There should be basic classes. Ones without subclasses. Ones without frills. Ones with minimal choices during combat. So we proceeded to lay out a few ideas:

  • Basic classes increase the damage die of a weapon or cantrip by one tier. (d8 becomes a d10, a d10 becomes a d12. Maybe a d12 gets d12 +d4.)
  • Basic classes increase their number of attacks/cantrips one level before other classes. (fighter gets 2 attacks starting at level 4, warlock gets 2 eldritch blasts at level 4 instead of 5.)
  • Basic classes cannot take feats or multiclass. They do get +3 ability points every four levels though. (spent as +2, +1 or +1, +1, +1)
  • Basic classes can go to 22 on their ability scores instead of 20.
  • Basic classes still get the regular skill and equipment proficiency.

So basically, basic classes are super focused classes. For example, a basic fighter might get to choose 2 weapons to focus on. Those weapons do not harbor their weapon mastery properties. They just do more damage and learn it faster than the other classes. Same with spells. A basic wizard might get two cantrips. Those spells deliver more damage and at an increase at an earlier level.

We thought it might help beginners learn the game or help players that are indecisive or help speed up tables that host a lot of players.

Thoughts? I am sure there is a lot missing from this, but it was just a brainstorming breakfast conversation.
 

log in or register to remove this ad

Initial thought is to not change some of the base classes as a whole assumptions. 5th level is when you get two attacks and bumps to the cantrips. Changing this for some might confuse things. Certain cantrips do certain damage and bumping this might be confusing as well.

I can see having a base class subclass. A Fighter- Fighter subclass could just have base things to make it easy. Then people will just say that the Champion is the base/easy thing so why do something else. Likely the same with Evoker Wizard, Life Cleric, and Rogue Thief.
 

Long ago a couple friends and I theorized an idea of having basic, advanced, exotic, and expert classes. There would be a warrior, rogue, priest, and mage for each one.

The basic classes would have no real subclasses and just get an early choice then feats.

Their strength woulf be that they get very strength general bonuses.

Like a Brute would get 1d4/1d6/1d8/etc to all weapon damage and Str, Dex, and Con checks.

The healer just got more dice to Cure Wounds and Inflict Wounds. Not slots just X casts per rest.
 

I like the idea, but I also agree with @aco175 that changing the levels some abilities are gotten at may be more confusing than helpful.

My take on how to do this would be to create a "basic subclass" which at the levels it is supposed to give features instead just increases the base class abilities further.

So the basic fighter subclass for example might be something along the lines of:

3rd level: 1 extra Second Wind at the start of the day (still just 1 more per Short Rest after that).

7th level: one extra Action Surge at the start of the day (still just 1 more per SR after that).

10th level: one extra Indomitable per day.

If that is not strong enough, then tweak the numbers of extra usages, or make them scale more often still.

But basically, give no extra features, just give more uses of existing features.

I think there is a way to make it balanced and even competitive. It’s also interesting for multi-class builds that for example want a dash of fighter flavor without going too deep into a very specific theme. Just general fighter flavor, then dip into the basic sub, while your main class can carry the main flavor of the character with its sub.

But anyway, multi-classing aside, I do think this would make it easier for casual players too.
 


I think I'd do what was done in the past with the basic, just remove any extra subclasses and have the subclasses set, in the past it was champion fighter, life priest, evoker wizard, and (I'm assuming) thief rogue. Remove the bits that mention subclass and just replace them with the subclass abilities.
 

So...why not just play Basic? It pretty much works as described.
Our thought was for mixed tables. Sometimes you have a single player that just want something simple, or a player that uses large chunks of time during their turn, which in turn, brings the game for the other players to a crawl.

If it was for an entire group, I would just use basic.
 

I got you.

 

My friend and I were discussing classes the other day, and while he hasn't played in a while, he buys all the books and reads them. And we eventually came to the same conclusion: There should be basic classes. Ones without subclasses. Ones without frills. Ones with minimal choices during combat. So we proceeded to lay out a few ideas:
My absolute requirement for that would be that they can not covewr a single character concept or archetype that couldn't be done with another class. I wouldn't want to have to compromise on a character idea because a designer decided that my concept was covered under something 'basic'.

Which would require effecively two copies of each class that was basic, the basic one and a normal one.

For space we can just print them once, and indicate where there are no choices.

Oh wait, every choice in the 5.5e PHB already has indicated a default choice.

So this is already done.

Congratulations, what you and your friend desire already is being done. Without the power creep.
 

My friend and I were discussing classes the other day, and while he hasn't played in a while, he buys all the books and reads them. And we eventually came to the same conclusion: There should be basic classes. Ones without subclasses. Ones without frills. Ones with minimal choices during combat. So we proceeded to lay out a few ideas:

  • Basic classes increase the damage die of a weapon or cantrip by one tier. (d8 becomes a d10, a d10 becomes a d12. Maybe a d12 gets d12 +d4.)
  • Basic classes increase their number of attacks/cantrips one level before other classes. (fighter gets 2 attacks starting at level 4, warlock gets 2 eldritch blasts at level 4 instead of 5.)
  • Basic classes cannot take feats or multiclass. They do get +3 ability points every four levels though. (spent as +2, +1 or +1, +1, +1)
  • Basic classes can go to 22 on their ability scores instead of 20.
  • Basic classes still get the regular skill and equipment proficiency.

So basically, basic classes are super focused classes. For example, a basic fighter might get to choose 2 weapons to focus on. Those weapons do not harbor their weapon mastery properties. They just do more damage and learn it faster than the other classes. Same with spells. A basic wizard might get two cantrips. Those spells deliver more damage and at an increase at an earlier level.

We thought it might help beginners learn the game or help players that are indecisive or help speed up tables that host a lot of players.

Thoughts? I am sure there is a lot missing from this, but it was just a brainstorming breakfast conversation.

The first thing I would do if these existed was multiclass them to get the mechanical benefits while still having the frills. So take one class of Basic Warrior then immediately multiclass to Champion and do 1d10 with my Longsword and Shield.
 

Remove ads

Top