D&D 5E (2024) Best Arcane Caster. Sorcerer VsWizard. Dungeon Dudes: Sorcerer "Won"


log in or register to remove this ad


No summary is perfect. I thought yours was fine.

Wizards k8nda got nerfed as well. Bo more unlimited misty steps and shield spells.

Missed that.

Not sure wat the best soelkcaster is. I rate support higher tgan the internet for example.

Probably cleric, maybe druid and some bards.
 

I'm not theorycrafting as such. More experience plus I own a large pile of WotC adventures.
When you turn your experiences into claims about the game in general, you are theorycrafting.

I'm not making assumptions around how the games actually played. WotC and designers have provided data and how the game is being played.
You literally are. I've given you data too, from WotC themselves, and you rejected it because you claimed using it was white room. Your excuse now doesn't change that.

If my use of WotC data in the past wasn't enough of a shield to fend off "theorycrafting", why is yours?

Why is there a double standard?

Lower levels and less encounters are recurring things. Apparently they're leveling up a lot faster as well. New adventure is 1.5 sessions per lvl approximately.
Irrelevant. You have explicitly and specifically told me, on multiple occasions, that a pattern observed does not and cannot excuse "white room" arguments.

I'm not theory crafting specific builds. Im not number crunching. U plsy s lot of D&D and have seen 5 or 6 of the new sorcerers in action.
I never said anything about specific builds. "Sorcerer is the strongest caster" is still, unequivocally, a theorycrafting statement. Because you yourself have told me that me saying Wizard is the strongest caster is theorycrafting.

Hello pot. You're looking rather carbonized today.

Also? You absolutely have done number crunching. You absolutely have actually presented BUILDS in favor of this. Just not in this singular thread. You started threads, plural, to discuss whether your theoretical builds would achieve the results you were seeking.

That.

Is.

Theory.

Crafting.

Always has been. Always will be.

3.X I suspect was a lot of theorycrafting on forums. Lvl 5 this, 3 PrC that, 2 this two that lvl 12. I suspect most builds like that were pure theorycraft.
Utterly irrelevant.

When you build a theory of character options based upon synthesizing your personal observations, you are theorycrafting.

I think the wizards rule thing has been vastly over blown at least at levels people actually play at.
I'm well aware of this position. I disagree with it. I believe you project your own false assumptions about what it is like to play a Wizard onto others. Had I played a Wizard in my current campaign, rather than a Sorcerer (because I just like playing Sorcerers for thematics, regardless of their mechanics), I would have been much more powerful. Unequivocally more powerful.

Would I play a wizard in a game if I cared about mechanics? Probably not unless non phb options were available and the game started at a higher lvl Probably lvl 6. Ymmv of course.
And that thing right there? That "Would I play X in a game if I cared about mechanics? Probably not" LITERALLY IS you demonstrating theorycrafting. You are making a claim that is a universal claim about the mechanical effectiveness of characters. That IS theorycrafting.

You only disagree because you see the label of "theorycrafting" as a negative. How could this harmless analysis be the horrible boogeyman of "theorycrafting"!? Because it is--by its structure. You are presenting a theory of character creation: Don't play Wizards, they suck until you reach levels that "nobody" plays, so don't bother. It's a trap. Choose this other thing, which is vastly more powerful in the levels you'll actually play.
 

If he wanted me to consume his ideas, he could have written an essay. I'm almost never in a time where I can consume video content without distracting someone else with the noise. Besides, essays are much easier to dissect than video because skipping around to listen to sections multiple times to digest the subtle difference between specific word choices is a pain.
No the thread does not support that assertion either. You have repeatedly refused to divorce yourself from your personal N=1 table "experience" and talk about what you feel are contributing factors to why your experience differs from that of the posters you are disagreeing with --AND-- you also have done the same when other posters post how they see a trend you do not but feel that a particular set of rules/design elements contribute to what they perceive at their table in play. That exhausting trend is bookended by some flavor of "ZOMG that's just theorycrafting and has no place in discussion" or "portent so your observation is impossible" chewbacca defense for continuing a decade of "MOAR POWAH for sorcerer". The video is being discussed by those who regularly see sorcerer as extremely good and can identify specific design choices setting that stage at their table because the distraction can be dismissed entirely by pointing out how it was already addressed

There's nothing wrong with having a differing perception, but having a differing perception and being unable or unwilling to elaborate on elements one feels contribute to why it differs provides little room for discussion other than "um? ok.... moving on", it does not negate or disprove what others perceive at their table or overrule what they feel contributes to what they perceive simply because others are not at your table & they cannot fill in the contributing factors for you in order to discuss them.
 
Last edited:

When you turn your experiences into claims about the game in general, you are theorycrafting.


You literally are. I've given you data too, from WotC themselves, and you rejected it because you claimed using it was white room. Your excuse now doesn't change that.

If my use of WotC data in the past wasn't enough of a shield to fend off "theorycrafting", why is yours?

Why is there a double standard?


Irrelevant. You have explicitly and specifically told me, on multiple occasions, that a pattern observed does not and cannot excuse "white room" arguments.


I never said anything about specific builds. "Sorcerer is the strongest caster" is still, unequivocally, a theorycrafting statement. Because you yourself have told me that me saying Wizard is the strongest caster is theorycrafting.

Hello pot. You're looking rather carbonized today.

Also? You absolutely have done number crunching. You absolutely have actually presented BUILDS in favor of this. Just not in this singular thread. You started threads, plural, to discuss whether your theoretical builds would achieve the results you were seeking.

That.

Is.

Theory.

Crafting.

Always has been. Always will be.


Utterly irrelevant.

When you build a theory of character options based upon synthesizing your personal observations, you are theorycrafting.


I'm well aware of this position. I disagree with it. I believe you project your own false assumptions about what it is like to play a Wizard onto others. Had I played a Wizard in my current campaign, rather than a Sorcerer (because I just like playing Sorcerers for thematics, regardless of their mechanics), I would have been much more powerful. Unequivocally more powerful.


And that thing right there? That "Would I play X in a game if I cared about mechanics? Probably not" LITERALLY IS you demonstrating theorycrafting. You are making a claim that is a universal claim about the mechanical effectiveness of characters. That IS theorycrafting.

You only disagree because you see the label of "theorycrafting" as a negative. How could this harmless analysis be the horrible boogeyman of "theorycrafting"!? Because it is--by its structure. You are presenting a theory of character creation: Don't play Wizards, they suck until you reach levels that "nobody" plays, so don't bother. It's a trap. Choose this other thing, which is vastly more powerful in the levels you'll actually play.

What data explicitly are you referencing?

I font think it's a hot take these days acknowledging games are actually being played at vastly lower levels than previous online assumptions.

I dont think a high level wizard is powerful is a hot take.

But if youre not reaching those high levels.

Reading 5.5 adventures you don't need any classes in particular. Hence why the video is claiming versatility is over rated. And DM dependent when it comes to buying scrolls.
 

What data explicitly are you referencing?
Insufficient short rests, causing short-rest-based classes in 5.0 to fall behind.

You explicitly told me that that was theorycrafting. It came to us directly from WotC. They explicitly said they were redesigning things because of it. I had been making that point for years. You dismissed it every time, even when I had WotC themselves with me.

I font think it's a hot take these days acknowledging games are actually being played at vastly lower levels than previous online assumptions.
I could not care less if it is a hot take or an absolute-zero take. It is still theorizing. You are not omniscient. You are taking your understanding, based on the sample you personally experienced, with all the biases and imperfections associated with it, and then making a blanket statement that applies to everyone else. The Sorcerer is stronger than the Wizard, for XYZ mechanical reasons.

That is theorycrafting.

I dont think a high level wizard is powerful is a hot take.
Again, whether it is as hot as the surface of the Sun or as cold as the depths of intergalactic space is absolutely irrelevant. It is a claim about mechanical power independent of individual table context. You have repeatedly, explicitly rejected every argument I've ever made about that topic. Now, you do it without a second thought, and balk at being treated to the exact same arguments you used against me.

But if youre not reaching those high levels.
Irrelevant. It is a theory you have built based upon the personal experience you have, and analysis you have done of the mechanics. That is what theorycrafting is: constructing a theory of mechanical value based on observation and analysis. What else could it possibly mean?

Reading 5.5 adventures you don't need any classes in particular. Hence why the video is claiming versatility is over rated. And DM dependent when it comes to buying scrolls.
RE: first sentence, I've never said otherwise. Versatility is flatly not overrated, or if it is, only by an extremely small degree. Anyone who thinks versatility is unimportant..."is in error where the truth is involved." (An obscure Babylon 5 quote--I'm afraid I can't source the video.)

Folks in this very thread have told you their own personal, lived experience, where Sorcerers in their games were weaker than Wizards unless the game was massively biased toward predictable combat. That is a lived experience contradicting your blanket statement. That is precisely the conflict of "theorycrafting" and anecdote.

You are doing exactly what you have accused me of doing for years and years and years, and now when I give back to you the very arguments you gave to me, you seem unwilling to accept them. Why were they acceptable then, but unacceptable now?
 

Reading 5.5 adventures you don't need any classes in particular. Hence why the video is claiming versatility is over rated. And DM dependent when it comes to buying scrolls.
I'd wager that the impact of scroll availability being so incredibly DM dependent in all versions of 5e is massively amplified by WotC's own actions on the matter. For years we have heard how DMs who see x in sorcerer should add free prof bonus number of spells known to it & expanded spell lists like tcoe65 I don't believe that the importance of scroll availability & sufficient funds for scribing ink to the wizard has ever really gotten so much as a reflexive gesture let alone any serious attention. That's made even more significant because of things like 202dmg306 having a section about what amounts to 2e style check to scribe or destroy a scroll without the high commonality of scrolls as treasure found in old adventures. You can see how sparse scroll availability is by comparing what you see reprinted in TYP where shrine of tamochan still has 8 scrolls to find white plume mountain 4 dead in Thay over a dozen & so on throughout the various updated adventures still using old style treasure to something like frostmaiden where one of the very very few few 5e HC adventures to includes even one spellbook.✰

Looking deeper at the ten towns equipped frostmaiden HC there are multiple smiths and fewer scrolls in the entire 300+ pages than many of those individual TYP dungeons yet so little gold that a wizard would be hard pressed to even start scribing some of those into their spellbook. Having wizard scroll scribing gold throttled & limited is fine & probably even good but not being up front about the need for both gold+spellbooks/scrolls as treasure & putting out HC adventure after HC adventure that treats those needs like the Persian Leonidas lost patience with is very much not.

✰ Couple towards the end when it's too late to benefit much from scribing & PCs are still too broke to actually scribe much and one earlier on behind a time gated check textual obfuscation and an illusory script spell. It's such a farce I couldn't even be annoyed at my AL players when they announced an action like "I go to the library and spend at least an hour searching ..." followed by "I cast dispel magic on the plain red book of poetry" immediately upon 'finding' what they obviously read the adventure to find. I can remember a +5 holy avenger from the lake with a lower bar
 

No the thread does not support that assertion either. You have repeatedly refused to divorce yourself from your personal N=1 table "experience" and talk about what you feel are contributing factors to why your experience differs from that of the posters you are disagreeing with --AND-- you also have done the same when other posters post how they see a trend you do not but feel that a particular set of rules/design elements contribute to what they perceive at their table in play. That exhausting trend is bookended by some flavor of "ZOMG that's just theorycrafting and has no place in discussion" or "portent so your observation is impossible" chewbacca defense for continuing a decade of "MOAR POWAH for sorcerer". The video is being discussed by those who regularly see sorcerer as extremely good and can identify specific design choices setting that stage at their table because the distraction can be dismissed entirely by pointing out how it was already addressed

There's nothing wrong with having a differing perception, but having a differing perception and being unable or unwilling to elaborate on elements one feels contribute to why it differs provides little room for discussion other than "um? ok.... moving on", it does not negate or disprove what others perceive at their table or overrule what they feel contributes to what they perceive simply because others are not at your table & they cannot fill in the contributing factors for you in order to discuss them.
Except that I'm not disagreeing with anything. I've consistently said that I'm speaking about my table and other may have different experiences. I've also said repeatedly that I hold all experiences as equally unique and valid. I also think theory-crafting is wonderful those who enjoy it. No problem. And why should they theory-crafters care that I something think their methodology is limited and fails to encompass large swaths of the ecosystem? They might have no interest in those sections of our hobby I do. And why should they? Who am I to them? Why should they even consider my thoughts? They should rock on doing their own thing with confidence and bravado. We should all love what we do. Who cares about the negative opinions of others except when they sharpen our own capabilities? If I'm no use to them, they can simply ignore me. I won't complain. They should do them. Always. Conformism is death.

As for power level, I don't really care if sorcerers get more power. Or wizards get more power. Or if their power level stays the same. Whatever happens, I remain in control of my table. I decide how the rules conform to my fantasy realm, the same as every other DM. We all get to decide which rules to employ, which to chuck out, and which to alter. It's not like Mr. Crawford or Mr. Mearls or Mr/Mrs whoever knows any of us and can tailor-make the game to our tastes.
 

so, having finally watched the video, i felt like all the reasoning was slightly inclined in the wizard's favour for most of the analysis and then in the final stretch they just took a hard pivot into saying the ball was in the sorcerer's court.

i mean, they were saying it was more balanced than they were expecting throughout the evaluation but still, even knowing what they were going to finish on that choice of who was the 'winner' at the end still threw me.
 

Remove ads

Top