So, again, just to confirm, 100% for sure, without any confusion:
- Data and examining WotC's output (class design, adventure design, playtest discussions, etc.) is a valid move
- There are places where 5e's lack-of-rules really does mean lack-of-support, meaning "rulings not rules" is not actually a universal solution
- A class's stats actually do matter, e.g. Charisma has high utility innately
- Raw mechanics matter, even though player, GM, etc., all matter too
- It's possible to get a highly effective full spellcaster with a relatively small number of amazing spells
- We can draw conclusions from direct comparison of mechanics between distinct classes
All of these are things you have
refused to accept from me, and responded with endless repetitions of "white room" "white room" "white room", or "depends on GM" or various other things, because
back then, apparently, all of the points above could be rebutted so. Now that
I am applying that logic to
your arguments, suddenly, mysteriously, this response isn't valid.
Do you now see how unproductive, how
damaging, it is to constantly fling out "white room" "white room" "white room" "white room" "white room" "white room" "white room" "white room"? How that response
destroys discussion, rather than opening or enabling it? How it's fundamentally dismissive?
Because the whole idea of the "white room" retort is to state that analysis is absolutely pointless. You are now doing analysis, and presumably want others to engage with that analysis. Being told, "Analysis is pointless. Stop talking about it. Vibe." is not actually a rebuttal at all--it's just a more complicated way of saying, "Oh just
shut up."
That's why it's so irritating for people to CONSTANTLY trot it out.