D&D 5E (2024) Best Arcane Caster. Sorcerer VsWizard. Dungeon Dudes: Sorcerer "Won"

That discussion has a dead end though.

Campaigns that favor rituals and/or alternate spells, Wizards are better.

Campaigns that favor spell power, Sorcerers are better.

Thats it.

Discussion is done unless you discussion popularity or percentage.
Sure, but which adventures favor rituals is rife for discussion.
 

log in or register to remove this ad


Sure, but which adventures favor rituals is rife for discussion.

Video mentioned that. Generally they dont require specific spells. They used passwall as an example.

Sorcerer can often just brute force their way through.

The internet seems to assume each wizard player is a master of versatility. Knows how to recon, pick the right rituals etc and has a pet familiar.

Most casuals are not powergamers imho.

Its funny when posts are starting to turn up along the lines of "why does my wizard suck. The Sorcerer is clowning on me. The internet said wizards rule".

First question to that is usually what levels. If you're not 13+ wizard with the right subclass its kinda not. Especially at combat. And the player needs to know what makes a wizard good. And right DM.
 

Because the data backs it up along with WotC adventure design.

Exploration is the neglected pillar, has been most of 5E.

Sorcerers are outright better at combat amd social.

The one pillar wizards are good at are also player, DM, campaign and possibly adventure dependent.

And even if the wizard loads up on rituals a lot are campaign dependent.

A few of us here have identified key spells. Eg a blaster only needs 2 spells really. A single target blaster needs around 2-4.

Control yoi really only need 3. Tashas or command and pick one from frar/slow/hypnotic pattern.

Video identifies 12 key spells. Sorcerers can get all of them and can metamagic them.

That's better than an S tier spell? A metamagic S tier spell. That and concentration mechanic negates the wizard advantages until lvl 13ish.

And most campaigns dont go anywhere near lvl 13 by the numbers.
So, again, just to confirm, 100% for sure, without any confusion:
  • Data and examining WotC's output (class design, adventure design, playtest discussions, etc.) is a valid move
  • There are places where 5e's lack-of-rules really does mean lack-of-support, meaning "rulings not rules" is not actually a universal solution
  • A class's stats actually do matter, e.g. Charisma has high utility innately
  • Raw mechanics matter, even though player, GM, etc., all matter too
  • It's possible to get a highly effective full spellcaster with a relatively small number of amazing spells
  • We can draw conclusions from direct comparison of mechanics between distinct classes
All of these are things you have refused to accept from me, and responded with endless repetitions of "white room" "white room" "white room", or "depends on GM" or various other things, because back then, apparently, all of the points above could be rebutted so. Now that I am applying that logic to your arguments, suddenly, mysteriously, this response isn't valid.

Do you now see how unproductive, how damaging, it is to constantly fling out "white room" "white room" "white room" "white room" "white room" "white room" "white room" "white room"? How that response destroys discussion, rather than opening or enabling it? How it's fundamentally dismissive?

Because the whole idea of the "white room" retort is to state that analysis is absolutely pointless. You are now doing analysis, and presumably want others to engage with that analysis. Being told, "Analysis is pointless. Stop talking about it. Vibe." is not actually a rebuttal at all--it's just a more complicated way of saying, "Oh just shut up."

That's why it's so irritating for people to CONSTANTLY trot it out.
 

Hm...most of those are also in the wizard's hands - if the DM is doing his job.

The wizard is always free to ignore the DM's time limits and use rituals. Sure consequences might ensue, but the wizard can always choose to let them occur. (Personally, I find time limit dumb in most cases. They limit player action. I rarely use them to manipulate my players, and I wouldn't play with a DM who used them regularly.)

In dungeons, the wizard can retreat outside, barricade himself in a room, etc. Clever thinking can create time. (Assuming the DM isn't unreasonable, in which case, best to walk away anyway. Never play with bad/stubborn DMs.)

Wizards can take it into their own hands gather information about other wizards and steal their spellbooks. (Again, we're assuming the DM is worth his salt. Otherwise, leave anyway. Don't give bad DMs attention.)

The wizard can always choose which foes to fight. Different types and adventure sites contain different foes. Having multiple saves allows the wizard to specialize his arsenal to combat the foes at the adventure site he's chosen to explore. (If the DM is railroading you, leave. Don't put up with being a character int he DM's novel.)
I don’t know if it’s just me but I’m always a bit surprised by these types of posts… and advice.

Do people find their DMs on some speed dating site that I never heard of? Is there a Tind&der? Or is this advice for people who play exclusively at conventions or game shops (i.e., with strangers)?

For people who play with friends, rage quitting over some particular DM quirk seems a bit impractical to me…

DMing is not easy and there are many ways to do it. If as a player I get tired of some particular friend’s DMing style, then I’ll suggest that we rotate across another campaign where I’ll be the DM so we can try out some other ideas I might have. If those ideas are well received, they’ll eventually percolate into other DM’s campaigns…

As an analogy, if you think waiters at restaurants are paid too much tip, the rational thing to do is NOT to be a cheap ass bastard and not pay them tip. The rational thing to do is: go be a waiter yourself! If it’s that easy, and it pays so much, do it then! Maybe you’ll find your dream job! Or maybe you’ll learn it wasn’t that easy afterall and everyone does the best they can with what they’ve got.

None of this is personal by the way. I have no idea what kind of player or DM (or waiter!) you are and no reason to think you’re bad at any of it. I am writing this because I have seen this type of comment a few times from different folks, and it just seems weird to me.

It’s just a game… so why does every paragraph end with "in that case, stop playing the game!" 😅 …?

It’s already difficult enough getting a game scheduled with work, family, life and everything else going on… if on top of that we squander the friend groups we do have then we might as well give up on the hobby altogether 🤷




Circling back to the topic at hand… if a specific DM’s campaign gives you no scrolls, there is never 10 minutes available to cast rituals, your familiar always dies from an explosive cough the second it’s summoned, then… what can I say… maybe lean into the harshness of the campaign and enjoy its quirks (is it Dark Sun? Maybe everyone else is also struggling in their own way?) or just play another class that doesn’t have a fraction of its power budget allocated to rituals and familiars?
 
Last edited:

I don’t know if it’s just me but I’m always a bit surprised by these types of posts… and advice.

Do people find their DMs on some speed dating site that I never heard of? Is there a Tind&der? Or is this advice for people who play exclusively at conventions or game shops (i.e., with strangers)?

For people who play with friends, rage quitting over some particular DM quirk seems a bit impractical to me…

DMing is not easy and there are many ways to do it. If as a player I get tired of some particular friend’s DMing style, then I’ll suggest that we rotate across another campaign where I’ll be the DM so we can try out some other ideas I might have. If those ideas are well received, they’ll eventually percolate into other DM’s campaigns…

As an analogy, if you think waiters at restaurants are paid too much tip, the rational thing to do is NOT to be a cheap ass bastard and not pay them tip. The rational thing to do is: go be a waiter yourself! If it’s that easy, and it pays so much, do it then! Maybe you’ll find your dream job! Or maybe you’ll learn it wasn’t that easy afterall and everyone does the best they can with what they’ve got.

None of this is personal by the way. I have no idea what kind of player or DM (or waiter!) you are and no reason to think you’re bad at any of it. I am writing this because I have seen this type of comment a few times from different folks, and it just seems weird to me.

It’s just a game… so why does every paragraph end with "in that case, stop playing the game!" 😅 …?

It’s already difficult enough getting a game scheduled with work, family, life and everything else going on… if on top of that we squander the friend groups we do have then we might as well give up on the hobby altogether 🤷
My experience isn't representative, but I have always built my own groups. If a game isn't working for someone, building a new groups is an excellent option.

For the past 12 years, I've lived in a tiny non-English speaking country. As a far as I know, no one plays D&D here (maybe some ex-pats, but I don't hang out with them; I can't imagine why someone would move abroad to spend time with one own countrymen), so I had to build my group from scratch.

When considering to invite someone to the game, I've always used a simple heuristic. The invitee must:

  • Read books (not social media, not articles, BOOKS!) in multiple languages (genre doesn't matter or which languages - I flip between three languages while DMing. Odds are, any given person living here speaks one of them.)
  • Enjoy math
  • Be able to laugh has his/her mistakes (the bigger the mistake, the more laughter)

Without those three qualities, I don't bother inviting anyone. (Of course, other aspiring DMs shouldn't use my criteria; they should invent their that fit/reflect their own personality). So far, it's worked liked a charm. I've built up a group of 14 players I met at work. Most are math/physics/philosophy professors and university students, but we also have a middle eastern diplomat (who I think might work for the Taliban, but is too shy to admit it).

We play twice a week (once in person, once online - because a couple of our players now attend university abroad but still wanted to continue playing). Not everyone comes to every game, so it's like we a have rotating cast of characters. If someone cast make it for a few weeks (or even months), it isn't a problem. We have more than enough players.

I haven't really played since high school, but enough of us were interested in DMing that it was pretty much like speed dating. Of course, we all sucked at DMing back then. Me, most of all.
 

So, again, just to confirm, 100% for sure, without any confusion:
  • Data and examining WotC's output (class design, adventure design, playtest discussions, etc.) is a valid move
  • There are places where 5e's lack-of-rules really does mean lack-of-support, meaning "rulings not rules" is not actually a universal solution
  • A class's stats actually do matter, e.g. Charisma has high utility innately
  • Raw mechanics matter, even though player, GM, etc., all matter too
  • It's possible to get a highly effective full spellcaster with a relatively small number of amazing spells
  • We can draw conclusions from direct comparison of mechanics between distinct classes
All of these are things you have refused to accept from me, and responded with endless repetitions of "white room" "white room" "white room", or "depends on GM" or various other things, because back then, apparently, all of the points above could be rebutted so. Now that I am applying that logic to your arguments, suddenly, mysteriously, this response isn't valid.

Do you now see how unproductive, how damaging, it is to constantly fling out "white room" "white room" "white room" "white room" "white room" "white room" "white room" "white room"? How that response destroys discussion, rather than opening or enabling it? How it's fundamentally dismissive?

Because the whole idea of the "white room" retort is to state that analysis is absolutely pointless. You are now doing analysis, and presumably want others to engage with that analysis. Being told, "Analysis is pointless. Stop talking about it. Vibe." is not actually a rebuttal at all--it's just a more complicated way of saying, "Oh just shut up."

That's why it's so irritating for people to CONSTANTLY trot it out.

Whitr rooms more theory crafting.

I noticed sorcerers outperforming wizards fairly early in 5.5. Wizard player switched t9 one. Power gamers are ignoring the wizard.

Online assumptions about wizards make a lot of assumptions. Usually high level games and that versatility matters.

Video essentially is saying versatility is over rated (rituals also very situational) and most games aren't going to level 13.

The wizard spell list is also very very rated and sorcerers can get most of the required spells anyway.

Its also being noticed more elsewhere online.

Even a wizard using CME is mostly theoretical. Makes for a good white room. In reality you blow through your spells very fast and its not even all that lvl 7-10.

Thats what I mea by white room. When you gave to conjure up specific examples or make assumptions (eg a DM saying yes to lots of scroll purchases).
. Similar thing with fireball. Main reasons its meh now is hp inflation. Its still situationally useful and those soelks tend to be C tier.
 

Video mentioned that. Generally they dont require specific spells. They used passwall as an example.

Sorcerer can often just brute force their way through.

The internet seems to assume each wizard player is a master of versatility. Knows how to recon, pick the right rituals etc and has a pet familiar.

Most casuals are not powergamers imho.

Its funny when posts are starting to turn up along the lines of "why does my wizard suck. The Sorcerer is clowning on me. The internet said wizards rule".

First question to that is usually what levels. If you're not 13+ wizard with the right subclass its kinda not. Especially at combat. And the player needs to know what makes a wizard good. And right DM.

Every wizard players I've known is a master of versatility. That's how I explain the class to my players. I tell them that if they just want to cast spells and blow stuff up, they should play a sorcerer. The wizard only shines when players take advantage of its virtues.

Most gamers are irrelevant to me. The players who I care about are those who play at my game. Most of my players have PHDs in math/physics/philosophy or have aspirations to attain a PHD in those fields (I work at a university). They enjoy trying figure things out. The wizard suits them well. They don't spend hours outside the game pouring over books. They just use what they have in front of them to excellent effect. I'm often impressed by their ingenuity. They come up with plans I could never have prepared for. I love them! They're so smart and creative!

If the wizard had the raw power of the sorcerer, the wizard would be overtuned at my table.

I cap my game at 6th level, but even in those spell lists, wizards have a lot of tools. Wizards gain thick spell books by stealing other wizards' spells (my players enjoy heists for thier own profit), while sorcerers are stuck with 7 spells to choose from forever. The bonus spells from some sub-classes help a bit, but when the wizards have 50+ spells to choose from each day, sorcerers feel left out.

My wizard players create different spell lists for different activities:

  • Dungeon delving (combat heavy, targets all saves)
  • Hiests (illusions / enchantments / movement)
  • Wilderness travel (movement spells / divinations / illusions)
  • Library research (divinations / enchantments / illusions)
  • Making money in towns (a wacky mix for solving personal / household problems; Speak with Dead at funeral parlors is my favorite!)
  • Social gatherings (enchantments / divinations / movement)
  • Dealing with other spellcasters (counterspell / dispell magic / some other stuff; I forget)
 

Whitr rooms more theory crafting.

I noticed sorcerers outperforming wizards fairly early in 5.5. Wizard player switched t9 one. Power gamers are ignoring the wizard.

Online assumptions about wizards make a lot of assumptions. Usually high level games and that versatility matters.

Video essentially is saying versatility is over rated (rituals also very situational) and most games aren't going to level 13.

The wizard spell list is also very very rated and sorcerers can get most of the required spells anyway.

Its also being noticed more elsewhere online.

Even a wizard using CME is mostly theoretical. Makes for a good white room. In reality you blow through your spells very fast and its not even all that lvl 7-10.

Thats what I mea by white room. When you gave to conjure up specific examples or make assumptions (eg a DM saying yes to lots of scroll purchases).
. Similar thing with fireball. Main reasons its meh now is hp inflation. It’s still situationally useful and those soelks tend to be C tier.
If you evaluate at the encounter level then sorcerer seems to have the stronger case. If the evaluation is over the whole campaign I think Wizard has a stronger case.

I think there’s a strong consensus that sorcerers are better at combat than wizards. The only real question is the degree and the extent to which wizard non combat abilities matter.
 
Last edited:

I think there’s a strong consensus that sorcerers are better at combat than wizards. The only real question is the degree and the extent to which wizard non combat abilities matter.

Pretty much.

Most people say sorcerer is better in combat unless you take a wizard subclass that really beefs up another combat option (bladesinger-melee, necro/conjur- summons).

The wizard wins on out of combat and pre-combat features and spells.
 

Remove ads

Top