Doing some catch up in this thread...
I think others have already done a good job of proselytizing the power of "and". It really is much more satisfying that another "is ____ a sandwich" debate. Also, generally, if something is barely horror (or sci-fi, etc.), that's often why it's not the best in that category.
Personally, I have no problem admitting that even my #1 franchise is uneven in its categorization. Alien (1) is definitely the most "horror" of all the movies. Aliens shifts to more "action". Prometheus is the most "sci-fi". The most recent, Romulus, is a big return to the series horror roots, and part of what kept the ranking so high.
Very few horror series can maintain the same level of horror across all movies. At some point, the thing that was scariest in the beginning becomes mundane. The creativity of how to keep a franchise alive is a big part of what makes it good, and why judging a franchise is different than judging a movie.
Romero's zombie series was literally in and out of my top 5 multiple times as I wrote the OP. If I did a Top 10, it would definitely be there. The OG is indisputably one of the most influential horror films of all time. It literally changed the definition of "zombie" and created an entire genre. And the rest of his work is generally very solid. I love them.
But in the end, there are flaws when viewed as a franchise. The biggest being it's lack of a central ... anything. Yes, Romero made 7 zombie movies. But they are basically 7 distinct zombie movies that happen to be made by the same person, using similar names as marketing. There are a couple of easter eggs you could tenuously use to connect a couple random moments, but that's it. And it's hard to compare that to the long long form of these other multi-film franchises.
My other complaint is a lack of variation. Later entries, even the best of them, are all still just retreads of zombie movies. They don't bring too much new to the table. Good, yes, but not as much originality as I would have hoped. You'll note that the higher rated franchises on my list have more variability (even if sometimes it's to their detriment). Keeping a franchise alive is not an easy task, and Romero basically rode his one note has hard as he could. And if you want to see my complaint about repetitive junk when talking about horror franchises as being hypocritical: Yes. Yes it is.
Hrm. I've seen people here mention both the 'Alien' and 'Predator' franchises. And don't get me wrong, I like most of the movies in these series (including but not limited to 'Alien Resurrection'). Yet somehow, to me, these don't really register as being 'horror' but instead as 'science fiction'. Oh, well.
I think others have already done a good job of proselytizing the power of "and". It really is much more satisfying that another "is ____ a sandwich" debate. Also, generally, if something is barely horror (or sci-fi, etc.), that's often why it's not the best in that category.
Personally, I have no problem admitting that even my #1 franchise is uneven in its categorization. Alien (1) is definitely the most "horror" of all the movies. Aliens shifts to more "action". Prometheus is the most "sci-fi". The most recent, Romulus, is a big return to the series horror roots, and part of what kept the ranking so high.
Very few horror series can maintain the same level of horror across all movies. At some point, the thing that was scariest in the beginning becomes mundane. The creativity of how to keep a franchise alive is a big part of what makes it good, and why judging a franchise is different than judging a movie.
If I had to pick the best horror movie franchise, it'd be Romero's Dead series. While Diary and Survival are steps down, the thing is, they are smaller dips in quality than other franchises experienced. All of the movies have something to say, and that's a huge part of them staying relevant to this day.
Romero's zombie series was literally in and out of my top 5 multiple times as I wrote the OP. If I did a Top 10, it would definitely be there. The OG is indisputably one of the most influential horror films of all time. It literally changed the definition of "zombie" and created an entire genre. And the rest of his work is generally very solid. I love them.
But in the end, there are flaws when viewed as a franchise. The biggest being it's lack of a central ... anything. Yes, Romero made 7 zombie movies. But they are basically 7 distinct zombie movies that happen to be made by the same person, using similar names as marketing. There are a couple of easter eggs you could tenuously use to connect a couple random moments, but that's it. And it's hard to compare that to the long long form of these other multi-film franchises.
My other complaint is a lack of variation. Later entries, even the best of them, are all still just retreads of zombie movies. They don't bring too much new to the table. Good, yes, but not as much originality as I would have hoped. You'll note that the higher rated franchises on my list have more variability (even if sometimes it's to their detriment). Keeping a franchise alive is not an easy task, and Romero basically rode his one note has hard as he could. And if you want to see my complaint about repetitive junk when talking about horror franchises as being hypocritical: Yes. Yes it is.






