Can a Targeted Dispel Magic or Greater Dispelling be Spell Turned?

[Malin Genie]

As per the topic.

On the pro side - it's Targeted.

On the con side - it's targeted at the spells you have active, not really at 'you' - that's why SR deosn't apply and there's no save.

 

[LokiDR]

Pro: it targets you and effects all spells on you. Just because it doesn't allow SR doesn't mean anything unless you are defended by SR (spell imunity gives you unbeatable SR, IIRC).

I might change my opinion for Mord's Disjunction. But that is a 9th level spell, vs a 7th. Dispell and Greater Dispelling are 3rd and 6th, respectively. 7th trumps.

 

[Malin Genie]

Of course, spell immunity gives you unbeatable SR only against spells that allow SR in the first place, so spell immunity is ineffective against dispel magic.

 

[LokiDR]

Exactly. You can't use spell immunity against dispel due to how it is defined. Spell turning doesn't have that problem.