Chaosium clamps down on AI and removes 40 community titles

In short, they say "just don't use AI."
1792689830588.png

Chaosium, like many companies, has a community content program which runs at DriveThruRPG--essentially, the same basic premise as the DM's Guild operated by WotC and DTRPG. It allows third party creators to make new content for Chaosium's roleplaying games, such as Call of Cthulhu, and benefit from access to art and text belong to Chaosium in exchange for a cut of the royalties. Lots of companies have this same arrangement with DriveThruRPG, including Monte Cook Games, Free League, Paizo, Mongoose Publishing, and more--including, of course, the DM's Guild itself as the most well-known example.

Chaosium's most popular community content program is called the Miskatonic Repository for Call of Cthulhu content. They also operate programs for their other lines, including RuneQuest and Pendragon:
Recently, Chaosium removed over 40 community titles from its community content programs. These were removed because they used AI-generated text, something they describe as "a recent disturbing trend". The company describes AI-generated content thusly: "..we hate it. It is antithetical to every reason that we all come to the table to play games with each other, to meet characters that we have created or inhabit, and in doing so explore our collective humanity. AI is not art. It is theft from you and every writer who has gone before you, repackaged dishonestly and shamelessly as original."

Outlining the rules for community content, Chaosium listed the things that creators could not use AI for, from generating ideas to actual text, artwork and layout. In short, they say "just don't use AI."

Checking 40+ publications to confirm AI use drained and demoralised us, but it had to be done. The net result is that we are now better at spotting it, and our tolerance is lower than ever before. Publications which have the characteristics of AI-speak will be removed from our programs, as will any future publications by those creators.

Read Chaosium’s full statement here.
 

log in or register to remove this ad

<First point cross-posted with guidance. Removed>
For an optional program, I'd rather they do no harm to the innocent as a higher priority. For example, for products they believe are AI contact the authors before removing and require them to take a pledge that AI was not used if they want to keep it up.
Given that they are contacting the authors, and are not naming and shaming, I'm not sure how this greatly differs from what they are doing. Sure the product is taken down for a day or more while the process plays out, but that seems trivial in the overall scope of the situation (someone who would notice and buy the product on Monday is likely to do the same if they first see it on Wednesday, or at least so close that we can't predict which day would be more optimal). Is there something specifically you think would be different in this scenario?
 

log in or register to remove this ad

<First point cross-posted with guidance. Removed>

Given that they are contacting the authors, and are not naming and shaming, I'm not sure how this greatly differs from what they are doing. Sure the product is taken down for a day or more while the process plays out, but that seems trivial in the overall scope of the situation (someone who would notice and buy the product on Monday is likely to do the same if they first see it on Wednesday, or at least so close that we can't predict which day would be more optimal). Is there something specifically you think would be different in this scenario?
My entire entry to this post was that a person does not need to have a better suggestion in order to point out a process is flawed.

BTW, I saw no indication from Chaosium that they are doing what you said when I was last in the other link. They said some people denied it but there is no indication that got their products relisted. So what you are describing isn't the process at all. Once you drop your erroneous description of "might be taken down for a day or more while the process plays out" and replace it with the "there is no appeal, the author cannot defend it, we take it down solely on our gut instincts and known-for-false-positives AI detectors", then it's a world of difference.
 

Did you read Chaosium’s follow-up? That will provide you more context

 


The long-term threat is not their potential customers buying AI-slop instead, but using AI to generate material for themselves so they don't need to buy it anymore. No degree of fence-building will fix that.
I can't really imagine that ... RPG has always been a hobby where you actually don't need a lot of extra material. I could run ten lifes full of well-tailored RPG campaigns from the material I own, but I still buy new stuff, because I still like to read other people's ideas, both in terms of what a scenario is about and how it is developed. Without an author behind it, that would be pointless. I have zero interest in my own ideas regurgigated and stretched with gallons of cliché.
 


Remove ads

Remove ads

Top