D&D General Comparing Giant Sizes

Anders Johnson, a Swedish artist over on ArtStation, has an awesome image in which he compares the relative sizes of various D&D giants.
Anders Johnson, a Swedish artist over on ArtStation, has an awesome image in which he compares the relative sizes of various D&D giants.

anders-johansson-giants-023.jpg
 

log in or register to remove this ad

Why, though? What if your player has other ideas, and has a great concept for a halfling barbarian?
Im my game you can do a halfling (they're called Hobbits, by the way!) warrior if you want but unless you make it a ranged-weapon type your choice of species is going to fight you almost every step of the way.

As IMO it should: some species by their very nature are just not cut out to be some classes while at the same time excelling at other classes. 5.xe forgot this notion somewhere along the way, and in so doing made choice of species nearly irrelevant other than whether you can see in the dark.
 

log in or register to remove this ad


… some species by their very nature are just not cut out to be some classes while at the same time excelling at other classes. 5.xe forgot this notion somewhere along the way,
5e didn’t forget. 5e made sure it wasn’t a thing. All races/species being able to perform more or less equally in all roles is a deliberate design choice. As I’m sure you know..
 

Im my game you can do a halfling (they're called Hobbits, by the way!) warrior if you want but unless you make it a ranged-weapon type your choice of species is going to fight you almost every step of the way.
While I do prefer it the modern way I have a special place in my heart for Mazzy from Baldurs Gate 2 the Halfling Paladin-Archer (who cannot actually be a Paladin because 2e, or ADnD? I always forget...)
 

5e didn’t forget. 5e made sure it wasn’t a thing. All races/species being able to perform more or less equally in all roles is a deliberate design choice. As I’m sure you know..
Which immediately raises the question: if all species are roughly equal in all things then why bother having them?

It may have been a deliberate design choice but it's also a bad one.
 

Which immediately raises the question: if all species are roughly equal in all things then why bother having them?

It may have been a deliberate design choice but it's also a bad one.

There are a number of reasons but basically it boils down to not hyper-specializing species so that a character concept must be of a certain species in order to be optimal, and by extension, that no choice of species locks a player into a suboptimal build for a character concept. So in the end, species is mostly about aesthetics and a selection of ability packages to choose from.

I’m not saying that’s my preference; PHB 5.0 was hitting the right spot for me in terms of racial identity, abilities, and limitations, both in the construction of species and rules about small characters.
 

A 12' tall humanoid towers over Thanos or the Hulk. If a hill giant of them is a basketball center, the crown of their head is at the top of the backboard. They basically fill up the whole lane by themselves. A giant of a man like LeBron James leaping up to slam dunk the ball encounters a wall of living flesh. LeBron and similar NBA stars that tower over people, are diminished to childlike figures. Isn't that big enough if you want to imagine a melee combat between a mere mortal and a giant? Just imagine basketball between a LeBron and a Hill Giant and you'll see what I mean.
I think David (television series) did a really nice job of depicting the giants from the bible. The fight scenes were really well done.
 

Which immediately raises the question: if all species are roughly equal in all things then why bother having them?

It may have been a deliberate design choice but it's also a bad one.
Maybe it is a modern thing we do not get? Like race is more like a fortnite skin ? :P
 


Which immediately raises the question: if all species are roughly equal in all things then why bother having them?

It may have been a deliberate design choice but it's also a bad one.
Why? Apparently a lot of people enjoy having halflings wielding great swords and dwarves casting spells.

It’s a fantasy game. If dragons are right there are the cover, why is a halfling with a great sword a bridge too far? It’s subjective, so if you don’t like it in your games, that’s awesome, but not agreeing with your subjective taste doesn’t mean it’s bad design.
 

Related Articles

Remove ads

Remove ads

Top