D&D 5E (2024) D&D WoW Shaman thread...


log in or register to remove this ad


It's been almost seven years since I last played World of Warcraft, but I was interested in seeing the 5th edition version, but it looks like this is a somewhat lazy adaptation. I would expect to be able to make a decent Shaman healer, a Monk that can DPS or tank, and for other classes to feel more like they belong in WoW than they do in D&D.
 

It's been almost seven years since I last played World of Warcraft, but I was interested in seeing the 5th edition version, but it looks like this is a somewhat lazy adaptation. I would expect to be able to make a decent Shaman healer, a Monk that can DPS or tank, and for other classes to feel more like they belong in WoW than they do in D&D.
That's probably asking too much of a product that's meant to be compatible with the rest of 5e. These are Warcraft concepts, but they're also intended to be useable by any 5e player, so ultimately they have to belong in D&D too.
 

That's probably asking too much of a product that's meant to be compatible with the rest of 5e. These are Warcraft concepts, but they're also intended to be useable by any 5e player, so ultimately they have to belong in D&D too.
I didn't realize it was supposed to be compatible with the rest of 5E. In that case, there was no chance for this to be anything I was interested in. Which is fine, the world doesn't revolve around me, but it leaves me baffled as to who the audience for this product is.
 

That's probably asking too much of a product that's meant to be compatible with the rest of 5e. These are Warcraft concepts, but they're also intended to be useable by any 5e player, so ultimately they have to belong in D&D too.
I don’t think any D&D player would have objected to a new class, like Shaman.

All of the native WoW concepts can fit into the D&D milieu, it just takes a little more work for some than a light reskin of a PHB subclass.
 

I don’t think any D&D player would have objected to a new class, like Shaman.

All of the native WoW concepts can fit into the D&D milieu, it just takes a little more work for some than a light reskin of a PHB subclass.
Players wouldn't have objected, but WotC has historically been extremely cautious about introducing entire new classes ever since the start of 5e. I believe the grand total still stands at one, which has not yet been updated to the 2024 rules. Introducing another one would not be just a little more work.
 

I don’t think any D&D player would have objected to a new class, like Shaman.

All of the native WoW concepts can fit into the D&D milieu, it just takes a little more work for some than a light reskin of a PHB subclass.
Exactly. The shaman sits perfectly between the druid and cleric. Either would have worked a treat for the easy close-enough-is-good-enough treatment. I would have been over-the-moon if they had made a new class, but I didn't expect one.
 


Players wouldn't have objected, but WotC has historically been extremely cautious about introducing entire new classes ever since the start of 5e. I believe the grand total still stands at one, which has not yet been updated to the 2024 rules. Introducing another one would not be just a little more work.
I disagree. WotC’s reluctance makes the audience feel as if releasing a new class is a major undertaking. The sheer amount of 3rd party material that is commiserate in quality to WotC’s, often done by very small groups or even solo, demonstrates that the amount of labor isn't a major impediment, even factoring in the extra work of Beyond coding.

WotC simply doesn’t feel as if a large amount of mechanical expansion is good for the brand. And that desire is unfortunate when it comes to settings with existing, detailed diversity where a 5e guidebook would be better as more of a mechanical expansion than predominantly a reskin.

I’m curious to see if the reactions will be similar when a Dark Sun Templar is a warlock with a new pact, or a Jedi is a reskinned bladesinger.
 

Remove ads

Top