Daggerheart Discussion


log in or register to remove this ad


Does anyone have a suggestion on which campaign frames would work well with 2 players (plus GM)?
Of the official frames? I might second Beast Feast as one that might work pretty well. Reign of the Weredragon might also be good, since it's partially inspired by some older Disney movies, and those tend to have a duo of protagonists, not counting funny animal sidekicks and the like.
 

Thinking on the 2+GM model... due to the lack of niche protection, as long as you have a warrior of some stripe, most of the frames should work.
I know Witherwild worked as well as Beast Feast for the same 2p group for me. (I as GM didn't enjoy the Witherwild frame as much. Which is why it didn't get mentioned.)

There are a few monsters with needs for a specific niche PC to "solve" them, but those are usually pretty clear, and can be avoided.
My 4P Age of Umbra ran headlong into one case where the monster's weakness wasn't addressed... but it was doable.

Part of that is that the number of NPC actions is directly tied to the number of PCs acting, with a hardline max sustained of just shy of double (if you're playing with hard luck cases who made their high-loaded d12 their fear die): 1 for each fear rolled and 1 more for spending the fear point generated.

As for Beast Feast... the map has a lot of interesting tidbits. My favorite is the mechanical sphere on the lower right... My players seemed to like the waterfall. (I put a troll on one of the bridges collecting token tolls of food.) Letting players name the areas and riffing off those names for what's there was probably my favorite bit for that frame. The hidden object find aspects of that map made session 0 a bit long, but quite fun. I do recommend highlighting things as they're named.
Also fun with Beast Feast is that it is in side-on perspective, not top down nor 3/4 like the others.
 

I hope no one thinks I'm against games I don't prefer because that is absolutely not true. I think Daggerheart is a partial step in one direction but not a giant step. It's not pbtA. It is a little further along that track than D&D is, even 5.5e. D&D is too far for me though.
The part that is hard for people to get their heads round is that Daggerheart actually owes more to 4e than 5e.
I like what I like and for me these days roleplaying is a rare opportunity and since I view roleplaying as vastly more fun than a board game or video game I want what I want. If I had more time for many campaigns, I think I might try a more narrative as a totally different experience just for kicks. I think if simple enough it might make a good roadtrip game for me. I think though if I wanted to do that I'd go beyond Daggerheart to something even more narrative. And yes I still do take long roadtrips on occasion.
A good call. A fun thing about the more narrative RPGs is that many of them play fast; Apocalypse World was aimed at a dozen sessions, Daggerheart two dozen before characters level out. And there are a lot of single session games that could be played on a long car journey or in the space of a boardgame (Fiasco remains amazing as does Ten Candles).
 

The part that is hard for people to get their heads round is that Daggerheart actually owes more to 4e than 5e.
The problem is a lot of people who hate 4e would still steal a few ideas from 4e. If I were designing my own game, I'd have proportional healing. I'd do it in a more old school way in terms of healing still being healing and not refreshing and I wouldn't have any PC under the sun just self-healing. I do thought like proportional healing. Same for monsters. I think the recharge mechanic of 4e for monsters is fantastic but I would only want it for spells or spell like effects. I still overall hate 4e and will never play it again.

I haven't bought or read Daggerheart so I don't know what it takes from 4e and how it presents it but that would matter for a lot of people. The argument from 4e apologists is that accepting something presented in an entirely different mechanical format is not evidence of bias against 4e. It just means the mechanical presentation may have been the issue.

A good call. A fun thing about the more narrative RPGs is that many of them play fast; Apocalypse World was aimed at a dozen sessions, Daggerheart two dozen before characters level out. And there are a lot of single session games that could be played on a long car journey or in the space of a boardgame (Fiasco remains amazing as does Ten Candles).
That would lend itself to a long roadtrip. You could play an entire campaign driving to Florida and back.
 

I’m somewhere approaching 25 sessions in and level 4 in both my campaigns, I feel like 4-5 sessions (3hr windows) per level still feels about right? I didn’t rush L1 either, players start out competent and have plenty of stuff they can do thanks to action rolls.
 

Remove ads

Top