D&D General Design issues with 5e

Only 5e has 6, every other edition has saves that arent simply save=stat.

False pedantry doesn't change that. 5e saves are weird and there is no reason to do them this way.
5e 6 saves is no more weird than 3e 3 saves.

Me personally 5 saves would be the best.

  1. Muscle
  2. Dodge
  3. Poison/Death/Petrified
  4. Mental
  5. Spiritual/Magical/Banishment
6 Is slightly too many. 3 simplifies too much (saves vs Knockdown and vs Poison are different things)


The bigger issue is the math is off in most editions.
 

log in or register to remove this ad

In regard to 5E's Skill system and it's issues:

IIRC, Baldurs Gate 3 has a thing where if something made sense according to your background and it involved a skill you normally weren't proficient in, your prof score was added to the roll.

Example: If you chose Soldier as your background, you were able to add your prof score to Persuasion(if you aren't proficient in Persuasion) against Kith'rak Voss during your first encounter because "technically" your both Soldiers and know how to "talk shop" as my mom would put it whenever she met another Nurse in real life .

So, If I was a DM, and a PC, with a Soldier background, made an argument that their character would know how to do light/average field dressing due to having to learn it on the fly/the hardway on the battlefield before, I wouldn't be opposed to letting them add their Prof score to their Medicine check, even if they weren't proficient in Medicine.

Now there would be limits. You want to reattach an arm or perform ER surgery on somebody on the spot? Yeah your gonna need that Medicine proficiency and/or spellcaster.


Another thing I kinda like doing is adding Backgrounds+Heritages(Tales of The Valiant) and allow that to provide extra skills for PCs.
 
Last edited:



In regard to 5E's Skill system and it's issues:

IIRC, Baldurs Gate 3 has a thing where if something made sense according to your background and it involved a skill you normally weren't proficient in, your prof score was added to the roll.

Example: If you chose Soldier as your background, you were able to add your prof score to Persuasion(if you aren't proficient in Persuasion) against Kith'rak Voss during your first encounter because "technically" your both Soldiers and know how to "talk shop" as my mom would put it whenever she met another Nurse in real life .

So, If I was a DM, and a PC, with a Soldier background, made an argument that their character would know how to do light/average field dressing due to having to learn it on the fly/the hardway on the battlefield before, I wouldn't be opposed to letting them add their Prof score to their Medicine check, even if they weren't proficient in Medicine.

Now there would be limits. You want to reattach an arm or perform ER surgery on somebody on the spot? Yeah your gonna need that Medicine proficiency and/or spellcaster.

Another thing I kinda like doing is adding Backgrounds+Heritages(Tales of The Valiant) and allow that to provide extra skills for PCs.
Yep. The baseline for "skills" should be anything that's reasonable for your race, class, or background to be good at. That should be automatic. There's an optional rule that's similar in the 2014 DMG. Anything that's outside that should be where the dedicated skill system starts. Sure, there'll be that 1-in-1000 character who wants to go against the grain and make a cleric who's bad at Religion or a druid who's bad at Nature. But those are the rare exceptions you can make carve outs for rather than design the whole system around from the ground up.
 


5e 6 saves is no more weird than 3e 3 saves.

Me personally 5 saves would be the best.

  1. Muscle
  2. Dodge
  3. Poison/Death/Petrified
  4. Mental
  5. Spiritual/Magical/Banishment
6 Is slightly too many. 3 simplifies too much (saves vs Knockdown and vs Poison are different things)
1e has death-poison-paralysis as a single category and it never sat well with me, so I split them out.

I'd tweak your list to something like

1. Death
2. Physical other than death (covers poison, petrify, muscle, etc.)
3. Agility (covers dodge, balance, etc.)
4. Mental-Spiritual
5. Magic other than mental-spiritual

Were it me, though, I'd probably split these out further and end up with about 12 categories, mostly because different stats would provide their bonuses to different save types (example: poison or petrify would be Con-based while 'muscle' would be Str-based)
 

Were it me, though, I'd probably split these out further and end up with about 12 categories, mostly because different stats would provide their bonuses to different save types (example: poison or petrify would be Con-based while 'muscle' would be Str-based)
take one step further and ask "wait, if these are all stat-based, what actual reason is there to separate them?", and suddenly woe, 5e ability saves upon ye
 

I have zero problem with stats being the saves. It makes perfect sense. PCs who’re smarter automatically get better at resisting things that effect their INT. PCs with higher DEX are automatically better at dodging. Etc.

Special categories for saves are just goofy and you have to kludge so many things into bizarre categories. I’ll take a DEX save against a fireball all day every day. It also points back to the fiction in a way the old-school saves don’t. You can try to dodge this effect, so make a DEX save vs whatever a save vs spell is supposed to look like in the fiction.

I’d go a step further and bring back 4E defenses. Save + 10 = Defense. There, now attacks can target your NADs (non-armor defenses) again.
 

5e 6 saves is no more weird than 3e 3 saves.

Me personally 5 saves would be the best.

  1. Muscle
  2. Dodge
  3. Poison/Death/Petrified
  4. Mental
  5. Spiritual/Magical/Banishment
6 Is slightly too many. 3 simplifies too much (saves vs Knockdown and vs Poison are different things)


The bigger issue is the math is off in most editions.
That doesnt look anything like a thing from dnd.

3 makes sense. It fits the rest of the game's history. 6 is a different paradigm because 6 is taking the saves and making them "this effect targets your strength, specifically." It is a different way of looking at what a save is.

And 3 plus AC is plenty, and makes it much simpler to have some advancement of saves without losing the very good design of nearly all PCs having at least 1 save they suck at.
 
Last edited:

Remove ads

Top