D&D General DMing Theory #2: Strong and Fast

A series of threads dedicated to analyzing the diversity of DMing styles. No right or wrong answers.

Question: A player comes to you, the DM, and expresses a desire want to play a warrior who is both physically strong and dexterous like those in "traditional fantasy fiction" (define however you think more appropriate) in your 5(.5)e game. The player wants both his high Strength and high Dexterity to be mechanically meaningful (because that's what fits his understanding of the source material). He also expects his character to be a warrior, not a conglomeration of reflavored spells and will be disappointed by that suggestion.

How do you proceed?
I would honestly tell the player, "The thing you want isn't really achievable in 5e without extensive homebrew, to the point of creating at least an entire subclass built around what you want, or several powerful magic items. That is a lot of work on my part, without any guarantee that it will actually be what you want."

From there, it would depend on what they're looking for. If they really, really, really cannot let go of playing specifically some version of 5th Edition D&D, and they really, really, really cannot let go of getting clear and significant in-combat advantages from both their Dexterity and their Strength...and they assure me in no uncertain terms that they will genuinely play this class and they'll enjoy it even if it fails to measure up mechanically so long as it achieves the goal thematically...

Then I would heavily consider doing as they have asked, but it would legit be in tossup territory. That is a HUGE amount of work that has an extremely high risk of leaving either me unhappy, them unhappy, or (most likely) both.

But if their commitment seems even slightly shaky, I'm just going to tell them no, I'm sorry, I'm not going to do that for you in 5th Edition, whatever flavor you choose to play. There are other systems which can handle that, and I would genuinely consider running such (13A and 4e being the two front runners.)
 

log in or register to remove this ad

I was thinking along these lines as well reading the first several posts. The game allows the player to describe and play the character how he likes. He can have a musclebound Conan-type in how he is portrayed and looks, but the rules only allow for certain things. Conan would miss sometimes if he rolled dice.
Missing is fine, the problem for this kind of wish is more that except if you play a Barbarian that there is in the system 0 incentive to have strength and dex high. In general stat combinations which make sense are quite a bit limited (and you need to focus on 1 stat to increase).

Mechanically some things could be done within the rules. Maybe the Alert feat to swap initiative with someone else gives a feel they are looking for. I think there is now 4,666 classes and another 12,000 subclasses for 5e to choose from that something should be found without asking the DM to do more work and accommodate me.
Unless you go for homebrew there are not that many classes (13) and subclasses (for martials maybe 7 if you also count the 5.0 ones and most include some magic). And builds are still way way more limited than in 3.5 or in 4E.
I can also see a new player wanting to be Conan or something and not wanting to turn them away from their idea. I would explain the classes and how feats and classes work with subclasses and find something. Failing this, I would give options for multiclassing to expand the options.

I feel some of the problem is players have an idea to play Luke Skywalker, but want Return of the Jedi Luke instead of Tatooine Luke at first level.

The problem is more that most "variety" in 5e is just in spells / magical features, which heavily limits what kind of fantasy characters you can play in a meaningfull way.
 

I've never believed strength affected to hit rolls. Oh I've allowed it by the rules in the past. DEX should always affect to hit rolls.

You could just rule that he adds DEX on his to hit and STR for his damage.
 

What do you lose if you put points into both STR and DEX? You won't get that one slightly higher mental stat that most warriors usually have.

But so what?

Most of the time your prototypical Fighters have highest STR, high CON, and high WIS with the rest being mediocre (11s, 10s, 8s). In this case... your Fighter will have a high DEX rather than a high WIS. Okay. So be it. All it means is your Fighter is going to be 2 points worse in Perception checks and charm saves (and the like) but you get to have your high DEX like you wanted (and thus 2 points of bonus in your Acrobatics, Stealth, reflexive saves etc.)

The player just needs to make that choice to do so-- to have three mediocre mental stats (or drop their CON to keep a higher mental stat and then try to offset that HP loss with feat selection). If they wish to do so for characterization decisions, then great! If they don't want to make that sacrifice... then they don't.

That's just the way the game is played.
 

It's not an issue. We use point buy so I would explain how it works and what the options are. In most cases they'll probably want to focus on one stat over another and also that this is probably going to be a character very focused on physical stats and a front line fighter so constitution should also be a priority. I also always use custom backgrounds so ability score adjustments are up to the player.

It's what I did with my barbarian with a starting 17 strength, 14 dex, 16 con (it was a tossup was between dex and con). All three are above average; it wouldn't have made a huge difference if I had gone 16, 16, 14 instead and had a couple more points to put into intelligence and wisdom. If I really wanted to I could have had 16, 16, 16 and 8s in the other numbers. But this was my fun BDF (big dumb fighter) build.

It does mean that you have to sacrifice a bit on intelligence, wisdom and charisma but that's where I'd explain how it's designed to have balanced characters and the goal of the game is not to have a Mary Sue or Marty Stue character that's good at everything. If everybody at the table (including the DM) is happy with using higher numbers for point buy, we can do that as well but we tried it once and decided it wasn't really necessary. Sometimes it's fun to have a low number to play off of.

On a side note for many games strength may be "pointless". It's not in mine so buyer beware. I have a group where the highest strength is a 10 and it's been an issue a few times because they need to hold a door closed while something is trying to break it down, move something heavy and so on. I don't design these things specifically to point out their literal weakness, it's the type of physical challenge I throw in every once in a while because I like to make challenges that require a different skill set. So far it hasn't been an issue but only because the druid can change into something strong.
 

Custom subclass for either fighter or rogue (or possibly ranger), depending on how they wanted to do it.

I made a subclass like this for Rogue once, it got bonuses to attack if its Str and Dex modifier were identical, and could treat all melee weapons as finesse if its Strength was high enough. It also had mechanics to boost the lower of Str or Dex when it gained an ASI.

Basically, I hacked the attack math a bit so that keeping Str/Dex at 16/16 or 18/18 was better than rushing to 20 for just one stat. That would be the primary design goal for the concept, to me, rather than just giving bonuses for a moderate (Str or Dex) while keeping the other one the primary.

For a Fighter, I would also probably give some distinct bonuses to different types of armor (if light or no armor, gain X; if heavy or medium, gain Y), since they can wear any armor and have the stats to effectively use all kinds.
 

I've never believed strength affected to hit rolls. Oh I've allowed it by the rules in the past. DEX should always affect to hit rolls.

You could just rule that he adds DEX on his to hit and STR for his damage.

Making physical contact is only part of the picture when doing damage. I could hit someone with a pillow and it isn't going to hurt nearly as much as if I hit them with a baseball bat even if the baseball bat hit was only a glancing blow. Personally I think dexterity is way overblown. Look at any gymnast (particularly men) and tell me they don't need a decent strength to do those acrobatics.

A better model would consider both strength and dexterity but like a lot of things it's simplified for the game.
 

Yeah I didn't understand either if this is a 5e optimization trap or something that I wandered into, but it seems like the obvious low hanging answer is to give the character those two good scores and they already have mechanical meaning, so no problem?
It's a 5e optimization trap. In 5e, you boost Strength if you're a melee attacker using large weapons and (ideally) are wearing heavy armor. So, primarily fighters, paladins, and sometimes clerics. Barbarians also use Strength because their class features basically mandate it, but want a 14 Dex in addition since they're limited to medium armor.

Every other class will treat Dexterity as either their primary or a secondary, and generally ignore Strength outside of specific character concepts (for the "roleplay"). Dexterity boosts initiative and AC if you don't have heavy armor, and you can make weapon attacks just fine with Dexterity. Dexterity also governs more skills that get tested more broadly, and is a much more commonly rolled save.

Because of the attack roll, damage roll, and AC overlap, you pretty much don't see any character concept that mechanically benefits from boosting Str in addition to Dex.
 

Making physical contact is only part of the picture when doing damage. I could hit someone with a pillow and it isn't going to hurt nearly as much as if I hit them with a baseball bat even if the baseball bat hit was only a glancing blow. Personally I think dexterity is way overblown. Look at any gymnast (particularly men) and tell me they don't need a decent strength to do those acrobatics.

A better model would consider both strength and dexterity but like a lot of things it's simplified for the game.
Strength might dictate the type of weapon you can use for sure. But whether you land a blow is far more dictated by dexterity (and training of course which probably matters more than anything but we are talking attributes here).
 

Strength might dictate the type of weapon you can use for sure. But whether you land a blow is far more dictated by dexterity (and training of course which probably matters more than anything but we are talking attributes here).

Strength also dictates the amount of force that can be applied. In any case we disagree - I think from both a gameplay and simulation standpoint dexterity is overrated and you don't. Agree to disagree.
 

Remove ads

Top