I believe the PC not feeling different via more options is generally not a problem even if I like some growing number of them. It's D&D's normal for decades now to give the PC more stuff and accumulate complexity, but it doesn't need to be that way.
Well, I'll just suggest that for some people it
does need to feel that way for high level play to have a point.
I play Cypher System, and its PC high levels (most obviously in the superhero genre, incidentally, but this applies to all) get high power capability with only a minor increase in complexity. Advancement is modeled as being able to accomplish bigger "impossible" tasks more readily and reliably by spending more pool points without burning out. They get only a modest increase in special abilities, and the whole of the game otherwise is the task resolution roll, and yet high power narrative is easily obtained.
Yeah, but for some people that's not enough, and I'm speaking from years of running the Hero System and Mutants and Masterminds. The narrative change by itself just doesn't do it.
Of course you can't get far comparing D&D to a universal system. I guess you could look at B/X for an uncomplex D&D DNA, so it's not completely alien to D&D.
Given the time frame, I'd wonder how many people saw the upper levels there; I hopped out after OD&D so I genuinely don't know. I know it avowedly had fairly high level support, but I have no idea how many people sa it.
(I'd say the difference between low level OD&D Fighters and high level ones othe than gear was, honestly minimal. But then, I've noted that the blandness of Fighters in OD&D was one of the things that drove me out of it).
My opinion is that the answers to your questions are not necessarily answered by stat blocks. The best bestiary I have ever read is the 13th Age Bestiary, and it's not the best because it has the best stat blocks or the best special abilities, it's because it gets every monster in it completely over --- why they're strong or weak, how they fit into an epic narrative, what cool stuff they do in and out of combat, what plots they may be involved in, etc.
I understand what you mean--I finished up a 10 level 13th Age Campaign some months ago--but that's all pretty dependent on the effective communication between the GM and players, and I just don't think you can count on that working in a reliable way (given how many failures happen there even with experienced groups, I can bet on it being an issue with new ones).
I would argue that most games' and editions' ancient red dragon stat block could be scaled up and down and/or put on a different monster and no one would really care about the difference --- "reskinned". The stuff outside the stat block is largely what gets the ancient red dragon over, like what got Randy Savage over compared to just another athletic muscley dude.
I dunno. As noted, within the D&D-sphere proper I only have really three cases to look at (I had some passing contact with AD&D 2e but not enough I consider it relevant): OD&D, D&D3e, and D&D4e, and I'd say a big part of the impact they had in those had to do with special abilities, some of which varied considerably by level. I mean some of it was right out the gate (the breath weapon wasn't so common even at the bottom end it didn't tend to impress people to some extent), but some tended to accumulate or at least get enough stronger
relative to the PCs at higher levels to have psychological impact.
Totally agreed on monster counts. It's a bad pattern if piles of more than usual monsters --- each complex --- is what the game expects the GM to do to make an interesting or challenging encounter. Compare with the brilliance of 4e minions, or mob rules (both of which are low complexity).
Yeah, I found that was a big part of what slowed some of my later 13A higher level games. Sometimes even including mooks if they happened to have any special abilities with heavier handling. Its not probably a coincidence that some of the higher handling cases (among other things) got buffed down in 13A 2e.
On this, I'm merely reacting to the tone of the thread. Complexity of combat or the epic nature of high level stories are the only common active reasons not to play high level that I think have been identified here (apologies if I missed/over-generalized more), removing burnout and fatigue as passive reasons we don't know the reason behind, as well as removing games fizzling for totally extraneous real life reasons. Since the epic nature reason is totally to taste, and that's fair, what's left for us to address in the game in this thread is complexity.
No, you're generally right in terms of the assumptions at least one and probably more than one poster have made here. I'm just of the opinion that taking that as a given is jumping to conclusions. There can be all kinds of reasons not to stick with a D&D game to high levels, and complexity overload is only one of them, and not self-evidently the most common (to make it clear, it is nt self-evident that's the case, not that its self evident it
isn't).
(To be fair to your combined points, I would criticize the game more for the "just throw more normal monsters into the combat" problem, but I personally think I beat that dead horse already.)
Some people feel the complexity is manageable, others not, but I don't think anyone is denying the complexity exists, so it's maybe simply the most obvious target (of the targets fixable by the game's designers, at least). Maybe the book could say "hey it's fine to start at 10th level if you want" a lot, as a reminder, but that seems like an uninteresting conversation around the raw number of players compared to the game itself.
Well, I wouldn't argue more complexity doesn't impact handling time. But how
much it impacts it can vary considerably, and I've played Pathfinder 2e, Shadow of Demon Lord and 13th Age all the way up to their top ends, and they're all different. As I noted earlier, one of the things it can turn on is
how fast you expect it to play. As I've expressed before, I'm not sure I consider it reasonable to expect a top-end on-par combat to take less than an hour (because I'm not sure I've played a game since OD&D where that was true, but I guess people who are playing max three hour sessions are going to have different expectations than I do).