"Edgerunners II" coming this month

I loved the telegraphed ending, a good tragedy needs exactly that.

In general I think the first season is a bit overrated, I found the pacing a bit weird and choppy sometimes. But it has a big place in my heart and I am very much looking forward this season 2.
It’s one of the few series where I thought they needed more episodes. More time to get to know the crew, see what their regular jobs are like when things aren’t going wrong. More time to see David take over as the leader, and grow into the job. Would make the ending even more… affecting.
 

log in or register to remove this ad

It’s one of the few series where I thought they needed more episodes. More time to get to know the crew, see what their regular jobs are like when things aren’t going wrong. More time to see David take over as the leader, and grow into the job. Would make the ending even more… affecting.
yes I think 12 episodes instead of 10 with day-to-day content of his crew before all naughty word goes down would've been better.
 

A big part of what makes the arc so compelling is that you can see the fall coming. Even earlier on, when the episodes are pumping you up with cool cyberpunk-anime nonsense, lulling you into a false sense of security, there's foreshadowing.
exactly its dramatic tension for a tragedy - its why the biggest theatre plays work why they work. Its not supposed to be a surprise/twist, you are supposed to see it coming and be torn and twisted because you want the good early moments to stay and the doom to stay away.

I call it the "red wedding effect" - people thinking tragedy should always come as big shocking surprises since GoT aired.
 

exactly its dramatic tension for a tragedy - its why the biggest theatre plays work why they work. Its not supposed to be a surprise/twist, you are supposed to see it coming and be torn and twisted because you want the good early moments to stay and the doom to stay away.

I call it the "red wedding effect" - people thinking tragedy should always come as big shocking surprises since GoT aired.
From the very beginning in Edgerunners season 1, episode 1, we see how cyberpsychosis ends.

The Red Wedding worked, not because it came out of nowhere, but because GRRM had already established that this is the kind of world where such a thing could happen. Had we not already seen that, I think it would not have been able to land.
 

The trailer is kind of pretty but I am actually not particularly enthused. It feels like a particularly goofy form of cyberpunk, and not in a good way. Like, I will be happy to be proven wrong, but that is the vibe the trailer gives me.
 

From the very beginning in Edgerunners season 1, episode 1, we see how cyberpsychosis ends.

The Red Wedding worked, not because it came out of nowhere, but because GRRM had already established that this is the kind of world where such a thing could happen. Had we not already seen that, I think it would not have been able to land.
I was already on the edge. "The Red Wedding" pushed me over it and I dropped the show, completely.
 

I was already on the edge. "The Red Wedding" pushed me over it and I dropped the show, completely.
I knew it was coming from the books. As I've gotten older, as more and more time has passed since the last A Song of Ice and Fire book was published, I've increasingly soured on grimdark as a genre. Much of it feels excessive, meanspirited, and misogynistic now. A world can be cruel without the author being cruel.

Anyway, to the matter at hand, I haven't watched Edgerunners 2 yet. Work and all. I did briefly think about setting an alarm late at night last night, but I didn't want my first viewing to be bleary-eyed and sleep-deprived. So I wait until I finish work (while hoping no one spoils anything)...
 

So I finished watching and it was not as goofy as I feared. I felt it was alright, much as I felt the first season was alright, not as great as others obviously do.

I wonder whether this series is really Cyberpunk, the 2020 setting if not the genre. The key technologies from both seasons are basically magic rather than tech. That might be fine for a video game but it works less well in this sort of medium. Like, this would not really be a problem in Shadowrun where there is explicitly magic but the Cyberpunk setting is not Shadowrun.
 

I wonder whether this series is really Cyberpunk, the 2020 setting if not the genre. The key technologies from both seasons are basically magic rather than tech. That might be fine for a video game but it works less well in this sort of medium. Like, this would not really be a problem in Shadowrun where there is explicitly magic but the Cyberpunk setting is not Shadowrun.
This is explicitly in the 2077 portion of the setting (the one in the video game) which is why CD Projekt Red is involved.
 

This is explicitly in the 2077 portion of the setting (the one in the video game) which is why CD Projekt Red is involved.
My post originally got a bit confused because originally I was going to ask whether it was really small-c cyberpunk. But, as I mention, Shadowrun exists. More I mean, like, if you take Star Trek and throw in an Imperial Star Destroyer it is still Star Trek on the label and has most of the trappings of Star Trek but there is something that is distinctly not Star Trek about it, right? The Sandevistan and Capricorn as portrayed in this series just seem to operate outside the concept bounds of our reality. Whereas non-magical cyberpunk has a basis in extrapolating from our reality.
 

Remove ads

Top