Fan discussion of Rings of Power: Back for Season 3 [+]


log in or register to remove this ad


Not a terribly meaningful question: most of Tolkien's published work isn't even "Canon".
I just want to emphasize this, and add that Tolkien rewrote and rethought so much of his legendarium over the decades that it is filled with different versions of stories, concepts, etc.
 

Question on the new trailer? Is any of this canon
Other than the use of the names, it bears essentially no resemblance to Tolkien's writings of the Second Age (and in some cases the Third - Gandalf is about 1,000 years too early). To the extent that the enjoyment from the show is probably inversely proportional to the amount you know about those writings. It's basically extremely lavish fan fiction.

On the topic of the thread, the thing I'm looking forward to with the new season has been mentioned a couple of times: the music really is excellent.
 

Other than the use of the names, it bears essentially no resemblance to Tolkien's writings of the Second Age (and in some cases the Third - Gandalf is about 1,000 years too early). To the extent that the enjoyment from the show is probably inversely proportional to the amount you know about those writings. It's basically extremely lavish fan fiction.
I understand where you're coming from (I think!), and I'm not saying you're "wrong", because people experience things differently and come at things from any possible angle, but I also think it's possible to know a lot about a work and love it deeply but still enjoy any given - even very loose - adaptation of it.

Also, I have this theory that an awful lot of things now are "just" fan fiction. I add the quotation marks because, given where we are in popular culture, I think being dismissive of fan fiction is a mistake.
 

To the extent that the enjoyment from the show is probably inversely proportional to the amount you know about those writings.
This is definitely not true:myself and most of the people I know enjoying the show are extremely well verses in Tolkien's work, while a lot of the criticisms I've seen are from people who clearly only ever war he'd the movies since they consider weird decisions of Jackson to be Canon. Of course, it is not so simple the other direction, either. But being familiar with Tolkien's work is absolutely no barrier to enjoyment of what these creators are laying down

It's basically extremely lavish fan fiction.
images (6).jpeg
 

I know sod all about greater Tolkein world.

Season one. Well trekkies might like it. Don't think anyone else did.

Season 3. Pleasantly surprised enjoyed it. 7/10 maybe wasn't great but expectations were rock bottom going in.
 

Remove ads

Top